I just received the replacement back and it was the correct one, same as in the ebay picture. He told me to keep the first one (all brushed) and then sent this one. I don't know why all the mix-ups, I'm guessing he ran out of them or is running low on them and waiting to see if people even say anything about getting the wrong item. But I've ordered a few things from him now and he has always responded to my ?'s quickly and been very good with shipping and customer service.