Okay so I tried it...
Needless to say it didn't work...I actually ran into a bunch of problems.
I used the TSS server in tinyumbrella. That worked like a charm, I was able to downgrade to the custom firmware after entering DFU.
Problem: I can't exit out of DFU after install. I used tinyumbrella's "Fix Recovery" thing, but all that does is kick it to a white screen which does nothing.
So then I tried to restore to a stock 4.3.1. That didn't work either. Gave me a 1013 error.
So then I just tried a straight up restore. That worked, restored my phone to 4.3.2.
Any pointers on what went wrong?
Thanks guys.