You’re correct. I meant to say the 13 Pro. The 13 Pro is the same weight (204 grams) but 1 mm thinner than the 17 Pro. I still have that phone and even that feels much chunkier after handling the Air.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone Air Returned the Air ... wanted to keep it.
- Thread starter danpass
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I agree with you, the 17 Pro is definitely easier to grip/hold and navigate the screen because it's not as wide as the Air. But overall I think it's just too heavy imo.
The Air really has disturbed the status quo this year with its new form factor. Causing lots of emotions and people head scratching over which device to get lol
The Air’s got a big hold on our hearts!
This is an excellent point. I think it’s a balance of weight, size, and reach for me. I feel like the iPhones aren’t very ergonomic for me as I have had wrist and thumb issues ever since Apple released iPhones with Face ID. I type using my thumbs and get soreness from my thumbs that runs down to my wrist.
When I use my iPhone SE (3rd gen) or my Pixel 6 Pro I don’t get any of these issues, I feel relief and more comfort.
When Apple announced the Air I was excited and thought this was the answer for me. With the Air being thinner, it is easier to use one handed but two handed typing is more difficult and less comfortable for me. Adding a case has helped a little bit though. But by adding a case it has caused my Air to feel warm/hot when I’m doing anything on the phone which is also uncomfortable.
I held the Pro in the Apple Store and because of the rounded edges, it felt much more comfortable to hold but I couldn’t really get a feel for how heavy it is for longer use. I tried the 17 but felt the edges weren’t as comfortable in my hands as the Pro.
With all of this being said I’m thinking about moving from the Air to the Pro. I am hoping the smaller size with the rounded edges will be more comfortable to hold even with the added weight.
Ooooh, I would be all over that. I hung on to my 16PM because of the camera as well.... And I have zero interest in a foldable
I'm also returning the Air mainly because it unexpectedly just feels too big and isn't as comfortable to hold as my 16 Pro I find even with the thinness and weight. Now I'm wondering whether to get the 17 Pro, or if the 16 Pro I have is a good middle ground. I'm interested by how the 17 Pros seem comfortable to hold with the new aluminum design, no sharp sides.
I do sometimes miss my 15 Pro I had for two weeks, light and small.
I do sometimes miss my 15 Pro I had for two weeks, light and small.
Do you use a case? Rounded edges on the 17 series definitely helps if going caseless.
I don't most of the time no, so that's a plus for me.
I'm not strictly against a case but I wonder especially on the 17 Pro how much a case could impede the benefit of the thermals covering the aluminum.
That's what I did. Wanted the Air, went to the store, experienced the in my opinion annoying sound when in landscape, had doubt about the wide angle lens and ended up ordering a 17 PRO in blue. Thought it was a bit expensive but hey, why not treat yourself to the best. Then the carrier came with a delivery date end of October. Now waiting for a regular 17 in black waiting to arrive at the end of the week 😇
I can't imagine it would have a major impact. Never seen any testing done on it before.
Keyboard is not an issue, I use 2 hands when I type.
I have small female hands and short stubby fingers. My thumb only goes like 2/3 of the screen’s width when trying to reach straight across never mind the corners. The large size makes it feel unbalanced in my hand when doing simple things like swipe to unlock or scrolling.
I tried using a MagSafe PopSocket with the Air but that wasn’t particularly comfortable either.
Had the 17 pro Max in a case for a week, and never never got hot with the case on, not like the 16 Pro Max. The Air is better than the 16 but gets a little warmer in the case.
I'm another former Air user that went to the 17 Pro. I love, love, love the Air for what it is--lightweight, thin and just a well made piece of kit. Battery life was fine for me. Speaker was clearly not great, but it was a non-issue, as I rarely use it. The cameras though--I thought I could get by for a year with just the one camera. Then I had a family gathering this weekend where I took a lot of pics, and it was then that I realized I had goofed. That ultra wide lens is just something I'm not willing to go a year without. For what it is, the Air camera is fantastic. And if all you ever had was a phone with a single lens, you would be over the moon with the Air. But it's hard to take something away and then act like it doesn't matter.
I've been a Pro Max guy since forever, but the slightly increased weight and girth of the 17PM kinda put me off this year. I got to toy around with my wife's 17 Pro some over the past week and really came to love the smaller but weighty form factor. One hand use is nice to have again, and while the Air did provide that, it was still somewhat of a stretch to make it happen.
When Apple brings the Air cameras up to par with the Pros, I'll 100% be back. That form factor is the future and I can't wait to have a svelte phone again. I already miss the Air, but the 17 Pro is just fine for my needs.
I've been a Pro Max guy since forever, but the slightly increased weight and girth of the 17PM kinda put me off this year. I got to toy around with my wife's 17 Pro some over the past week and really came to love the smaller but weighty form factor. One hand use is nice to have again, and while the Air did provide that, it was still somewhat of a stretch to make it happen.
When Apple brings the Air cameras up to par with the Pros, I'll 100% be back. That form factor is the future and I can't wait to have a svelte phone again. I already miss the Air, but the 17 Pro is just fine for my needs.
Having both the 17 Pro & Air in my possession, the lighter Air definitely feels more premium in the hand IMO.
i agree , pro does feel premium but the Air is on another level
Material > Weight when it comes to premium "feel"
That said, I want both. I want a heavy titanium phone.
The threads and YT videos of 17 Pro picture samples is giving me pause ...
Damn that Air for not having a wide angle lol
-
Will never happen, you can’t cheat physics. It will never be on par with the Pro phones…
There is no middle of the road anymore. No matter what your pick, it ticks others off. No wonder the world is the way it is.
This is why I decided to hold off on the Air. I use my wide angle enough on shots that I would miss if I didn’t have them. Every other facet of the Air was great for me. I am hoping next year they add an ultra wide and I’ll be all in.