Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

What do you think of Safari 4's tabs?

  • Hate it

    Votes: 42 37.8%
  • Prefer this new way

    Votes: 45 40.5%
  • I don't care

    Votes: 24 21.6%

  • Total voters
    111
I prefer tabs on top but with apple's implementation as it currently stands they have had to change a lot of functionality and to be honest I feel it a good start but just that. Needs reworking.
 
Moving and bringing windows to the front is a hassle with the new style.
 
top or below is not a problem, just need to improve the implementation.
 
I like it on the top, however the dragging tabs is a pain, the close button is on the wrong side? and sometimes when you want to drag the window you open a tab etc.

I love safari 4, except i HATE THE LOADING BAR!
 
I like it on the top, however the dragging tabs is a pain, the close button is on the wrong side? and sometimes when you want to drag the window you open a tab etc.

agreed, targeted clicking should NOT be required more and more, its the backward development.
 
I don't mind it but I hate the implementation. It breaks a few fundamental design rules of osx, draggable area is too small, too difficult to drag a link to the right area of the plus symbol and it just looks plain sloppy. Google has a far better implementation and I can't even stand chrome. Another thing that surprised me is that even though safari is faster, they still have not decreased the memory footprint. Btw where are my iTunes scrollbars!

You can tell they'll do the same thing with the finder when all is said and done. I just hope they perfect the interface by the time snow leopard is released.

The best description so far is on daring fireball. Gruber nailed it right on the head.
 
With a few tweaks to it, I'd prefer it so I didn't vote as hate is too strong a word.

It needs the tweaks listed above but I also think the active tab should be highlighted in some way (coloring the frame perhaps).
 
Am I the only one who doesn't use tabs? Don't get the point, never used them on any OS, and particularly don't get the point on an OS with a feature like Expose.
 
When i downloaded the beta, I used new tabs for an hour then gave up and went back to old style.
After a couple of days I switched back to new, since then I haven't gone back to old again. It's just a matter of getting used to it.

Was just gonna ask how to drag tabs but I just noticed the little thing in the top right of each tab to do it.
 
I love them on top, but it'd be ridiculously awesome if Apple added an option (or if somebody made an addon) that removes the close/move buttons on tabs and instead lets you middle-click to close and middle-drag to move.
 
I love them on top, but it'd be ridiculously awesome if Apple added an option (or if somebody made an addon) that removes the close/move buttons on tabs and instead lets you middle-click to close and middle-drag to move.

Glims achieves this - to an extent. Favicons replace the close icons and middle-click close is an option.

Why not write to the authors to suggest the other things. Those guys are very receptive to input.
 
What is the point of tabs in general, especially that tabs do not work with Expose?
 
Bleh, I hate the new tabs. Fortunately, I'm using the old tabs and toolbar in safari thanks to Terminal :p
 
All you have to do is put a few codes in terminal. I did, and its looks exactly like Safari 3.

I really don't care though.
 
You don't find it easier to look at the tabs and click on the one you want without using Expose? :confused:

Actually, no, I do not. I use a dedicated mouse button for Expose and all I need to do to switch windows in Safari is to the button and move the mouse ever so slightly.

Maybe it is just me, but I find Expose and Command-~ to be the two most useful means of switching between Safari windows. Neither of these works for switching between tabs, where you actually have to move the mouse all the way to the top of the screen, which is much less convenient for me...
 
I prefer tabs under the address bar. And what happened to the loading bar? And I haven't installed it on Mac but I've tried it in Windows XP.
 
I prefer the on the bottom.

Besides the "looks cool" part, I can't think of any practical reason to have the tabs on the top. All it does is make the tabs farther away when you want to click on them.
 
Well, we don't know what the final version will look like. I would prefer if Apple included an option to have the tabs on top or at the bottom.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.