Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
67,482
37,746


Apple may have a fight on its hands in the 27-inch 5K display space. Recently we've seen a solid budget competitor to the $1,600+ Apple Studio Display arrive on the market with the $799 ASUS ProArt 5K Display, and now here we have the BenQ PD2730S, part of the company's Designer Series that promises "always accurate and consistent colors."

benq-pd2730s-studio-display.jpg

Price-wise, this monitor sits $400 either side of the Apple and ASUS offerings at $1,200. As you'd expect, it packs more features than the cheaper ASUS display. For a start, it's Thunderbolt 4. But the extra capabilities don't end there. I've spent several weeks with it, putting it through its paces alongside an Apple Studio Display. So how did it fare?

Key Display Specifications

  • Panel Type: 27-inch IPS with Nano Matte coating
  • Resolution: 5120 x 2880 (5K)
  • Brightness: 400 nits peak
  • Contrast Ratio: 2000:1 (IPS Black technology)
  • Color Gamut: 98% P3, 100% sRGB
  • Refresh Rate: 60Hz
  • Response Time: 5ms (GtG)
  • HDR Support: VESA DisplayHDR 400
  • VESA Mount: 100 x 100mm
  • Built-in Speakers: 2x 3W stereo
  • Included Accessories: HotKey Puck G3 wireless controller
Design and Build Quality

benq-pd2730S-8.jpg

First off, the PD2730S doesn't match Apple's all-aluminum aesthetic. Let's be honest, nothing on the market quite does. But BenQ has remained faithful to the same design ethos that was evident in our MA270U 4K monitor review. While it may not be to everyone's taste, it's tried and tested.

benq-pd2730s-x-e1739546575168.jpg

The monitor combines black, white, and silver elements into a cohesive whole. The black bezels remain pleasantly slim, the rear of the display is a white plastic that curves outwards slightly, and the silver stand is a brushed metal pipe about 2.5 inches in diameter. Assembly is extremely simple and requires no tools. You just click the neck of the stand to the back and then use the key-screw to fasten on the rectangular base.

benq-pd2730S-14-e1739545228563.jpg

Once set up, the monitor feels remarkably solid, and the stand deserves special mention - it's a robust piece of engineering that provides great stability. I particularly like how the display panel remains steady even when adjusting its position, something that's surprisingly rare in this price range.

Speaking of adjustments, BenQ hasn't skimped here. The stand offers a comprehensive range of movement: height adjustment up to 150mm, -5° to 20° tilt, and smooth 60° swivel capabilities. This versatility comes as standard - no $400 upgrade required, Apple. For those preferring alternative mounting solutions, there's a standard VESA mount option.

Connectivity and Features

benq-pd2730S-5.jpg

Connectivity is where the PD2730S really shines. The monitor boasts a genuinely useful selection of ports. The Thunderbolt 4 input delivers 90W of power delivery, which is enough for my 14-inch MacBook Pro. You'll also find HDMI 2.1, DisplayPort 1.4, and a downstream Thunderbolt 4 port supporting display daisy-chaining. These ports face outward rather than downward - a small detail that makes a big difference in daily use.

benq-pd2730S-7.jpg

A thoughtful array of USB ports rounds out the package. There's both USB-C (2x) and USB-A (3x) connectivity, making this an effective hub for any desk setup. That said, most of these are located directly under the panel next to a headphone jack and they face downwards, so the dangling cables can look a bit messy if you use them all. On the other hand, BenQ includes a hook that attaches to the stand behind the monitor for funnelling cables through, which is a much more aesthetically pleasing cable management system than the one found on the ASUS ProArt 5K Display.

Another point worth noting is that the hub can provide power even when the display is off, so you can keep your MacBook and whatever else plugged in and charging regardless.

benq-pd2730S-13.jpg

BenQ also includes its unique HotKey Puck G3 controller. This wireless dial provides quick access to display settings and input switching. It's customizable and works well, and creative professionals might appreciate it, but it's not something I've found myself using regularly.

Display Performance

benq-pd2730S-2.jpg

Let's get down to brass tacks: image quality. The IPS panel delivers outstanding clarity. Text on the panel appears razor-sharp, and images pop with vivid detail. With 5120x2880 resolution, you're getting the same pixel density as Apple's Studio Display. And just like the Apple Studio Display, you get 218 pixels per inch, ensuring that sweet spot for 5K Retina.

benq-pd2730S-1.jpg

Likewise, color accuracy impresses right out of the box. The monitor covers 98% of the P3 color gamut, which is crucial for creative work. BenQ's factory calibration proved spot-on as far as I'm concerned, although you can fine-tune things further using the included software tools. Display ColorTalk lets you easily match colors between a MacBook and the monitor or between two monitors – no calibrator needed – while Palette Master Ultimate lets you achieve more precise color matching using a calibrator.

benq-calibration-1.jpeg

The panel employs BenQ's Nano Matte co... Click here to read rest of article

Article Link: Review: BenQ PD2730S 5K Designer Monitor – A Studio Display Alternative That Doesn't Break the Bank
 
Any thoughts on the Dell 40" Ultrawide? It's down to $1499 at several retailers now. I've had BenQ in the past and they've been great but considering the Dell now for screen size.
 
You can usually pick up an Apple Studio Display refurbished for only $150 more than the list price of this BenQ. Better build quality, better speakers, a webcam built in, and most importantly 50% higher max brightness (600 nits vs 400 nits).

I'm glad to see more 5K displays coming out to compete with the ASD, but I wish they were bringing a bit more to the table.
 
Last edited:
Looks like a really good monitor for creative professionals, at last. Aside from not being as bright as the ASD, this would be a slam dunk purchase for someone in the market at this price point. BenQ has a solid reputation among photographers I've spoken with.

It's not as bright and it lacks decent speakers. Speaking only for myself and what the lighting is like where I work, those wouldn't be deal breakers. Plus it's height adjustable and has a matte coating, both of which are extra charges from Apple. Though being matte AND not as bright is a strange combination.

So it could be a solid competitor for the ASD in this space, which is much needed. And at that price, a shopper wouldn't need to wait for the ASD to go on sale.
 
Looks decent, but at $1199 that is only $100 less than what the ASD goes on sale for. Yes it has some features that the ASD doesn't have or include at the base model, but can't match the ASD in other areas. At least the ASUS 27" 5K Display (PA27JCV) is another $400 under that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drrich2
It’s probably 400 nits because another 200 nits escaped out the massive gaps.

The joy of the Apple Studio Display is I don’t have to worry about dust getting into cracks and it is so easy to wipe across the whole front display.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2789.jpeg
    IMG_2789.jpeg
    953.4 KB · Views: 921
Last edited:
Has the ASD gotten better about playing well with PCs? I know that it was a bit kludgy at launch, but perhaps it's a non-issue now. If that's the case I think I'd wait for a $1299 deal on the Apple. Regardless, it's nice to see some 5K competition! Hopefully we'll start seeing some >60Hz versions soon too - I don't think you need to be a hardcore gamer to enjoy a smoother experience.
 
Has the ASD gotten better about playing well with PCs?

Everything works plug and play except the ambient sensor. Brightness/Audio control has to be done with Window utilities if you are using a PC keyboard.

On an Intel PC use the included Thunderbolt cable.

On an AMD PC use a USB 4.0 cable.

You can connect to Nvidia GPUs with a DisplayPort to USB-C cable but then you won’t get audio or data. Nvidia got rid of USB-C on their graphics cards 4 years ago for reasons unknown but probably because they want to support DisplayPort and HDMI only.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: drrich2 and dmr727
Strange how all the competitors use matte displays and don't offer glossy versions.

Almost like a matte coating masks little things like screen uniformity and backlight bleed :rolleyes:
 
  • Sad
Reactions: lostPod
A sale price of $899-999 will make this a more compelling option for those who want/need a 5K monitor, IMO. With the ASD on sale for $1299 regularly I would just wait for the sale and pay the extra $100 for the ASD, but to each their own.

The ASD is a chore to share between 2 or more Macs, that is my only gripe with the thing because it is an excellent display. But these monitors have multiple inputs + KVM unlike the ASD.
 
As one of very few 5K monitors that has a built in KVM (in an already tiny market of 5K monitors), it'd be interesting to hear how quickly it flips to each input. And can it do 3-way KVM (eg. TB4 / HDMI / DP)... presumably so if there's that many inputs?
 
  • Like
Reactions: maruyama
It's very nice to see more options in the 5k space. But if I'm already spending in the $1,200 range why not just go ahead and go for the real deal Apple Studio Display that is guaranteed to be fully compatible in the future with better specs? It's worth the extra cost.

But if a 3rd party display could one-up Apple in some specs then that would get my attention.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.