Is there anything you have to do to make the new remote work? I had to set up the Apple TV with the old remote. I can't get the new one to work at all.
Believe it or not, they must have shipped the remote completely dead. I really wasn't expecting that. I plugged it in and kept it close to the ATV and it eventually worked. If I didn't have the old Apple TV remote I don't know how I would have figured that out