Hope this is the right forum to post this. I have a hard drive from my dead G5 that I'd like to use. It's the stock Western Digital that came with the G5. (250 mb) I tested it in another machine, and the drive is just fine. I bought an enclosure at Best Buy. First I bought a 2.5 by mistake. Returned that, got a 3.5 and the drive fit perfectly. Except the enclosure was defective (the usb connection was loose and flaky). This one: http://tinyurl.com/yjhhnwn So I returned that and ordered this one from Wal Mart (half the price): http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=10363723 It arrived, and my hard drive won't fit. There are screws around my hard drive, and it might fit if those screws weren't there, but I don't know anything about removing screws from an internal HD. So now, I need to make a FOURTH try on this crazy enclosure. Can anyone tell me the difference (besides price and maybe quality) between those two enclosures? Did I miss something? Both are SATA 3.5 and I can't understand why my HD wouldn't fit the Coolmax. And can anyone recommend an enclosure that's on the cheap side? This isn't going to be used that often, so I don't need a Mercedes. Also, I'd like to be able to buy/order from a store that has local return, given my bad luck so far. That basically means Best Buy, Target, Wal Mart, Kmart...if I start ordering from online sources and keep getting duds, the shipping is gonna eat me up. Thank you.