Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

w00t951

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Jan 6, 2009
1,834
53
Pittsburgh, PA
I bought an Apple 5/5S case in Product RED. Here's my take on it...

Build Quality
Superb. The leather is flawless and the fit is impeccable. Typical Apple quality. The red is bright, at least out of the box.

Ease of Use
Mostly perfect. The buttons are easy to press. The port cutouts are quite fitted, so you'll probably have trouble getting chunky cables and headphone jacks in.

Actually Using It
Leather is a unique material - it bounces like foam yet resists scratches like rubber. Unfortunately, a problem exists with the lighter colored cases - the leather gets discolored after very little use. The edges are discolored to the same shade as the indented Apple logo on the back - it doesn't look horrible, but for people who care the Apple case won't look brand new for very long.

Aside from that little problem, the case is awesome. The buttons press easily, all the ports and switches and grilles are accessible (each speaker hole is cut and aligned with the grille hole!). The case even stops the silent switch from being flipped accidentally - you have to deliberately press the switch with your finger.

Conclusion
Now that I think about it, I should have gotten the black case. It would be less distinctive and fun, but the staining on the leather makes the case look slightly dirty. Until the leather ages properly, the discoloration will bother me.

Aside from that, the case is perfect. Good protection, high quality, and fine design make this one of my favorite cases from Apple.

Rating
:apple::apple::apple::apple:

Update
I returned the case. I stand by my original review, but the discoloration got worse since I wrote this. Now the case is gnarly and I doubt it will age like regular leather.
 
Last edited:
Yeah i got the same problem with the red, its getting discolored from the edges due to constantly taking in and out from jeans pockets.
I cleaned it with wet cloth but i don't think this color of case will last me long enough.
 
Agree with your review. I understand leather ages and changes with time and so on, but not convinced the red leather will age into anything that looks better than a dirty red case. Brown or black, sure, I can see that.
 
Yes, I am of the mind that colored leather won't develop a nice patina like brown or black leather.
 
I've had my case sept 21st and it's already getting really dark edges.

Yea please post pics. I got mine Sunday and it's starting to look... I dunno. Already.

I thought many maybe had the phone in new jeans or such and that led to the dye bleeding onto the phone. However that's not the "case."

It's a fine line between aged and looking dirty. I'm not sure how this is going to end.
 
I got this and loved it - then I tried plugging my earphones in and the case blocked my right-angle jack.

Very very sad.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    1.2 MB · Views: 652
Yea please post pics. I got mine Sunday and it's starting to look... I dunno. Already.

I thought many maybe had the phone in new jeans or such and that led to the dye bleeding onto the phone. However that's not the "case."

It's a fine line between aged and looking dirty. I'm not sure how this is going to end.

You can see it better in this pic
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 366
That doesn't look bad at all IMHO. I may still take a chance and grab one. Was thinking blue or red, but black maybe the safe choice.

Yea I would still get it. I like it a lot. It'll probably get more wear but aslong as it's the case and not my phone taking wear and tear.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.