Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ataboc

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Nov 27, 2007
285
3
Ca
Howdy, I've got a late 2012 11" MBA. To date, I've had two SSDs fail. The OEM :apple: drive and now an OWC SSD.

Are failures of this rate typical?

Never had a problem with an OZ SSD nor my 27' iMac.
 
I wouldn't call them typical overall, but there have been a few notable mess ups. Like the 128GB drives on the 2012 MBA models, that apparently had lousy firmware that caused premature failure of many of them.

The problems that are cropping aren't so much with the SSD technology itself, but with things like the support hardware and firmware that have bugs, or software that isn't quite optimized to handle SSD storage, which MUST be treated a bit differently from traditional hard drives.

Hard drives aren't perfect either though.Ask anyone who's bought Western Digital drives recently, or the Seagate 1.5TB drives back in 2008, or ask an IT person about the reputation of Hitachi "DeathStar" drives.

Meanwhile, we've been using a cheaper, slightly slower form of SSD for years and haven't really paid much attention to it. It's in our smartphones and tablets.
 
Was your OEM drive covered by Apple?

Sadly no. One month past the 12 month warranty. I almost always buy apple care on ebay before the window closes. I waited too long!

Did you have trim enabled on the owc?

I couldn't say. But if it needs to be enabled than probably not.

I wouldn't call them typical overall, but there have been a few notable mess ups. Like the 128GB drives on the 2012 MBA models, that apparently had lousy firmware that caused premature failure of many of them.

The problems that are cropping aren't so much with the SSD technology itself, but with things like the support hardware and firmware that have bugs, or software that isn't quite optimized to handle SSD storage, which MUST be treated a bit differently from traditional hard drives.

Hard drives aren't perfect either though.Ask anyone who's bought Western Digital drives recently, or the Seagate 1.5TB drives back in 2008, or ask an IT person about the reputation of Hitachi "DeathStar" drives.

Meanwhile, we've been using a cheaper, slightly slower form of SSD for years and haven't really paid much attention to it. It's in our smartphones and tablets.

Ahh. Well, that does answer my question a bit that others have had problems with that year... I've used SSDs since 2008 and have had no problems until this MBA. Thank god for being able to boot off an external!
 
It should be covered if it was one of the faulty drives

http://www.apple.com/support/macbookair-flashdrive/

The problem is that i no longer have the original drive. I called :apple: and I now have a genius bar appt but I'm rather certain that they'll turn me away due to the fact that there's no drive installed in the computer. I just RMAed the OWC drive back to them for testing and hopefully replacement.

No fault of Apple's because I understand their position, but it sure would be nice to have standard 3 year applecare.
 
Last edited:
You're wasting your time if you go there with a machine with no drive when the issue you are going there for is a defective SSD (that you no longer have). They aren't going to do anything for you. To get you a replacement drive you need to turn in the broken one.
 
You're wasting your time if you go there with a machine with no drive when the issue you are going there for is a defective SSD (that you no longer have). They aren't going to do anything for you. To get you a replacement drive you need to turn in the broken one.

Yeah, shoulda kept the drive. :p

Yep. Should have kept it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.