Hey guys! I’ve been having this same issue on my Apple TV for the past few weeks, and I just figured it out! My original issue looked exactly like
@-Gonzo- first screenshot, but when I clicked on it, it did not specify what I needed to adjust/fix, as it did for him in his second screenshot.
But this is what I did and hopefully it can help some of you guys too! So beginning of the year, I had to get a new phone, and the iPhone 14 pro max works much differently with Apple TV than previous phones did (and I imagine other Apple devices as well). Apparently when I upgraded my new phone, it signed me out of Apple TV, then prompting me to sign in again- only now, I realized that, when it did that, it automatically added my Apple ID to *Additional Users*, instead of as the Default User. To get there, it is under Settings > Users and Accounts (which is where the red circled 1 ⭕ was). Thus, there was no Default User. I tried add myself as the Default, but since I was already listed as an additional user, it would not allow it.
SO…
The only thing left for me to do was to click on
Users and Accounts > Additional Users, then > sign out of my Apple ID under all three… being:
> iCloud, > then Store, > and lastly Game Center, where it will tell you that by signing out, you will effectively be removing your Apple ID from Apple TV > click OK. Give it a second.
Then I went back up to Default User, and I entered my Apple ID password when prompted. The iPhone 14 pretty much does everything for you at that point, just by holding it near the Apple TV, so some of you will have to make sure to add your Apple ID and password to the store, iCloud and Game Center, if you use them all… My phone automatically signs me into all of them.
Next, click Menu/Back (going back into general Settings for Apple TV) > then click System > click Restart. Apple TV will restart, so give it a second. And then when it came back on for me, everything was all good again and set up correctly, WITHOUT the red circled 1! Yay!

And when you’re set up, you’ll be able to click on Default User, and look at the items on the list there, and make adjustments, if you wish, which you’re not able to do, if your account is merely an *Additional User*.
Ok, well, I so do hope this reaches some of you guys who are having the Apple TV issue, like I was… Perhaps even our original poster, here,
@MacBookpro2011 
Apologies this is lengthy and if I didn’t frame this the correct way. I’m not a techie person and have never posted about this kinda thing before (or anything publicly until this)- mostly because I’ve never been the one with any answers, ha! But I always really appreciate all of you who make the effort to help everyone else with troubleshooting like this. I’m usually one of the people putting your solutions to the test, lol- I just figured I’d try to give back a tiny bit for once, since I saw how recently some of you posted about this. So if any of you guys are [still] having this issue, fingers crossed this will do the trick! 🤞🏻 Best of luck and Happy New Year to all! 🍀🎉🙃