Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Wow! That pricing! What’s the point?

Most places, picking up a SIM is no more hassle then stopping at a kiosk in the arrivals hall. Takes five minutes and most countries have outstanding travel plans for tourists.

Worse yet is that it seems there is no way to just turn OFF your domestic line, except for Wifi to keep things like iMessage active.

The eSIM implementation seems pretty half baked at this point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: S G
Wow! That pricing! What’s the point?

Most places, picking up a SIM is no more hassle then stopping at a kiosk in the arrivals hall. Takes five minutes and most countries have outstanding travel plans for tourists.

Worse yet is that it seems there is no way to just turn OFF your domestic line, except for Wifi to keep things like iMessage active.

The eSIM implementation seems pretty half baked at this point.
I wouldn't fault this on the eSIM implementation, this vendor is just taking advantage of being early to the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: freezah
Completely useless if I use eSIM for my primary line, especially if it’s T-Mobile where they make it an unnecessary pain to put it there in the first place. I’d rather just get a local physical SIM.
 
Wow what prices you are ready to pay! My subscription is 5 euros/month with unlimited calls+SMS plus 20GB of data.
 
GigSky is great. I’m using it now in France while typing this. Yes, it’s a little expensive but a lot cheaper than Verizons international plan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: catean
Way too expensive even with its convenience. You can get like 40 GB of data for 10 € in France for example and use it all across Europe.

This. I travel to the UK once a year on average. There's a shop in Heathrow as soon as you exit customs. £30-40 (there are cheaper options) for a relatively large amount of data from a variety of local carriers, a local number, and great coverage. Just swap a SIM card (or use an eSIM-supporting carrier) and PAYG. Just remember to use an app (e.g. 1Password) for your 2fa-enabled services instead of SMS, which is arguably more secure (and I think more convenient, at least as implemented by 1P).
 
I’ve never swapped the SIM card. That’s why I like the esim. Do you lose you mobile number if you swap the sim? What if you need your assigned number for work, family, etc?
 
  • Like
Reactions: catean
Gigsky has competiton : Truphone and Ubigi.

The convenience of having your phone number for sms and voice calls and using this worldwide data only services is priceless. It’s the reason why I upgraded from the X to XS.
 
Apple's eSIM functionality seemed great at launch but there weren't a lot of ways to implement it right at launch. This is an example of a company who is early to the game in a significant part of the new iPhones. I enjoyed the review and thought it was more relevant than a lot of other articles where money/products is exchanged with MR.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have Tmobile One and honestly can’t complain as I had coverage all over Europe.

What’s interesting is the coverage is so much better in Europe than back home in SoCal.

Still worth the $80/month for two lines. I switched on hookup promo which was $100 initially and $80 with hookup.
 
I wouldn't fault this on the eSIM implementation, this vendor is just taking advantage of being early to the game.

Maybe we’re talking about different things here. From Juli’s use case (and I’m sure many others), the biggest advantage of eSIM is being able to more simply use another number while traveling, without having to worry about accumulating exorbitant data roaming charges. Without a clear cut way of disabling data roaming, you might as well still have two phones.

I’m still not totally sure what Juli means when she says she was unreachable via iMessage to her domestic line. It still should have worked when she was on WiFi.

I guess at the end of the day, I want to have two numbers that the device can potentially respond to at any time, and I want to selectively use ONE for data. Is that possible?
 
Maybe we’re talking about different things here. From Juli’s use case (and I’m sure many others), the biggest advantage of eSIM is being able to more simply use another number while traveling, without having to worry about accumulating exorbitant data roaming charges. Without a clear cut way of disabling data roaming, you might as well still have two phones.

I’m still not totally sure what Juli means when she says she was unreachable via iMessage to her domestic line. It still should have worked when she was on WiFi.

I guess at the end of the day, I want to have two numbers that the device can potentially respond to at any time, and I want to selectively use ONE for data. Is that possible?

I mean that when I disabled my Verizon number (in Settings, "Turn off this line") in an attempt to make sure I didn't accidentally use any VZW data, my iMessage stopped working entirely. It did not work on WiFi, and I don't know why. I didn't do further testing on this because I was in a foreign country and because removing my phone number also significantly broke things, so there may be some setup option where this does not happen. I do have email addresses associated with iMessage, but in my case, it just stopped working entirely with my primary number turned off even with GigSky associated with the secondary iMessage line.

It could have been a bug, or an early implementation issue because GigSky is data only with no associated number (which I suspect was the problem), or something that I did with the setup process. I don't know that everyone will run into this issue, but there are always going to be problems when changing or disabling the number associated with iMessage. I just wanted to make sure people are aware that things need to be set up carefully to avoid iMessage/FaceTime activation issues.

You can indeed use two numbers that can be responded to at any time while using just one for data if you set your Cellular Data setting to use the "Secondary" number while leaving the Voice line as the primary number and the iMessage line as the "Primary" number.

[doublepost=1546477510][/doublepost]
Wow! That pricing! What’s the point?

Most places, picking up a SIM is no more hassle then stopping at a kiosk in the arrivals hall. Takes five minutes and most countries have outstanding travel plans for tourists.

Worse yet is that it seems there is no way to just turn OFF your domestic line, except for Wifi to keep things like iMessage active.

The eSIM implementation seems pretty half baked at this point.

This. I travel to the UK once a year on average. There's a shop in Heathrow as soon as you exit customs. £30-40 (there are cheaper options) for a relatively large amount of data from a variety of local carriers, a local number, and great coverage. Just swap a SIM card (or use an eSIM-supporting carrier) and PAYG. Just remember to use an app (e.g. 1Password) for your 2fa-enabled services instead of SMS, which is arguably more secure (and I think more convenient, at least as implemented by 1P).

In this situation, there was no kiosk at the airport terminal where I arrived in the Czech Republic, I did not speak the language, and I did not have an opportunity to visit a cellular service store because of planned activities, so eSIM was simpler for me.

A local SIM you can swap in is DEFINITELY a better deal than eSIM at this point, but I do think eSIM is simpler than having to physically swap a SIM, though. Hopefully prices are going to drop as more and more carriers implement eSIM support and the technology matures.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi Juli, I wonder if you could answer a question for me?

I test drove both GigSky and Ubigi in late November/Early December while traveling in Asia. Was running iOS 12.1 on an iPhone XS at that point, with AT&T as my primary physical SIM.

Whenever I enabled GigSky or Ubigi I would lose Visual Voicemail. Supposedly AT&T had sorted this out with Apple by 12.1 release, so it was very surprising. Some Apple documentation claims if you have data-roaming enabled on the SIM (eSIM in this case with GigSky and Ubigi) that Visual Voicemail is disabled. But you have to enable data-roaming on them in order to use these eSIMs properly in other countries while traveling.

Unfortunately at the time I messed up my iPhone so much from fooling around trying to get Visual Voicemail to work while these data roaming eSIMs were active. In the end I wiped and setup my phone from scratch, so I have been hesitant to try again since 12.1.1 and 12.1.2 were released...

Can you tell me if you had any problems with Visual Voicemail on your trip with GigSky active? I know you were on Verizon, but any info would be helpful before I dare to try again. Curious if its related to the lack of phone number assigned to the GigSky eSIM as well, or maybe if 12.1.2 has improved the experience.
 
Gigsky has competiton : Truphone and Ubigi.

The convenience of having your phone number for sms and voice calls and using this worldwide data only services is priceless. It’s the reason why I upgraded from the X to XS.
The Hong Kong iPhone XS Max gets dual physical SIM support. IMO it's the best of both worlds solution at the current stage: being able to keep your original phone number online while you can pop in a cheap local SIM card for data.
 
  • Like
Reactions: catean
Here in Europe most subscriptions offer free roaming in Europe. I.e use included call/SMS/data etc, just like I am in my home country.

As I rarely travel outside Europe, expensive roaming charges is a thing of the past for me. (Except the satellite networks installed on ships, which is still very expensive and very slow)
 
  • Like
Reactions: catean
Here in Europe most subscriptions offer free roaming in Europe. I.e use included call/SMS/data etc, just like I am in my home country.

As I rarely travel outside Europe, expensive roaming charges is a thing of the past for me. (Except the satellite networks installed on ships, which is still very expensive and very slow)

You are right, we as europeans tend to do our holidays in mainland Europe, but do not forget about the Balkans states that are not regulated by E.U. yet. For me, traveling trough Serbia to reach Croatia or Greece, or going to Montenegro means a tariff of 10euros/MB from my network operator. eSIM saved me in those situations when I go to the seaside on my side of Europe.
 
Last edited:
Like others said, we tend sometimes to forget how cheap subscriptions are in Europe. I can have a monthly plan for 60 € with 100GB of data, of which I can use 80GB all over Europe AND the US/Canada .

For people from US/Canada, wouldn't it be more practical to simply get a used iPhone SE for example on top of your regular iPhone, then put a local european data SIM in the SE and use it to share data with your regular iPhone ? That way, you would get the best prices AND the convenience of keeping your regular number . It also means that you would have to carry another iphone with you at all times while in Europe, but the SE is so small and light that it would be worth it.
 
I mean that when I disabled my Verizon number (in Settings, "Turn off this line") in an attempt to make sure I didn't accidentally use any VZW data, my iMessage stopped working entirely. It did not work on WiFi, and I don't know why. I didn't do further testing on this because I was in a foreign country and because removing my phone number also significantly broke things, so there may be some setup option where this does not happen. I do have email addresses associated with iMessage, but in my case, it just stopped working entirely with my primary number turned off even with GigSky associated with the secondary iMessage line.

It could have been a bug, or an early implementation issue because GigSky is data only with no associated number (which I suspect was the problem), or something that I did with the setup process. I don't know that everyone will run into this issue, but there are always going to be problems when changing or disabling the number associated with iMessage. I just wanted to make sure people are aware that things need to be set up carefully to avoid iMessage/FaceTime activation issues.

Do you have your iMessage and FaceTime setup to also work with your iCloud email address or only your phone number?
 
I found Google Fi to be a better option. I have my AT&T Postpaid account on the eSIM on my iPhone XS Max, and I keep my Google Fi SIM in the tray. $10 per GB in every country, and you can get up to 9 free data-only SIMs for use with other devices that share the same data bucket, so I gave one to my wife to use in her iPhone XS. Data charges are capped at $60, so if you use over 6GB, you still pay $60. You do have to pay $20 per month for unlimited voice and SMS, but you can pause the service when you're not using it.

At least with AT&T, you can have their international department disable roaming completely, so you won't make an accidental phone call, and you don't have to worry about disabling that line on your iPhone, because it will simply have No Service, but iMessage and FaceTime still work for your main phone number. You can also setup call forwarding from your main number, so if someone calls you, your Google Fi number will ring, and you end up paying 20 cents a minute no matter where you are, which is very reasonable.
 
Great write up and review!

I purchased an Orange pre-paid SIM off Amazon before my trip to Europe last year. I had my X which was on T-Mobile, but I placed the SIM in my unlocked SE. My wife and I traveled to France and Italy and the SE worked flawlessly the entire trip. I really only used my X to take pictures. For me, the T-Mobile 2G speeds on my X were way too slow for me (and I was probably impatient too).

The next time we travel abroad, I'll definitely give GigSky a try on my Xs. Plus, it beats having to carry two phone's around, which is always a plus.
 
  • Like
Reactions: catean
Like others said, we tend sometimes to forget how cheap subscriptions are in Europe. I can have a monthly plan for 60 € with 100GB of data, of which I can use 80GB all over Europe AND the US/Canada .

For people from US/Canada, wouldn't it be more practical to simply get a used iPhone SE for example on top of your regular iPhone, then put a local european data SIM in the SE and use it to share data with your regular iPhone ? That way, you would get the best prices AND the convenience of keeping your regular number . It also means that you would have to carry another iphone with you at all times while in Europe, but the SE is so small and light that it would be worth it.

Not everywhere in Europe, I live in one of the richest countries in Europe, Data is expensive here, don't get it though, surrounding countries have much cheaper data prices.
 
Hi Juli, I wonder if you could answer a question for me?

I test drove both GigSky and Ubigi in late November/Early December while traveling in Asia. Was running iOS 12.1 on an iPhone XS at that point, with AT&T as my primary physical SIM.

Whenever I enabled GigSky or Ubigi I would lose Visual Voicemail. Supposedly AT&T had sorted this out with Apple by 12.1 release, so it was very surprising. Some Apple documentation claims if you have data-roaming enabled on the SIM (eSIM in this case with GigSky and Ubigi) that Visual Voicemail is disabled. But you have to enable data-roaming on them in order to use these eSIMs properly in other countries while traveling.

Unfortunately at the time I messed up my iPhone so much from fooling around trying to get Visual Voicemail to work while these data roaming eSIMs were active. In the end I wiped and setup my phone from scratch, so I have been hesitant to try again since 12.1.1 and 12.1.2 were released...

Can you tell me if you had any problems with Visual Voicemail on your trip with GigSky active? I know you were on Verizon, but any info would be helpful before I dare to try again. Curious if its related to the lack of phone number assigned to the GigSky eSIM as well, or maybe if 12.1.2 has improved the experience.

Yep. I definitely had an issue with voicemails while using the GigSky data, even with VZW still set as my primary carrier. I'm not sure if it was because I was overseas, something to do with the eSIM, or something caused by my fussing with settings, but my voicemail didn't seem to work until I got back to the U.S. and reset all of my network settings. Of course, I don't get a ton of voicemail, but the one I did receive on 12/13 didn't show up until 12/16 when I was back home.
[doublepost=1546540583][/doublepost]
Do you have your iMessage and FaceTime setup to also work with your iCloud email address or only your phone number?

I've got both enabled.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CommanderData
Previously when travelling with just the wife, we used a pocket wifi device. The advantage is that they can be used with locked phones and you only need one as long as you stick together. We would both disable our cellular modems to ensure no roaming charges. Calls, text messages and voicemail all continue to work normally, as if you're still at home, with wifi calling and imessage enabled. Had a $5 skype balance for any local calls.

There are 2 obvious significant disadvantages to this approach - you have to carry around / keep charged another device, and things get interesting if you accidentally get split up.

For those reasons I like the idea of having a local esim. My question (and it wasn't completely clear from Julie's write up) - has anyone tried turning off their primary sim with with imessage AND wifi calling enabled? Would the phone use the data connection on the esim as if it were wifi to make and receive calls?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.