Anyone else caught this? If I try to open a MIDI file in QTX, it tells me I need to launch QT7. Why would Apple release a half-complete version of QTX?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Quicktime X Lacks MIDI Support
- Thread starter Papajohn56
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
QuickTime should start supporting more formats, not fewer!
What a strange omission. You would think QuickTime is extensible enough that they could include a MIDI component in the latest release. It's not like a MIDI wavetable eats up a ton of space.
They're really working backwards from where they should be going; I use VLC almost exclusively for video playback because QuickTime has such weak format support, where VLC can play just about anything. Heck, my original Xbox running an old version of XBMC can play far more formats than QuickTime!
Fortunately, I had QuickTime 7 installed because I always install any "old" software whenever Apple makes it available as an optional component. Otherwise you're left without vital tools like Rosetta and older Mac OS X (10.3/10.4) development targets in Xcode.
What a strange omission. You would think QuickTime is extensible enough that they could include a MIDI component in the latest release. It's not like a MIDI wavetable eats up a ton of space.
They're really working backwards from where they should be going; I use VLC almost exclusively for video playback because QuickTime has such weak format support, where VLC can play just about anything. Heck, my original Xbox running an old version of XBMC can play far more formats than QuickTime!
Fortunately, I had QuickTime 7 installed because I always install any "old" software whenever Apple makes it available as an optional component. Otherwise you're left without vital tools like Rosetta and older Mac OS X (10.3/10.4) development targets in Xcode.
Isn't it supposed to just default to QT7 for whatever it needs that the new Quicktime doesn't have yet? Or am I misunderstanding how QTKit works? I mean, QTX Player has no problems with Ogg after installing XiphQT, for instance.
*sigh* Quicktime X just isn't done yet. It seems they just got a few central features bug-free, and shoved the rest for 10.7.
*sigh* Quicktime X just isn't done yet. It seems they just got a few central features bug-free, and shoved the rest for 10.7.
if you want a technical explanation, ars has a very good one.
Quicktime X is really a ground-up rewrite, and in order to have full support for the feature list that you come to expect, they made a quicktime 7 bridge. I'd suspect 10.7 will have more if not all of the rest of the support natively in quicktime X.
Quicktime X is really a ground-up rewrite, and in order to have full support for the feature list that you come to expect, they made a quicktime 7 bridge. I'd suspect 10.7 will have more if not all of the rest of the support natively in quicktime X.
You have to keep in mind that QuickTime X has still not been released for Windows, and iTunes among other applications still use QuickTime 7 to playback content.
Clearly, we're in a transitional period. Apple is giving up something like 18 years of API development with the move to QTKit/QuickTime X.
I would expect updates to QuickTime at WWDC. I don't believe Apple's done with it. The current version is more like a beta than anything else.
Clearly, we're in a transitional period. Apple is giving up something like 18 years of API development with the move to QTKit/QuickTime X.
I would expect updates to QuickTime at WWDC. I don't believe Apple's done with it. The current version is more like a beta than anything else.
If you want to get midi support back in Quicktime Go to http://apple.com/feedback and complain and keep complaining. Apple discontinued midi support in Mountain Lion. They don't listen to the forums, they do listen to feedback. Keep at them until they fix it.
