I just got my switcheasy capsule rebel tiger in the mail today and put my shiny new iphone 3gs in it today. I compared it to my roommates incase slider. Heres the good and the bad:
Good:
-Looks really slick
-solid case
-looks like it can take a hit and keep going
-got it for 20 out the door on ebay brand new (price is good)
Bad
-doesnt have the friction that a silicon-like case might have...Im worried this thing will come out of my hands!
-I see a bit of chrome on the top and bottom right - not engineered to perfection
-bottom part of case does flex (the "sagging" that everybody talks about...doesnt happen now but I guess could in future)
-start button is harder to press because of the case.
-need to use straight headphone jacks.
Neutral
-some people say the screen protector is good...even on some guru youtube reviewers videos...are you friggin kidding me, they suck
b@lls...no...they g@rgle balls.
-microfiber is the size of tinkerbell's maxi pad. Its tiny.
So, heres the scoop. I did a LOT of research on cases (below $50) and the two I came up with were the Switcheasy capsule rebel and the incase slider (hard case). I chose the switcheasy because of the good reviews on ilounge and because it looks cool. I admit I dont want my phone to look the same as everybody else's and although there are a few colors out for Incase, its mostly black and white...but the yellow and black of the Capsule Rebel it certainly stands out.
I dont want to spend 40 bux on a damn piece of plastic but I think the incase slider has that much better traction/rubbery/nonslip feel to it, which is important to me. I hear about the scratching but...hmmm maybe they just didnt clean their iphones properly before hand!?
Switcheasy Capsule Rebel
looks wise> A
Feel> c+
price point> A (if you buy on ebay!)
Durability> B+
fit on iphone> B-
Incase Slider
Looks> c+
Feel>A
Price point> C+
Durability> Pass (cannot give grade on it)
fit on Iphone> A