Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Oh I totally agree with the sentiment, but my question is how much of a credit is it really if no one's going to notice it? I guess if the people involved feel like they're getting recognition though, the credits serve that purpose.
The credits also serve as documentation such that if anyone ever needs to return to a film to investigate some details about the people involved in the film, they can go to the film itself. It's like metadata, in a sense. So yeah, keep the credits.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VulchR
Not the point of credits is it.
If this becomes even more standard, credits will soon play over the entire movie.

Credit where credit’s due no more.
There was nothing preventing people from walking out of the theater once the movie wraps up (as many people do) and this is basically the digital equivalent.
 
And WTF do we need to know the driving team lead? Does this really make any difference to anyone?
I may not need to know who was the driving team lead, but I do find it interesting to learn that there *was* a driving team. I don't always read the credits, but when I do, I usually find interesting glimpses into what was involved in the making of the movie/show.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ivantheipodder
There was nothing preventing people from walking out of the theater once the movie wraps up (as many people do) and this is basically the digital equivalent.
I always wait between the possibility of extra scenes and letting crowds dissipate.
 
Might not work for moview with more to watch after the credits. I've seen some with bloopers, additional parts of the plot, etc...
Works well with Marvel movies that have mid-credit scenes, Plex said in their testing it did anyway. I have not tested that myself.
 
I esp. dig them when the end credits song is something that compliments the episode! (dark, moody, bright, majestic, etc.)
Spiderman No Way Home. And it's from Schoolhouse Rock! Was watching the new SR with the few live action skits. They were singing the 3 song, and I realized it.
 
I was sitting through the credits of The Glass Onions the other night just because I couldn't be bothered to turn the TV off and go to bed, and I was wondering what the point of them really was? I certainly wasn't thinking it was interesting to know who the hairdresser to the second assistant grip dolly boy in the Greece location was. I imagine the only people who actually read credits are the people who are in them (I know I would). But in terms of providing recognition or credit - by who?

So I guess you’ve never bought a programme at a theatre? Read the information tags beside works in a gallery? Stayed for the bows at the end of an musical/opera/ballet? Read the inlay card of a CD/record?

Because whilst those will often have additional descriptive information, one of their main purposes is to explain what went into creating the work, and credit those involved.
 
There was nothing preventing people from walking out of the theater once the movie wraps up (as many people do) and this is basically the digital equivalent.
Honestly I think it is rude of people to walk out before the credits are finished. Besides, sometimes there are little entertaining snippets embedded in the credits or at the end. The Wall Street bull floating through space in the credits of Don't Look Up was pure comedic genius.
 
Honestly I think it is rude of people to walk out before the credits are finished. Besides, sometimes there are little entertaining snippets embedded in the credits or at the end. The Wall Street bull floating through space in the credits of Don't Look Up was pure comedic genius.
I agree, but I’m just saying this kind of feature will hardly change movies like some think it will. The people who wanted to skip credits always had the option to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VulchR
Honestly I think it is rude of people to walk out before the credits are finished. Besides, sometimes there are little entertaining snippets embedded in the credits or at the end. The Wall Street bull floating through space in the credits of Don't Look Up was pure comedic genius.
I don't mind at a movie, but it's absolutely rude to walk out on theater when real paople are there.

EDIT: But I can sometimes still understand why, especially with places with inadequate exits. State Theater in Easton is horrid with ONE exit. Reading Arena holds way more people, and we were outside within like two minutes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VulchR
I completely ignore credits now in films, even after working in the industry for a long while myself. I don't get why they exist anymore. Your resume and online listings matter more for getting gigs now. In the older days all the credits were at the beginning of films and some "auteurs" still do this today, for a reason.
Why do films have credits and not say, paintings? Who built the frame? Who designed it? Who painted it? Who hung it up? What delivery company delievered it? Who restored that painting? Who maintains it? Who dusts it each night? Who's in charge of security? Imagine a big list hung up next to each painting in a museum with this info. Oh we'll get whose "collection" it's from or on loan, or on "permanent" loan from but that's about it.

Movies should just end with an imdb link and the movies website url displayed for 60secs and move on. Just have that clickable on netflix and appletv and whatever from the remote.
Actually, if you get the exhibition programme (which most bigger shows have) it often will have those sorts of details.

A difference though, is those people may just be full time employees of the gallery. Whereas for a film they’re employed one-off for that project. I don’t know if that should make a difference… just pointing it out.

But in theatre/opera/ballet etc, all the crew will often be credited.
 
Streaming services can't incorporate only unique, new features only, can they? Who cares if Netflix did it. It's in Plex now.

Yep. Reminds me of "Android/Windows had this x years ago" comments. I'm always like, "So...you'd rather them never implement the feature than implement it 'late'?" LOL! I don't get their point other than just to criticize for the sake of criticizing.
 
I may not need to know who was the driving team lead, but I do find it interesting to learn that there *was* a driving team.
You never thought that there was a driving team moving the actors and other crew members around? OK. Now that you know about driving teams, is there some reason you can't look in the IMDb now? Why must we have the massive scrolls of stuff? Why not view a "making of" documentary to find out all the teams involved in making a movie?

Most importantly, do you realize there are all sorts of teams involved in making a movie that still are not listed in the credits?

What about all the movies from earlier -- films that never listed such non-creative support staff in the credits? Are you lacking in curiosity about those films?

What about actors that don't get credited for roles in the credits? What's up with that? Is it a "creative" decision for someone to exclude them? You can see uncredited roles all over the IMDb.

What about extras? Why don't we include them? Extras are people, too?

What about the people who made and maintain the roads on the route that the transportation team lead chose for his team? What about the maintainers of the roads, and the traffic cops that patrolled them. What about the people who fueled those vehicles -- with whatever kind of fuel they used? Where do you draw the line with your curiosity? Your inclusiveness is rather shallow.

I don't always read the credits, but when I do, I usually find interesting glimpses into what was involved in the making of the movie/show.
😆 That's a good one! But I am wondering why you didn't give a nod to the Dos Equis advertising creative team... and the transportation crew that ferried TMIMiTW to all of his most interesting commercials. Stay thirsty, my friend!

220px-Jonathan_Goldsmith_2009.jpg

 
You never thought that there was a driving team moving the actors and other crew members around? OK. Now that you know about driving teams, is there some reason you can't look in the IMDb now? Why must we have the massive scrolls of stuff? Why not view a "making of" documentary to find out all the teams involved in making a movie?

Most importantly, do you realize there are all sorts of teams involved in making a movie that still are not listed in the credits?

What about all the movies from earlier -- films that never listed such non-creative support staff in the credits? Are you lacking in curiosity about those films?

What about actors that don't get credited for roles in the credits? What's up with that? Is it a "creative" decision for someone to exclude them? You can see uncredited roles all over the IMDb.

What about extras? Why don't we include them? Extras are people, too?

What about the people who made and maintain the roads on the route that the transportation team lead chose for his team? What about the maintainers of the roads, and the traffic cops that patrolled them. What about the people who fueled those vehicles -- with whatever kind of fuel they used? Where do you draw the line with your curiosity? Your inclusiveness is rather shallow.


😆 That's a good one! But I am wondering why you didn't give a nod to the Dos Equis advertising creative team... and the transportation crew that ferried TMIMiTW to all of his most interesting commercials. Stay thirsty, my friend!

220px-Jonathan_Goldsmith_2009.jpg

Well, I'm just a casual viewer, to whom it wouldn't occur to look things up in the IMDB. I mean, there are people who don't even know about IMDB! End credits are an opportunity to list at least some of the people who contributed to the making of the movie/show. You are right that it's not a complete list, I suspect if you did try to list everyone, including all the extras, end credits could get very very long, maybe even longer than a short tv show. But you seem to be suggesting that if the end credits can't be complete, they shouldn't be there at all, and I disagree with that. It's presence reminds viewers that many people contributed to the making of the show/movie, and if my curiosity is engaged by something that I see there, I may even look them up further through other sources, like you suggest.

Maybe some day end credits would come to be seen as obsolete and people who want to know about who did what to make the movie/show would just be expected to look it up on the internet. After all, very old movies have credits at the beginning of the movie, and you had to sit through them BEFORE seeing the movie! So conventions can and will change. Attaching credits to movies/shows is a convention that developed before there was any Internet, so maybe it does make sense that as Internet access spreads, studios could just include a link people could click to look up the credits instead of having it scroll at the end. I don't think we are quite there yet, where the Internet is ubiquitous enough that there is no need for end credits at all. There are still many people watching in ways that don't involve the Internet. So to reach them, end credits are still needed.

and I have no idea what you are referencing with the Dos Equis. You lost me there!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.