I noticed that too. Some people like to post a lot and sometimes they don't realize what they're responding to.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Quick Takes: Audiophile Calls AirPods Best Truly Wireless Earbuds He's Ever Heard in Year-Later Review
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I have been enjoying my BT Bowers & Wilkins PX over the ear headphones out in public. But for ease of use I can see where BT earbuds have an advantage
Attachments
Last edited:
I haven't tried airpods, so I can't say first hand what the sound quality is but I've heard from people who have used them that they are essentially the same (or slightly better) as the Apple wired headphones that are included free with iPhones.
If that is true, then I'd have to disagree that they are the best overall. I've always replaced the included Apple headphones with much better sounding models. I only use Apple headphones as a back up.
Ease of connection is great but if the sound quality is subpar what's the point? I'd rather have a great sounding pair of truly wireless headphones that take an extra minute to set up initially and then automatically connect after that.
If that is true, then I'd have to disagree that they are the best overall. I've always replaced the included Apple headphones with much better sounding models. I only use Apple headphones as a back up.
Ease of connection is great but if the sound quality is subpar what's the point? I'd rather have a great sounding pair of truly wireless headphones that take an extra minute to set up initially and then automatically connect after that.
I agree with you, but I think the fact that they are slippery is one of the things that allows me to wear them for hours and hours without discomfort. I’ve never been able to do that with other earbuds.
I'm not a wine aficionado by any means, but if you can't tell red wine from red-dyed white wine by taste (and not sight), then there isn't much else to say.
Hard to take the word of any "journalist" that dismisses a product before reviewing. Reviewing is their job. So now this clown finally gets around to trying them out and whoa! he likes them. Don't get me wrong, I love my AirPods. My criticism here is this guy. His word has zero credence here based on his behavior. At this point he is merely parroting everyone else. It's like he knows he made a mistake and is now trying to paper over it.
I think a lot of you are missing the point by not reading carefully enough. He didn't say they were audiophile quality. He also didn't say they were better than all other earbuds.
He said that he, as an audiophile, believes they are the best (not audiophile quality) sounding completely wireless earbuds on the market. Based upon the number of people I see using them on a daily basis, and the fact that I have them along with others, I have to agree. They aren't audiophile quality. However, they still sound better than other TRUE WIRELESS (that's the key) earbuds on the market. Admittedly I haven't tried the new Bang and Olufson true wireless, so they may have some magic going on in them that make them sound better.
I know we all live in different areas, but if you walk around downtown Boston on any given afternoon, of the people with earbuds in their ears, a good 70-80% of them have AirPods in their ears.
He said that he, as an audiophile, believes they are the best (not audiophile quality) sounding completely wireless earbuds on the market. Based upon the number of people I see using them on a daily basis, and the fact that I have them along with others, I have to agree. They aren't audiophile quality. However, they still sound better than other TRUE WIRELESS (that's the key) earbuds on the market. Admittedly I haven't tried the new Bang and Olufson true wireless, so they may have some magic going on in them that make them sound better.
I know we all live in different areas, but if you walk around downtown Boston on any given afternoon, of the people with earbuds in their ears, a good 70-80% of them have AirPods in their ears.
Airpods: I am a waiting for them to make them cool... fashion cool. Heard so many good things about them, but people really look like as*&^%es (can I say that here without being banned?) - no, really, yes you do... and I am so tempted to buy them, but then I remember how that guy in the train looked like and I don't.
I think you should go back and watch the EarPods (the wired version) intro keynote. Apple specifically designed these to fit in the average ear testing against hundreds of ear shapes and this was the most universal shape they found, carried to the AirPods.
As for foam, Apple explicitly stated they designed this shape specifically NOT to seal (otherwise the bass stem wouldn’t work as intended).
I don’t t remember what year the EarPods were released but if you can find the video it’s a fun 10 minutes down memory lane.
First paragraph from The Verge review:
This is why I hate The Verge so much. They hate on everything Apple before they even try it out; it's instinctual for them. The only thing that surprises me here is that the author came out and admitted it so freely.
This is why I hate The Verge so much. They hate on everything Apple before they even try it out; it's instinctual for them. The only thing that surprises me here is that the author came out and admitted it so freely.
I'm just an average Joe and even I can tell the sound sucks on the AirPods. I got mine at launch because everyone said they sounded like the standard EarPods but hell no! I loved the multiple charges you get with the case and W1 pairing. But the sound coming out of them were just unbearable to where the point where it just sounded like noise. I had to return them.
Fast forward 1yr later and I'm on a Note 8 with the Samsung IconX 2018 and WOW! These things are awesome! The sound and fit is SOO much better than AirPods and I get all of the controls through touch. Sure I wish the case had more charges but these poop all over AirPods. Don't sleep on the IconX 2018 guys. You will also look like less of a tool bag wearing these compared to AirPods.
Anyway, this "reviewer" don't know a damn thang.
Fast forward 1yr later and I'm on a Note 8 with the Samsung IconX 2018 and WOW! These things are awesome! The sound and fit is SOO much better than AirPods and I get all of the controls through touch. Sure I wish the case had more charges but these poop all over AirPods. Don't sleep on the IconX 2018 guys. You will also look like less of a tool bag wearing these compared to AirPods.
Anyway, this "reviewer" don't know a damn thang.
I don’t see the disagreement. As far as I could tell, the person merely stated that one only thinks AirPods are overpriced if one hasn’t seen the competition.
Having tried the AirPods they provide decent audio quality, have an amazing range with my iPhone 10 and are pretty darn comfortable to wear overall, being light weight and wireless. I prefer the sound isolation of my CIEMs but I'd have possibly bought the AirPods for their sheer convenience and ease of use was I in the market for a pair.
Yeah, this seems a lot worse on Mac than on iOS. Unfortunate if you want to use AirPods for gaming. Lucky Macs got decent mics built in.
[doublepost=1521573196][/doublepost]
Those would look greasy and disgusting in no time. Most people's ears are not a clean place, even if they wash them daily.
Yeah they’ll have to drop pretty lucratively for schools to want them, and IF ios can actually get school friendly. multiple log ins, etc. Right now I doubt any school wants to fork over not just for the ipad, but a $100 stylus and $140+ keyboard cover.
Me I’m just wishing anything message/photo related and the share sheet weren’t 15 second waits and lag fests, iOS 12 can’t come soon enough. They really need to tighten stuff up.
And yet I see more people wearing them around me every day.
Seems more a limitation on the user’s part than the product’s.
Being that all video is synced to compensate for latency, that is a clear placebo or you are not using the system video player. Please report back if you are not seeing this YouTube video in sync and what browser / OS you are using, because we all are getting perfect sync.
I think it would still not solve a thing as some people, like me, like the earphones ''naked'', some people have allergies, some people do not like a rubber or foam feeling in the ear, the slight pressure when the foam is adjusting to their ear.
Apple could make some ''tips'' to put on earphones.
But some people prefer silicon, some rubber, some foam tips, ...
Some people want closed earphones, some like to know what is happening around them.
If Apple, or some other company would create those ''tips'' for AirPods, and maybe there are some already, I think it would be good enough.
About the quality of Airpods.
They are decent. Most self proclaimed audiophiles would not recognize in a true blind test (not knowing the shape)
I listen to Tipper a lot. Tracks like Scapula (very bass demanding track) and Ambergris (very clarity demanding), sound great on airpods.
The thing is that any true audiophile would avoid a ''portable player experience'' by miles.
Why? Standalone components are dedicated devices to sound superior. Same as a DSLR is just for photography.
Crack a wine bottle open, get some Vriend Kaas, sit on a comfy sofa and make than symphony orchestra truly fill your room.
I love my Sennheiser cans, but even if It was possible, I would no longer want to connect them to my Apple Watch to go for a walk.
[doublepost=1521597542][/doublepost]
You mean, not having a cable on earphones, makes it look bad?
You see, the bloke who used them is ''memorable'' to you. Was he wearing skirt and long orange socks and Airpods? Come on, Think about it, earphones, in general, look bad
These once just don’t have a cable.
The wireless earbuds, which are connected together with a wire, look like some very low budged necklace
The magical thing, with the people on this forum, is, that people complain about Apple's ''form over function'' and then they say that airpods are ugly. They are amazing tech (minus the volume up and down missing)
[doublepost=1521598228][/doublepost]
These feet were made for charging
Hiding the tech for you
For taking out of your ears
And that's what those feet were made to do
there, low budget Nancy Sinatra song just for you
Optional detachable nubs are fine
I have a rubber allergies
Last edited:
Apple Pay on the UTA transit system is DELIGHTFUL. I hope it rolls out to more cities/services just to benefit the people that use it.
My one complaint is that if you use a proprietary UTA tap-to-pay card you get a slight discount, but no discount for the tap-to-pay Apple Watch or iPhone.
My one complaint is that if you use a proprietary UTA tap-to-pay card you get a slight discount, but no discount for the tap-to-pay Apple Watch or iPhone.
That's the point of the study. Experts can not. And you likely would not be able to either given a true blind taste test.
You, along with all the experts, only think you can.