Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Applefanboy8153

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 3, 2012
204
0
I am planning to get a new MacBook retina 13, but i keep dropping stuff, I dropped my ipad almost thrice in a year. Will a retina survive a fall? or will have to get a MBA because of it's sturdier construction?
 
Why do you think that MBA is sturdier? If any of them should survive a fall, you are rather lucky. They are not designed to be dropped.
 
Why do you think that MBA is sturdier? If any of them should survive a fall, you are rather lucky. They are not designed to be dropped.

Well, my cousin uses a MBA and he dropped it from his bed once and not even a scratch, so i guess they are sturdier.


impossible for you to just try and be more careful?

Not really but i am always in a hurry, my day is packed!! So i tend to be careless.
 
I am planning to get a new MacBook retina 13, but i keep dropping stuff, I dropped my ipad almost thrice in a year. Will a retina survive a fall? or will have to get a MBA because of it's sturdier construction?

Dropped my cMBP 13 before from a kitchen table. I know it is not a retina but it survived the fall. No scratches etc...
 
I guess it all depends on what you drop it on, how it lands and hight of the fall.
all the Mac books are made of the same material, i do not see how that will effect how sturdy the machine is.
think the question comes down to the screen and how the machine lands.
BUT do get a SSD since they are sturdier when it comes to shakes and bumps.

Edit:
Do not drop it in a pool of water, will kill it:D
 
I guess it all depends on what you drop it on, how it lands and hight of the fall.
all the Mac books are made of the same material, i do not see how that will effect how sturdy the machine is.
think the question comes down to the screen and how the machine lands.
BUT do get a SSD since they are sturdier when it comes to shakes and bumps.

Edit:
Do not drop it in a pool of water, will kill it:D

Not much water in India, so dont worry about that
 
It totally depends how it hits, if it lands on a corner of the screen or something it's going to crack, but if landed on the bottom maybe not..


It totally depends.
 
Well, my cousin uses a MBA and he dropped it from his bed once and not even a scratch, so i guess they are sturdier.

And I am sure that someone has dropped an rMBP and there wasn't even a scratch. Anecdotal evidence is anecdotal. If you really want a computer that will survive a fall, you will have to look at rugged laptops. Alas, Apple does not build anything like that.
 
WorthAveGroup.com > SquareTrade > AppleCare

15OFF works for a 15% discount off WorthAveGroup.com
 
I would recommend either A) a disposable computer, B) a MilSpec ruggedized computer like the Latitude ATG, or C) something you can put an OtterBox case on.

However, if you're dead set on a MacBook, I have seen them take some pretty serious punishment and keep working (though a computer with buckled ports loses quite a bit of functionality... I should get pictures of the one I'm talking about). It's really a matter of luck.
 
I dont see this thing surviving a floor onto say Hardwood or tile without getting a scuff or scratch...Will the actual computer survive the fall, without a doubt! But coming away dent or scratch free, I dont see that happening, these machines scratch very easily.
 
The retina is more 'drop-proof' than the air, drop the corner of each machine from 1 metre and the Air will be worse off.
 
Uh, how about we just take your word for it :)

Take mine and his word for it, a schoolmate of mine dropped his air from his top bunk bed, it wouldnt even close properly, there was a 1-1.2CM gap between the display and the palmrest. He took a hammer to the poor thing to straighten the metal up xD :p
 
You might want to have a talk with your doctor and see why you keep dropping stuff.

Maybe it's just tennis elbow or you could have parkinson's disease.
 
I guess it all depends on what you drop it on, how it lands and hight of the fall.
all the Mac books are made of the same material, i do not see how that will effect how sturdy the machine is.
think the question comes down to the screen and how the machine lands.
BUT do get a SSD since they are sturdier when it comes to shakes and bumps.

Edit:
Do not drop it in a pool of water, will kill it:D
So I guess my pool side is out of question, I also ordered a rubberized hard case with my mac are they any good?
 
my rmbp fell from the couch to the carpeted floor below (~18") and now I have a shattered screen. I could not believe how little it took for that to happen. My 2006 mbp had made the same drop dozens of times with zero damage.
 
my rmbp fell from the couch to the carpeted floor below (~18") and now I have a shattered screen. I could not believe how little it took for that to happen. My 2006 mbp had made the same drop dozens of times with zero damage.

Then again, your 2006 MBP doesn't have glass in front of the display.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.