I'd always been an ardent Commuter user, but recently wanted something smaller (more form-fitting). For the last few weeks, I've been using the same Foliage-colored Magpul Field Case that map1978 posted earlier. BY FAR, it's been my favorite case!
Then, I remembered that I had the Incipio NGP stashed away that I'd never really used. So, I popped it on there tonight and I'm really liking it. I love that you can still see the band through the case.
My only concern is that over time, the piece of material below the home button will become saggy. I know we've got a lot of NGP users here...anyone experienced that?
Anyway...pictures (that's what we all like, right?)
(And yes, that's a black 4S with a white back. I started a thread a while back on it, if you're interested).