Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Every keyboard should light like the MacBook keyboards do. Since Apple doesnt want to cannibalize sales by adding that to their own keyboards, can every single Apple keyboard maker add it instead? Not everyone wants to be in a well lit room using their computer at home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: singhs.apps
OK, neither is really a deal-breaker - but its annoying on a premium-priced keyboard and after pushing USB-C so heavily on Macs since 2016.
Fair point. It doesn't rise past maybe a 2/10 on the annoyance scale to me, but I get it. It feels like they have a zillion Magic Keyboards and mice in the pipeline and for whatever reason haven't gotten around to changing ports. They managed to change over some stuff like Apple TV remotes and AirPods cases, but Mac accessories are further down the list ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Either way, I'm gonna have a lightning cable or adapter kicking around for quite a few years anyway just due to older gear I continue to use. (I've got stuff around that uses micro USB, which is truly the cockroach of charge connectors.)
 
Why, oh why, must they all have batteries and be wireless?
For what it's worth, you can use the Magic Keyboard over a wired connection. (In fact, even if you want to use it wirelessly, connecting briefly with a cable is the quickest and easiest way to pair with a different Mac without futzing with bluetooth settings at all.)

What I don't know is whether a Magic Keyboard with a totally dead battery will still function plugged in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DocMultimedia
Wouldn’t people in a budget look for a keyboard for less that $50?
Especially when you can buy a keyboard with mechanical key switches in that price range these days, thanks to the Gateron clone switches. A low profile keyboard with mechanical switches costs more, true, but, if I’m gonna shelp around an external keyboard (which, in fact, I do), I want one that provides a better typing experience than low profile membrane chicklet keyboards like this one (I currently use a Happy Hacking Keyboard with silent switches [because of the office], and Topre has grown on me, though I’ll still take a Cherry Blue keyboard given the chance).

The rise of the cheap but pretty decent mechanical key switches has been a major game changer in the keyboard market. Basically, decent mechanical switches are available at every price point now, when they used to be reserved for the $150+ USD market.
 
You lose - I've got a universal remote with a MiniUSB connector. Not sure if they were better or worse than MicroUSB...
If I remember correctly, I have three or four items lying around that use MiniUSB, most of which tend to be early-to-mid-2000s designs that haven’t gotten a refresh in that time. They’re more frustrating than devices using USB-C mostly because I have to find the appropriate cable if I want to use them. And good luck charging them.

I’ve still got a couple of devices that exclusively charge via microUSB and Lightning (but more that charge via Lightning than microUSB). The place where things really get annoying is work, where we have monitors with a USB C cable sticking out of them and thin clients with one USB C and two USB A ports. I use both USB A ports for external keyboard and mouse, but thankfully, I have a USB C to Lightning cable in my bag for when I need to charge my AirPods Max.

At home, I’ve got two USB C cables for use as charger cables and one Lightning. Maybe I should consider adding a long microUSB cable to the mix, but the only thing I’ve got that charges via MicroUSB that I keep near my seat is a headphone amp that I only occasionally use. I’m honestly looking more to replace microUSB than Lightning, since I’ve got fewer devices that charge via it.
 
If I remember correctly, I have three or four items lying around that use MiniUSB, most of which tend to be early-to-mid-2000s designs that haven’t gotten a refresh in that time. They’re more frustrating than devices using USB-C mostly because I have to find the appropriate cable if I want to use them. And good luck charging them.

I’ve still got a couple of devices that exclusively charge via microUSB and Lightning (but more that charge via Lightning than microUSB). The place where things really get annoying is work, where we have monitors with a USB C cable sticking out of them and thin clients with one USB C and two USB A ports. I use both USB A ports for external keyboard and mouse, but thankfully, I have a USB C to Lightning cable in my bag for when I need to charge my AirPods Max.

At home, I’ve got two USB C cables for use as charger cables and one Lightning. Maybe I should consider adding a long microUSB cable to the mix, but the only thing I’ve got that charges via MicroUSB that I keep near my seat is a headphone amp that I only occasionally use. I’m honestly looking more to replace microUSB than Lightning, since I’ve got fewer devices that charge via it.
I have exactly two things with MiniUSB: a Yeti mic and a high-end Japanese mechanical keyboard. They're both great pieces of gear and working perfectly. For MicroUSB, I have an e-reader, a bluetooth speaker and a couple other little oddball things that are still working fine.

So yeah, when something charges over Lightning, honestly it's like "welcome to the party". I'm gonna be dealing with multiple cables for some time to come, so whatever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kc9hzn
I'm still having issues finding new RS 232 cables. My computer is a bit old.

Stuff guy with dozens of SCSI cables laying around says.

Me.
:) ....and if one keeps buying stuff with anything but USB C connectors a similar scenario will remain for the longivety of ownerships. I find it a tad annoying that "future leaning Apple", that`s at least what they propagate, contributes to this both on the pherperial side and on Mac Mini/Studios. My MacBook Pro passed recently - will be replaced by a Mini, and those still have USB A and HDMI. Which means I still will have to use HDMI for my monitor to keep a USB C connector free as one will be allocated back-up.

There is a need for a cut-off at one stage no matter what, way overdue in my opinion. Apple aren´t shy replacing standards, and letting USB A / Lightning stay makes this stuff drag on and on and on.
 
My MacBook Pro passed recently - will be replaced by a Mini, and those still have USB A and HDMI. Which means I still will have to use HDMI for my monitor to keep a USB C connector free as one will be allocated back-up.
The problem there is that its only HDMI 2.0 and doesn't support 5k or higher frame rates - if you're only connecting 4k@60Hz that's a non issue, and if the M3 Mini shows up it will probably have HDMI 2.1. HDMI is still a very current standard for connecting displays - it's certainly not "obsolete" or "legacy".

Also, bear in mind that you haven't been robbed of a third/fourth TB/USB-C port by those USB-A and HDMI ports: the M1/M2/M3 SoCs only have two TB/USB 3.2g2/USB4 controllers (4 on the Pro and Max). My guess is that the USB-As (limited to 3.1g1) come from spare I/O lines from the SoC (probably used for internal peripherals on the laptops) and the HDMI from an internal DP-only port that would have been used for the internal display on laptops.

My pet peeve with USB-C is its use as the only port on desktops and full-sized laptops with room for multiple ports - on a phone, tablet, super-portable laptop or small peripheral you pretty much need to have a single connector that does everything - via dongles/docks if necessary, but on a desktop/larger laptop there's plenty of space to keep power, I/O and display separate, avoiding this "if I plug my display into a USB-C I can't plug a SSD into it" dilemma*. In the Intel days these were all independent resources on the logic board so having them share a single port introduced an unnecessary bottleneck. With Apple Silicon, unfortunately, that bottleneck seems to have been baked into the CPU somewhat.

Apple seems to have got this back-to-front: they pushed USB-C/TB3 as the only port on laptops where it caused problems until USB-C became more widespread, and then dragged there feet adding it to phones and small peripherals where it actually solved a problem (MicroUSB was rubbish, Lightning was proprietary and reaching its limits).

I don't think Apple are switching to USB-C because of the EU - they're just a bogeyman to blame for having to buy a new clock radio stand - they'd have needed a "Lightning 2" by now. Lightning only has two data lanes - it can't even do USB 3.0 without an active dongle (presumably because USB 3 needs a 3rd lane for USB 2 compatibility) and USB4, TB3/4 and full DisplayPort need 4 lanes (plus the 'slow lane' for USB 2 fallback). Maybe they could have produced a compatible Lightning 2 by making the plug truly 16 pin (its only 8 pins replicated on both sides) but that may have had mechanical issues because the "tongue" of the plug is the load-bearing part... plus it wouldn't qualify for Thunderbolt or USB branding. With the iPad Pro and - potentially - future top-end iPhones getting serious computing power, it made sense for those to go to Thunderbolt, at which point USB-C makes sense for the whole iDevice and peripheral range.

* Yes, it's convenient to have a single-cable docking solution for laptops but, for years, I had the horror of using an Apple Cinema Display at work which meant connecting a 3-tailed cable with one Magsafe, one USB, one MiniDP plug and a separate Ethernet cable which must have wasted 3 whole seconds twice a day (oh the humanity!). It also gave me a horrible choice of putting up with two cables on the desk or taking 2 minutes to bind them up neatly.
 
I needed a new keyboard and have used a LOT of them over the years. So I decided to give this one a try. I like the feel of it; it has just enough of a "clicky" response. The only complaint I have is with their proprietary keys, which take up the spaces where function keys used to be, keys I used all the time. So I've had to remap a lot of my keyboard shortcuts. But outside of that, I'm happy with it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.