rMBP or Mini i7 @ these prices for these needs? Which?

crashwins

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 11, 2009
101
0
Ok - I always get the best advice on here for decisions like this and lord knows I always seem to be making them.

From my work I have the option of buying the following:

6-month-old Mini 2.6GHz i7 with 8GB and 256 SSD (so, the latest $1300 model) for $600. Or, the 2.4Ghz 15" rMBP with 8GB Ram (the latest model retina) for $1300 even (it's only 1-month old and has the Samsung screen.

My uses: CS6 (a lot), but I'm starting to get into FCP and interested in video. I may start getting into Adobe Premier, which I understad Windows handles pretty well on the Mac.

So, for these prices and these needs which would you take? Thanks!
 

crashwins

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 11, 2009
101
0
Thanks for chiming in...

Well, they're both pretty excellent deals. The Mini is half off and the Retina is like a $1000 off. But I want to buy what will be most useful to me for the work, etc. Thanks!
 

yusukeaoki

macrumors 68030
Mar 22, 2011
2,550
6
Tokyo, Japan
I would go for the rMBP.
Im not a huge fan of retina models but for your use, I would buy it.

The Mini only has HD4000 while the rMBP has the GT650M.
For CS6 doing a lot of rendering, graphic intensive work, CPU intensive, MBP fits your needs.
 

crashwins

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 11, 2009
101
0
Yeah, I see the dedicated GPU definitely paying dividends in the CS6 environment.

May I ask why you don't like the rMBP? I was definitely weary with the class action suit and all, but among the Samsungs things seem excellent.
 

yusukeaoki

macrumors 68030
Mar 22, 2011
2,550
6
Tokyo, Japan
Yeah, I see the dedicated GPU definitely paying dividends in the CS6 environment.

May I ask why you don't like the rMBP? I was definitely weary with the class action suit and all, but among the Samsungs things seem excellent.
I went through 2 retinas and both were BAD.
Horrible image retention and so many bugs that needed to be fixed.
This was when the retina just came out so Im not sure about now.
But IMO, for another year or two until Apple settles this, Im not going to put my hands on it.

My way of looking is if Apple does something new, expect something faulty until the next model.
Like iPhone 4 and its antenna problems. Fixed in next gen.
2010 MBP CPU problem, fixed in 2011 with all new quad core.
 

crashwins

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 11, 2009
101
0
Yeah, I feel a similar way. I'm not an early adopter. But, technically, this model is the next iteration of the rMBP line, no? It's updated at least from the original build, albeit without taking care of the problems with the LG models.
 

B...

macrumors 68000
Mar 7, 2013
1,949
2
Yeah, I feel a similar way. I'm not an early adopter. But, technically, this model is the next iteration of the rMBP line, no? It's updated at least from the original build, albeit without taking care of the problems with the LG models.
Technically, yes, but in practice no. The new Lg panels (SJA2) still have IR issues. Waiting to see what Apple fixes in their TRUE rev. 2 in June/July/August.
 

yusukeaoki

macrumors 68030
Mar 22, 2011
2,550
6
Tokyo, Japan
Yeah, I feel a similar way. I'm not an early adopter. But, technically, this model is the next iteration of the rMBP line, no? It's updated at least from the original build, albeit without taking care of the problems with the LG models.
As stated above me, that is a no.
Ghosting still can be seen with retina models and it is still not "perfect"
 

theuserjohnny

macrumors 6502
Jul 7, 2012
450
7
Retina for sure! That dGPU will be a huge benefit!

You have a Samsung panel you have a less likely chance of getting LG! I went through about 5 of them and all had LG and all had the issue. I finally got a Samsung screen and I've yet to see the issue reproduced.

The issue of the image problem is due to the manufacture and not Apple. It's all on LG to fix the issue for Apple and since Apple is moving away from Samsung LG better get its game together before Apple starts producing it's own screens :p
 

fskywalker

macrumors 65816
Nov 6, 2009
1,223
3
Retina for sure! That dGPU will be a huge benefit!

You have a Samsung panel you have a less likely chance of getting LG! I went through about 5 of them and all had LG and all had the issue. I finally got a Samsung screen and I've yet to see the issue reproduced.

The issue of the image problem is due to the manufacture and not Apple. It's all on LG to fix the issue for Apple and since Apple is moving away from Samsung LG better get its game together before Apple starts producing it's own screens :p
You meant of getting ghosting, right?