Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

beatledud

macrumors 6502
Original poster
May 4, 2006
269
0
Ok, so I just got my MBP 2.33 15" back from apple. The warranty runs out tomorrow, and I hope if there's a problem they'll fix what they were suppose to fix.

What was wrong:
1. 'Smudge Like Spot' screen problem. RESULT: Replaced screen, not the casing though (it happened once before and they replaced the whole thing).
2. Superdrive couldn't write and sped up and slowed down a lot and took about 50x longer to install software. RESULT: Replaced superdrive.
3. 3rd bad Battery (and I mean bad, not just heavily used). Last time they replaced my power adapter. Replaced Bad Battery, Power Adapter was fine. Asked them to check the motherboard for something else. RESULT: Mother Board was replaced, but reason stated was video card problems. However, the Hard Drive wasn't formated with a fresh OS like they normally do.

What my Concern is:
Ok, the Superdrive just isn't right. First I insert a disk and it's makes the usual loading sound but with sharp loud clicks/snaps. Then as it spins up it makes sounds like a bad Hard Drive, but its most certainly coming from the SuperDrive. Then it takes 40 seconds to load a disc onto the desktop, seems a bit long. And more awful squeaking sounds like a dying Hard Drive.

I've got a link to a recording I made of it using my iPhone. Can anyone hear anything of concern? The sharp clicking as I insert the Disc isn't overdramatized, it sounds like it's snapping the disc as it goes in. And there's some weird click or tap through out afterwards, but that wasn't the drive, you can distinctively hear the weird wick-wick-wick sound as the drive spins:
http://public.me.com/andrewroberts
 
Well at this point I think it would be a good idea to purchase AppleCare. Generally I think that if one thing goes wrong, there's a strong chance that something else could as well.

With the SuperDrive, I think you should take it back or call up AppleCare and explain the situation that the repair you previously had might have affected another component.
 
NO, The point is that the machine that "just works" without any headaches should "just work" instead of fail. I'd take a plastic machine that lasts me 5-6 yrs than a "omg so sexy and luxury car like" machine that will break down in a yr.
If you've ha problems from day 1, i suggest you buy warranty. I've had excellent luck with squaretrade when my maytag dryer broke down.
 
Let me clarify, my 3 year apple care is running out. No more extra warranty.
 
If your AppleCare is going to run out, I'd take it back to the Apple Store (if applicable) and show them the problem. If not applicable, call up AppleCare and speak to CS as the agent will probably take it as a separate problem.
 
I just left the Apple store and they fixed replaced the screen for a lady who was 3 days out of warranty.

But don't talk to us; go to Apple!
 
I believe that the warranty gets extended to a minimum of 90 days after a repair. Re-check your warranty status.
 
I think it's very important to have AppleCare.
You really never know what will happen to your computer tomorrow or the day after, so if you really think about it, it would be much cheaper to buy AppleCare and know that you're secure, rather than have your computer break and have to get another one.

Lets face it, on your own, you can't really do much with a laptop if it breaks.

So.. if I were you, I would get AppleCare NOW.

If you still can of course.
 
I think it's very important to have AppleCare.
You really never know what will happen to your computer tomorrow or the day after, so if you really think about it, it would be much cheaper to buy AppleCare and know that you're secure, rather than have your computer break and have to get another one.

Lets face it, on your own, you can't really do much with a laptop if it breaks.

So.. if I were you, I would get AppleCare NOW.

If you still can of course.

Read much?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.