Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

San Francisco or Helvetica Neue?


  • Total voters
    113

vertsix

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Aug 12, 2015
1,949
7,103
Texas
Curious as to opinions on San Francisco.

I was obsessed with it for a while.

But I thought Helvetica Neue is a lot more stylish, simple, efficient, and less obstrusive after a while.

What do you guys think?
 
Last edited:
San Francisco has grown on me completely. Going back to Helvetica feels almost as weird as going back to Veranda from Helvetica.
 
SF was really weird in the beginning, but I've gotten used to it.

Helv is a better font in general but SF looks better on the UI.

But most rich text content on Safari, text in some apps and in the App Store is mostly Helvetica. It's a little inconsistent if you ask me.

Nevertheless, San Francisco is still a pretty good font.
 
Reading is far better on
Helvetica Neue

But for UI,
San Francisco looks better.

I say both are good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vertsix
San Francisco is definitely better. Helvetica Neue was always just a bad interims solution for the iOS 7 redesign.

Although, as a typographer who worked close to industrial designers at university, i wasn’t really surprised Jony Ives Team chose Helvetica, because most Industrial Designers know only a handful of fonts and default to Helvetica because it looks reasonably timeless and neutral to them. It’s really reassuring about Apples design team that they took the multiyear-path of developing their own modern font-family fit for the purpose. I think Erik Spiekermann really did have a little influence on Jony Ive to get SF ready and into the system so soon. Besides the fact that it would have been really hard to get Helvetica Neue working on the Apple watch at small, glanceable font sizes.
 
San Francisco is definitely better. Helvetica Neue was always just a bad interims solution for the iOS 7 redesign.

Although, as a typographer who worked close to industrial designers at university, i wasn’t really surprised Jony Ives Team chose Helvetica, because most Industrial Designers know only a handful of fonts and default to Helvetica because it looks reasonably timeless and neutral to them. It’s really reassuring about Apples design team that they took the multiyear-path of developing their own modern font-family fit for the purpose. I think Erik Spiekermann really did have a little influence on Jony Ive to get SF ready and into the system so soon. Besides the fact that it would have been really hard to get Helvetica Neue working on the Apple watch at small, glanceable font sizes.

Even SF Compact (Watch) and SF (OS X/iOS) are noticeably different. When you change Helvetica that much so that it works well on smaller screens, you are changing the character of the typeface itself. Helvetica was never meant to be a multipurpose UI typeface. It’s been misused, just like Verdana is (which really shines at small sizes).
 
Even SF Compact (Watch) and SF (OS X/iOS) are noticeably different. When you change Helvetica that much so that it works well on smaller screens, you are changing the character of the typeface itself. Helvetica was never meant to be a multipurpose UI typeface. It’s been misused, just like Verdana is (which really shines at small sizes).
Exactly. Good fonts have lots of different cuts (not sure if this is the correct english translation) for different purposes. Apple did a very good job with the different sizes of SF, instead of just scaling the glyphs.
 
I voted for San Francisco, but I really think both are just fine.

San Francisco looks just different enough to freshen up the interface and make it a bit more readable. It's really a gorgeous experience, the numbers look sharp too.
 
Helvetica, however I understand why SF is getting more votes. It's the novelty atm so people aren't tired of it.
 
Helvetica Neue has more class, style, refinement. However, for reading definitely San Francisco because is more spaced between each letter. But lacks of some design, class. The € symbol in San Francisco looks weird.
 
Curious as to opinions on San Francisco.

I was obsessed with it for a while.

But I thought Helvetica Neue is a lot more stylish, simple, efficient, and less obstrusive after a while.

What do you guys think?

I have the same opinion about the previous font. This one may be easier to read as there is more space in between letters, but the previous is way more stylish. I think it's a matter of time anyway. It's not a Comis Sans :-D
 
When it comes down to it: ease of reading > stylishness. Especially on such small devices.

And frankly, I believe that Apple has created a font that encompasses both.
 
I don't like how "blocky" SF looks compared to Helvetica. It doesn't look horrible but they could have made some subtle changes to make it look more distinct from Roboto
 
I don't like how "blocky" SF looks compared to Helvetica. It doesn't look horrible but they could have made some subtle changes to make it look more distinct from Roboto

Helvetica is just better for reading content I suppose.
 
I like it visually and it is also one of the most intelligently designed fonts ever for digital rendering. Take a look at the 2015 WWDC talk "Introducing the new system font".

2015-09-23 15_43_06-804_introducing_the_new_system_fonts.pdf - Adobe Acrobat Reader DC.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: LordQ
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.