Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

cosrocket

Suspended
Original poster
Jul 7, 2008
141
9
Amazon is less expensive and I do not need Apple to set it up for me and I would be purchasing the base model with no upgrades, so I'm interested only if there is a problem if one has better service over the other.

Thanks.
 
Amazon is less expensive and I do not need Apple to set it up for me and I would be purchasing the base model with no upgrades, so I'm interested only if there is a problem if one has better service over the other.

Thanks.
Get it from Amazon if you can - but if you buy it in store you can take it home without waiting for any type of delivery. Amazon do good discounts on Macintosh hardware. :)
 
Get it from Apple with student discount.

That is $200 off right away without even checking your student status.
 
Amazon is less expensive and I do not need Apple to set it up for me and I would be purchasing the base model with no upgrades, so I'm interested only if there is a problem if one has better service over the other.

Thanks.
It really does not matter.
I've bough from Amazon, B&H Photo and MacMall and all were good buying experiences. I bought my MBPr from MacMall and had no issues.

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/searc...N=4110474292+4291615352+4100277621+4294949014

http://www.macmall.com/n/Macbook-Pro-Retina-Display/macNavLinks-753
 
Last I checked, Amazon is good if you don't qualify for education pricing. If you do, Apple is cheaper by $0.99. Given that Apple services the warranty, purchase wherever benefits you the best, whether that's due to store loyalty, rewards, gift cards, sale price, etc.
 
I've been buying machines from Amazon for quite a bit of time and I love the process, nothing beats being able to not pay tax and the prime shipping.
 
Amazon is fine. Your warranty is through Apple and it starts on your purchase date, just like buying from Apple.
 
I've been buying machines from Amazon for quite a bit of time and I love the process, nothing beats being able to not pay tax and the prime shipping.

I miss the tax-free purchasing from Amazon, though given state use tax guidelines you are just having to pay it later anyway. Ever since mid-September California purchases are now charged sales tax, so saves some trouble come tax season and avoid having to fill out the use tax declaration.

I'm pretty sure they do check your student status nowadays.

No they don't, at least not in my experience. One method I used to use while I was working at my university was to purchase on-campus, as they were automatically inventoried in the bookstore's system with the edu discounted price. So, anyone could come in and purchase theoretically as they never asked for a student ID# or anything. Those days are over, as starting last year they no longer "stock" inventory and instead have an iMac hooked up that you can order from "in-store" and have it shipped to you.
 
I'm pretty sure they do check your student status nowadays.

Not that I'm encouraging fraud, but I recently purchased with an education discount through the website (which I am legitimately entitled to) and they did not confirm nor ask for my .edu email address online or when I picked up the machine.

But, when I've purchased in person they have made me log onto my .edu email address or provide a university ID card with a graduation date.
 
Amazon doesn't yet charge sales tax for Florida so I patiently waited earlier this month for Amazon to get the base model back in stock and went for it just about 4 weeks ago. I love Amazon. I use Prime and paid the extra $8 on a Friday to get it delivered the next day--Saturday. And with Amazon you do have 30 days to send it back--my 30 days expires next week but so far, there is no way they are getting this baby back. :)
 
Amazon doesn't yet charge sales tax for Florida so I patiently waited earlier this month for Amazon to get the base model back in stock and went for it just about 4 weeks ago. I love Amazon. I use Prime and paid the extra $8 on a Friday to get it delivered the next day--Saturday. And with Amazon you do have 30 days to send it back--my 30 days expires next week but so far, there is no way they are getting this baby back. :)

But you know that when you pay your taxes, legally you have to pay tax on that purchase, right? I know a lot of people like to think that it's tax-free shopping, but really it's not...
 
^^
Legally true although most Floridians do not file any state forms and so far, Florida has not aggressively pursued compliance. My guess it that eventually Amazon will have to start collecting sales tax, just a matter of time.
 
But you know that when you pay your taxes, legally you have to pay tax on that purchase, right? I know a lot of people like to think that it's tax-free shopping, but really it's not...

For me it ends up being as my current permanent address is in Europe and I'm not american, I travel to the U.S almost every week though which makes the Amazon option perfect as I avoid paying taxes for a state that gives me nothing in return (ie: my kids don't go to school there), not that it really matters as we are looking to help the OP, just some insight.
 
For me it ends up being as my current permanent address is in Europe and I'm not american, I travel to the U.S almost every week though which makes the Amazon option perfect as I avoid paying taxes for a state that gives me nothing in return (ie: my kids don't go to school there), not that it really matters as we are looking to help the OP, just some insight.

In your particular case, that makes a lot of sense. :) For those of us that live in the U.S., technically you're supposed to pay taxes on all internet purchases when you file your taxes in April, if tax wasn't collected at the time of purchase.
 
But you know that when you pay your taxes, legally you have to pay tax on that purchase, right? I know a lot of people like to think that it's tax-free shopping, but really it's not...

Many don't know this (others do their taxes for them); or just choose to ignore the requirement. Those that look for an out on paying state sales taxes then complain about cuts in the services THEY want funded....

^^
Legally true although most Floridians do not file any state forms and so far, Florida has not aggressively pursued compliance. My guess it that eventually Amazon will have to start collecting sales tax, just a matter of time.

And this will be a boon to brick and mortar stores in Florida and other states that DO compete quite well on price - but loose out because people walk out over paying sales taxes. :(

For me it ends up being as my current permanent address is in Europe and I'm not american, I travel to the U.S almost every week though which makes the Amazon option perfect as I avoid paying taxes for a state that gives me nothing in return (ie: my kids don't go to school there), not that it really matters as we are looking to help the OP, just some insight.

But the state does give things in return - roads, public transit, public safety, libraries, wifi access - all things that I have enjoyed in my travels in the US and overseas.

Please forgive us in the US for sales taxes on hotel rooms and rental cars that seem to fund stadiums and such that should have been funded by those that actually own the teams and businesses...
 
I miss the tax-free purchasing from Amazon, though given state use tax guidelines you are just having to pay it later anyway. Ever since mid-September California purchases are now charged sales tax, so saves some trouble come tax season and avoid having to fill out the use tax declaration.



No they don't, at least not in my experience. One method I used to use while I was working at my university was to purchase on-campus, as they were automatically inventoried in the bookstore's system with the edu discounted price. So, anyone could come in and purchase theoretically as they never asked for a student ID# or anything. Those days are over, as starting last year they no longer "stock" inventory and instead have an iMac hooked up that you can order from "in-store" and have it shipped to you.

Well when I bought my MacBook Pro in 2009 I didn't need to provide any identification when I purchased from the online store. However I have heard from others that they have had to provide ID when purchasing since then.
 
I got mine at Best Buy because of the financing and silver status member benefits :)
 
But, when I've purchased in person they have made me log onto my .edu email address or provide a university ID card with a graduation date.

Interesting. Wonder how they handle a case like mine where I qualify due to the fact that i'm the parent of (multiple) higher education students. I sure don't have their EDU logins nor their ID's.
 
Interesting. Wonder how they handle a case like mine where I qualify due to the fact that i'm the parent of (multiple) higher education students. I sure don't have their EDU logins nor their ID's.

You don't qualify for an education discount, but your children do per the Apple Store policy:

Those eligible to purchase from the Apple Store for Education Individuals include faculty, staff, students and parents as follows:

Higher Education Parents - Parents purchasing on behalf of their child, who is a student currently attending or accepted into a public or private Higher Education Institution in the United States, are eligible to purchase.
 
You don't qualify for an education discount, but your children do per the Apple Store policy:

Ok, I've bought 4 Macbook Pros and 2 iPads for my college attending kids, seems to me that I've had purchases that were eligible. Your point is? *I* qualify when buying for my kids, as your quote so clearly states.

Now that that's clear you want to answer how they handle that? I've NEVER been asked for their ID's
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.