Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I guess that depends on the user. For me anyway I could see LR5 (6) being good enough for me for 5 years before I felt the a newer version was compelling and useful enough to upgrade. Many others may prefer to update every time a new version is released but I'm sure many people don't need or want to. Even in your example of upgrading every two years (which is plenty) it's still cheaper than the subscription model. Where does this $5-$6 a month come from? Can you choose to rent LR on it's own for less than $10?

Whether your frequency of payments is a few dollars every month or a few hundred dollars every few years, you're still investing money over time in software. It really comes down to how often you want those payments to be, and how much you want them to be.

In your case, you might spend $140 every 5 years. That's probably on the extreme low end, but certainly not unreasonable. It's equivalent to putting a couple bucks every month towards your software. If Lightroom was offered on a subscription for $2/month, you'd be just as well off either way (probably better because you'd be getting the benefits of access to the latest release over that period).

We don't know what the monthly cost of Adobe Lightroom is, because it's bundled with Photoshop, but we do know that keeping current with a perpetual license costs $140 initially plus $99 every couple of years for what amounts to the equivalent of $5-$6/month (over 5+ years). Now, if you value Photoshop as much as Lightroom, their $10/month plan is a good deal. If not, then it's not a good deal.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.