Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

LCC0256

macrumors member
Original poster
Dec 5, 2017
63
31
Martinez, GA. USA
After much research I decided on Cisdem Video Converter for the software for ripping my DVD and Bluray collections. (about 300 total) I have 2 Macs (iMac running El Capitan and MBP running High Sierra) I chose this software over the free Handbrake and other software for sale because of the simplicity and ease of use. I was not disappointed. So far I have ripped 40 DVD's with 4 clicks of the pad and the results are perfect. (a click to start the program a click to drag the DVD to the program's screen, a click to choose the output file type and a click to start ripping!! - (if you want to edit and perform special effects those are intuitive and user friendly with the simple layout and obviously require a few more clicks)

There were 2 issues that cropped up and here is where this company showed me I had made the correct choice (for me)

The first issue was there were a couple of my DVD's that would not rip. They were not damaged - they simply would not rip and an error message was generated. (That I sent to Apple) I emailed the company and less than 16 hours later I had a response indicating the issue had been investigated, they had found the cause and were working on an update to correct the problem. Statistically this represented 5% of my library that I was having an issue with. I was amazed at this response. The second issue was a mistake I HAD MADE when purchasing the license(s) I was under the impression that a separate license was required for each of my Mac's. Upon further investigation the license is good for 5 Mac's in my home. After inquiring about this issue I had a refund on the way in less than 24 hours. These people remember what customer SERVICE really means.

Lastly I have had good success with handbrake and VLC ripping home movies - but it was a total PITA. And this was several years ago prior to my OS updates. Handbrake does not seem to play nicely with El Capitan or High Sierra (at least for me)

I am using iTunes as my platform to stream my rips and the movies I have downloaded from Apple to my 5 Apple TV's around the house. It is working perfectly. My issue now is going to be what to do when storage becomes an issue. And of course it will. My Macs have only 1/2 TB SSD's each. (1 TB total) I use iTunes to stream my music and videos & AirPort Extreme as my router and my home is wired completely with CAT 6 cable with 2 (8 port) Netgear gigabit switches so all ethernet capable devices are hard wired . I am unsure of how to proceed with respect to a NAS. But as for my software choice for ripping my DVD/Bluray library I hit a home run. Hope this helps others out there who are not experts with this either.
 
Sometime clever folks can put some effective GUI on standard utilities and make it easier of accomplish something. I just use the service (script) that someone over in the appleTV forum published. Its one drag/drop and done, no clicking....

I have my iTunes library stored on a 5TB drive attached to the Mac itune host. No need for a NAS. Unless you spend big bucks, they are way slow for HD streams, almost OK for home movies.
 
I had a big DVD library and have ripped almost all of it into iTunes over the past few years - a total of about 1200 files, all ripped with Handbrake. Out of all those, maybe 12 would not rip and the free trials of several commercial rippers didn't work either. I just bought iTunes versions of the movies I actually wanted and moved on.

Handbrake seems really easy to me, I can't think of any reason why I'd buy a commercial product. Now I have not ripped any BluRay disks though, so maybe that's a different ballgame.
 
I had a big DVD library and have ripped almost all of it into iTunes over the past few years - a total of about 1200 files, all ripped with Handbrake. Out of all those, maybe 12 would not rip and the free trials of several commercial rippers didn't work either. I just bought iTunes versions of the movies I actually wanted and moved on.

Handbrake seems really easy to me, I can't think of any reason why I'd buy a commercial product. Now I have not ripped any BluRay disks though, so maybe that's a different ballgame.

Will you please tell me what operating system(s) you were using with handbrake? I assume some of those were copy protected movies? I have El Capitan and High Sierra. Thank you
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.