Review of creating a dual band network

Discussion in 'Mac Accessories' started by gwihannom, Mar 11, 2009.

  1. gwihannom macrumors member

    Joined:
    Nov 16, 2008
    #1
    Here's something I have tried in the last couple of days.

    I have Time Capsule and Airport Express.

    I decided to try the dual band.
    Time Capsule distributing 802.11n only (5GHz),
    and in a bridge mode, have Airport Express connected via ethernet,
    and distribute 802.11g only.

    Wireless N network has a name "xxxn."
    Wireless G network has a name "xxxg."

    Two separate networks are on different frequencies,
    and are in different radio modes.
    They are positioned about two feet away from each other.

    I have used various internet speed test websites,
    and from a distance close to the routers (same room)
    I get a speed check of about 25~30 mbps.
    That's the speed that I'm suppose to get.

    Move to a couple rooms away,
    I would say about three wooden walls, a wooden door,
    some "normal" interfering objects in between.

    Speed test, and the results are very different.
    About 20 mbps for Wireless G only network, which is fine.
    But around 8.5 mbps for Wireless N only in 5GHz.
    Half the download speed.
    Upload is same at about 6mbps.

    In this case, wireless N was slower than wireless G.

    Harassed an Apple technical support and IP tech friend,
    and the answer was,

    "2.4GHz does better at passing through interferences such as large water tanks, electronic devices, glass and metal plates. 5GHz is not as resilient as 2.4GHz. For people experiencing issues with 5GHz, using 2.4GHz might be the better option."

    So there you go.

    Performance boost might not be that great.
    But then again, maybe new device has made a significant improvement.
     
  2. spaceballl macrumors 68030

    spaceballl

    Joined:
    Nov 2, 2003
    Location:
    San Francisco, CA
    #2
    Yes this is not unexpected. That's one of the reasons why 802.11a never really took off. It's also one of the reasons that the bidding wars recently got so high for the sub ghz spectrum. Networks that run on something like a 700 Mhz phone can really penetrate walls well.

    Now it all depends on where you live. For example, I live in San Francisco and have about 20 2.4ghz networks I can see. I bet moving to 5ghz would be a huge improvement for me since there would be way less interference on that spectrum. Interesting the way you created your dual network. Maybe eBay them both and then you'll probably have enough $ for one of the new ones - would just be more elegant and less of a hassle.
     

Share This Page