So my mother, who is very technologically challenged, managed to get her iPhone 4 broken. A speaker blew out or something, and it could only makes calls on speaker phone. I'm pretty sure she took it to an AT&T store, not an apple store, and they tried to convince her to use it on speaker all the time and just upgrade in a year when her contract allowed, even though the phone was still under warranty. Obviously, this wasn't acceptable, so she managed to convince the clerk to give her a replacement for the $49 fee. My question is, should she have received an equal iPhone 4 16GB? Because the clerk gave her an 8GB, even though it was under warranty and she paid the fee.