Got the case today, here are some pics and a review. My current case is the matte/frosted Peel/Tozo ultra thin, which has a really nice feel and which I've been really happy with.
-My previous experience with clear cases is exclusively with really nice, rock hard polycarbonate that is crystal clear and strong. Never had any type of silicony/TPU-y style case. Peel says this is a stiffer type of TPU that will not yellow. It is stiffer than other TPU style cases I see advertisements for - you wouldn't want to try folding this one in half. Yellowing remains to be seen but looks ok out of the box.
-The fitment is good, button cutouts are acceptable. All I really ask is that the buttons don't rub against the cutouts, and they don't. Sometimes they do on these ultra thin cases - sometimes the cases are good, sometimes they are junk because of the cutouts. This one is good, thankfully.
-It DOES have microdots. I was a little disappointed in this (I understand why they are there with glass backed phones but it seemed maybe Peel had found a way to get away without them), but the dots really are micro - much smaller than I expected and I had to look for them.
-The clarity is not great. Probably partly because of the microdots, and partly because of the material itself. It just isn't crystal clear like a polycarbonate. Honestly, it just looks dirty. It did come with a protective film on the backside of the case which I removed, and I rinsed the case out and rubbed it down good inside and out with a damp lint free cloth, dried it with a dry lint free cloth, and then got it extra dry with a can of compressed air. Still, it just looks not only not crystal clear, but just generally unclean? Looks like it needs a good wipedown inside and out, which is odd. It's probably like 85-90% optically transparent (think of all those screen protectors advertising 99.9% optical clarity, lol - this doesn't have it). I don't want to say it's cloudy, it's just...not very clear.
-The texture is smooth which I like/prefer, but it does have that rubbery feel that it looks like it would have. Most people might like this, but I like it really smooth and slippery in my hand. Not expecting it to get stuck sliding it in and out of pockets or anything like that though. I don't expect it to be durable to withstand scratches like a polycarbonate or the frosted matte ultra thin cases made of PP. It probably will look terrible quite soon.
-Would I buy it again? I'm not sure. I don't hate it, or even dislike it, but the clarity and overall grimy look really takes away from it. I like that ultra thin cases are now finally coming in clear, but it just isn't clear enough yet. I should note here that it is also NOT quite as thin as the non clear models, but close. On the other models the side buttons are flush with the case, on this one they are recessed a bit so I know the case is thicker.
-Overall: 6/10. Would be 9/10 if the clarity were better.
