Photoshop CS2 with Integrated Graphics

thomasp

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Sep 18, 2004
654
1
UK
How well does CS2 run on the Integrated Graphics-equipped intelMacs? Working with a half-decent file size (30Mb+)?

My dad is considering buying a new laptop for location work (photographer), and we're not sure what CS2 will be like on the Integrated-Graphics macs - basically that's one of the things which will swing us either to the MacBook or the MacBook Pro.
 

thomasp

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Sep 18, 2004
654
1
UK
Squareball said:
The issue really is that CS2 on Intel Macs runs under Roestta and not native. So I don't think the graphics are the real speed issue here
We've "played" with CS2 on one of the Intel iMacs in an Apple Store, and it seemed marginally faster than on our Dual 867MHz G4, and about a thousand times faster than PS7 on our 500MHz G3 iBook!
 

Voidness

macrumors 6502a
Aug 2, 2005
847
65
Null
thomasp said:
How well does CS2 run on the Integrated Graphics-equipped intelMacs? Working with a half-decent file size (30Mb+)?

My dad is considering buying a new laptop for location work (photographer), and we're not sure what CS2 will be like on the Integrated-Graphics macs - basically that's one of the things which will swing us either to the MacBook or the MacBook Pro.
Integrated graphics has no affect on performance in Photoshop. Photoshop completely relies on the CPU and RAM for everything it does. This only holds for the current version of Photoshop, this might change in the future.
 

milo

macrumors 604
Sep 23, 2003
6,887
511
Voidness said:
Integrated graphics has no affect on performance in Photoshop. Photoshop completely relies on the CPU and RAM for everything it does. This only holds for the current version of Photoshop, this might change in the future.
Yep. A faster processor helps a little, but the real speed will come from a universal version of the software. Integrated graphics will make zero difference on an app like photoshop.
 

tchorta

macrumors newbie
Jan 28, 2005
22
0
Wyoming
Voidness said:
Integrated graphics has no affect on performance in Photoshop. Photoshop completely relies on the CPU and RAM for everything it does. This only holds for the current version of Photoshop, this might change in the future.

Is this also true for the Dreamweaver and Macromedia's other apps? Thanks
 

thomasp

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Sep 18, 2004
654
1
UK
Voidness said:
Integrated graphics has no affect on performance in Photoshop. Photoshop completely relies on the CPU and RAM for everything it does. This only holds for the current version of Photoshop, this might change in the future.
If Photoshop relies on RAM, then surely a 2GHz MacBook would run Photoshop "worse" than a 2GHz MacBook Pro (assuming all performance related things are equal, aside from the graphics), both with identical memory, since the integrated graphics removes at least 85Mb RAM from use by the OS? So, with 512Mb RAM, that means that only 427Mb is available for the OS and Photoshop.


I believe Adobe say that you should have at least three times the RAM as the image size you are working with, so at least 90Mb for a 30Mb file, and 270Mb if you're working with three 30Mb files (not uncommon - in fact, a regular occurance). When dealing with the file sizes that pro photographers do, every kilobyte of RAM is useful ;)
 

Voidness

macrumors 6502a
Aug 2, 2005
847
65
Null
tchorta said:
Is this also true for the Dreamweaver and Macromedia's other apps? Thanks
Yes, they're all CPU dependent, the GPU has no affect on performance in those apps. On the other hand, some of Apple's own apps are affected by the graphics card, such as Aperture, Motion, Final Cut Pro, and others.
 

tchorta

macrumors newbie
Jan 28, 2005
22
0
Wyoming
Voidness said:
Yes, they're all CPU dependent, the GPU has no affect on performance in those apps. On the other hand, some of Apple's own apps are affected by the graphics card, such as Aperture, Motion, Final Cut Pro, and others.

Thanks so much for the info! :D
 

giganten

macrumors 6502a
Jan 23, 2006
602
0
So Photoshop and Dreamweaver will work great on integrated graphics.
But how will cad program like solidworks in bootcamp run on the integrated graphics.