Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Wow, hehe. At that price, I might pick up a "spare". ;)

I got it a few weeks ago from CC for $750 and thought that was a deal. Great price on a GREAT cam!
 
HV20 vs HG10

I saw an HV20 at BestBuy this weekend. I heard rave reviews about the video quality of the HV20 but was a bit dissapointed in the physical build quality of the camera itself. But I am mostly concerned with the video quality.

I then saw Canon's new HG10 and it looks a little more sturdy in build quality. So, my question is... how does the video quality compare between the two? HDV2 vs AVCHD? I really like the idea of a hard drive in the camera as opposed to the MiniDV tapes - though I admit I am a novice when it comes to video equipment and recording.

So, would I be much more "awed" by the HV20 video over the HG10 video???
 
I saw an HV20 at BestBuy this weekend. I heard rave reviews about the video quality of the HV20 but was a bit dissapointed in the physical build quality of the camera itself. But I am mostly concerned with the video quality.

I then saw Canon's new HG10 and it looks a little more sturdy in build quality. So, my question is... how does the video quality compare between the two? HDV2 vs AVCHD? I really like the idea of a hard drive in the camera as opposed to the MiniDV tapes - though I admit I am a novice when it comes to video equipment and recording.

So, would I be much more "awed" by the HV20 video over the HG10 video???

The HG10 is an excellent camcorder. IMO, probably the best HDD based cam out there. With that noted however, I returned one I had for a few days in favor of the HV20.

Quality wise, they are very close, again, IMO, and Canon has done a GREAT job with AVCHD on the HG10. My problem however was long term storage. I still prefer the instant archive capability of tape. I also think HDV has an edge over AVCHD in terms of quality and editability. One thing that had initially led me towards a hard drive cam, was not having to capture to the comp in real time. Uh, frankly, with AVCHD, it was even a bit LONGER than real time due to the system having to decode the AVCHD data into an editable format. This also creates HUGE files, and again, I wound up returning to that long term storage thing. With tape, I have excellent quality, and immediate archive. I also have a way to watch home movies in full HD glory in my living room by simply connecting the cam to the TV without having the need for a currently VERY expensive blue ray or HD DVD recording system.

Just my 2 cents, but as an "old timer" I think tape\mine dv\HDV still h as a LOT of life left in it. (And yeah, I'm a broken record, but the HV20 is an amazing camera)! :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.