Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Roundup of Features in Google Maps for iOS: Better Design than Android Version, iPad Version Coming

Praise the lord... Google maps is back and better than ever!

Apple should delete their poor attempts at a mapping app and forever hold their peace.

Seriously Apple you really dropped the ball on this one and lost a huge amount of consumer confidence in the process!
 
RDStrong said:
How gracious of Apple to gimp their own maps application. I guess they must love relying on the sadomasochistic tendencies of their customer base.

Spinning Apple's disastrous maps fiasco into a positive by painting it as an elaborate (some would say convoluted) attempt to force Google's hand is ludicrous.
Click to expand...

I don't think Apple planned on making a **** app. My point is that Google's Android app was miles better than the iOS one. Apple asked Google to add features to their maps app and Google wouldn't. So Apple threw them out and now Google release an app with (surprise) the features Apple asked for.

I'm not a fanboy that I'm going to blindly follow Apple till kingdom come but Google was partly at fault for not developing their apps on iOS to the same standard as Android.

The current YouTube and Google Maps apps are MUCH better than they were in iOS 5. That would have never been the case if Apple kept them as first party software.
 
So I download Google Maps on my iPhone this morning and start a route to my train station 2 minutes away. It's first instruction? Make an illegal left turn onto a major road that would probably result in an accident.

Tried it in Apple Maps and it correctly took my around to a place where I can legally make a left turn.

Irony.
 
iWe said:
Either you're missing the point, or you're a Google spokesperson. All maps have mistakes in them and Google is no exception.
Click to expand...

I'm not missing the point and I'm not a Google spokerperson. Placing the city center 100km away where it is is not similar to guiding to a road that exists and can be driven.

Where I have said that Google Maps have not errors?
 
The best "feature" of Apple Maps is that it prodded Google to give in and release a decent Maps App for iOS.

Would Google have made such a great app available for iOS if Apple hadn't created its map app? No, definitely.

In my book Apple Maps achieved its purpose: to make an awesome app available for iOS, even if it doesn't come from Apple.
 
Funny thing is the first street I pulled up with Google Maps had a closed location and a location located on the wrong side of the street! LOL

Having said that, it did have a ton more locations...the one shortcoming I have experienced with Apple Maps.

Competition is a good thing.
 
kis said:
well, rest assured - Google didn't program this gem in the last 8 weeks. This certainly was meant to be an update at first.
Click to expand...

They've known their maps wouldn't be in iOS6 for the better part of a year, if not longer.
 
HishamAkhtar said:
I don't think Apple planned on making a **** app. My point is that Google's Android app was miles better than the iOS one. Apple asked Google to add features to their maps app and Google wouldn't. So Apple threw them out and now Google release an app with (surprise) the features Apple asked for.
Click to expand...

But Google would, if they got better branding and the ability to integrate their other services better.

And now everyone will switch to this app, and Google still get those things. Google have everything they wanted.

All Apple have gained is a PR black eye, less control and poor integration compared to Android when that sort of cleverness is supposed to be their home turf. It's a lose-lose for Apple.
 
MacRumors said:
- Google has created the Google Maps for iOS SDK, which allows developers to feature Google Maps in their applications rather than Apple Maps. Developers can do this in two ways. The first uses a URL scheme so developers can have their apps launch Google Maps to complete a search, show a map or Street View imagery, or view walking, driving and public transportation navigation easily.*There are also API keys that allow developers to feature information like traffic navigation and general maps navigation.
Click to expand...

Glad I have readable maps back. Sure it's "uglier" than Apple's rendering, but I can read it at a glance with the big clashing colors and large lines used for roads/streets. Aside from streets that had gone missing (Apple's actual mapping data, streets, was far more incomplete for my area than Google's), the data wasn't really an issue for me.

But this news about the SDK is the best I've heard. Hopefully, Apple allows 3rd party apps that forgoe MapKit to use this instead in the App Store and some of my favorite Map enabled apps move to it.

As an aside, I wonder why they went with the old style bitmap/mip-map tiles instead of their vector version from 2010. Guess they didn't want it to be that much better than Android's version.

----------
Oletros said:
Where I have said that Google Maps have not errors?
Click to expand...

Google Maps isn't perfect. The difference is in the magnitude of errors. Google Maps has far less and they seem to be improving at quite a rapid pace.
 
Thank you Google and thank you Apple for letting this happen. Yet this would have been great news in 2010.

Today we have so many alternatives that the Google newcomer will be a nice addition but nothing more. The market for free maps and navigation apps is expanding fast and differentiation is becoming the driving tendency.

Nokia maps allows partial downloading for offline use, Waze is great for sharing of info and the navigator is very nice, openmaps come with different layers (cycling, railways...), Apple maps are fast in loading and rendering, Google has street view and nicely integrates maps with driving...

There is less and less meaning in asking which is the "best" app overall. The "best" is the one that does best what I need to do now.
 
Last edited:
The Phazer said:
But Google would, if they got better branding and the ability to integrate their other services better.

And now everyone will switch to this app, and Google still get those things. Google have everything they wanted.

All Apple have gained is a PR black eye, less control and poor integration compared to Android when that sort of cleverness is supposed to be their home turf. It's a lose-lose for Apple.
Click to expand...

Not sure if everyone will switch to this app. Apple Maps being the default map for iOS is huge. Slowly they will become better and have more control and more ways to integrate it into other services.

To be honest, the Maps debacle has been a lose-lose for everyone until now. It was a PR nightmare for Apple, Google lost a huge base for ad revenue, and the consumers lost a good mapping option on their smartphone.

Now, we have 2 options to choose from in terms of which mapping we want to use. Personally I will probably use both.
 
HishamAkhtar said:
Not sure if everyone will switch to this app. Apple Maps being the default map for iOS is huge. Slowly they will become better and have more control and more ways to integrate it into other services.

To be honest, the Maps debacle has been a lose-lose for everyone until now. It was a PR nightmare for Apple, Google lost a huge base for ad revenue, and the consumers lost a good mapping option on their smartphone.

Now, we have 2 options to choose from in terms of which mapping we want to use. Personally I will probably use both.
Click to expand...

I'll use both too.

Plus MotionX and Waze.

It's good to have options!
 
I wonder if this app and its acceptance is a result of the execs at both companies reaching an agreement because of the joint bid on Kodak 's patents
 
Love it, but does anyone know how to delete a pin after you've dropped one, can't work it out!
 
arn said:
Google wanted things in return

https://www.macrumors.com/2012/09/2...ps-driven-by-turn-by-turn-navigation-dispute/
Click to expand...

And the Apple answer was to give us maps that get me lost indefinitely in nearby little mountain towns.

Great mapping application. Nevertheless, it lacks iOS integration and therefor, makes it a bit inconvenient to map addresses in contacts where I have to copy and paste address information.

I wished apple would allow choosing default applications in settings, wait! That would never happen.

Fix your map data apple, the next time I need a new phone I might actually try the new nexus.
 
samcraig said:
I wonder if this app and its acceptance is a result of the execs at both companies reaching an agreement because of the joint bid on Kodak 's patents
Click to expand...

I get the feeling that Apple and Google have realized that attacking each other in public is probably bad for both of them.

However, Samsung hasn't realized that. Although I kind of enjoy their potshots at Apple.
 
The Phazer said:
But Google would, if they got better branding and the ability to integrate their other services better.

And now everyone will switch to this app, and Google still get those things. Google have everything they wanted.

All Apple have gained is a PR black eye, less control and poor integration compared to Android when that sort of cleverness is supposed to be their home turf. It's a lose-lose for Apple.
Click to expand...

Everyone will switch to this? How do you figure that? I'm guessing at least 95% of the users will stick to apples maps. Even though apples maps get a lot of criticism on places like this, most casual users don't care and are fine using apples offering.
 
Does anyone know how to load my saved places from Google desktop map into this new map app?
 
fruitpunch.ben said:
Google allegedly wouldn't allow turn by turn unless Apple accepted a number of conditions such as Google branding within the app, advertising, etc. Obviously Google is free to include any such things within their own app, and they presumably have done that

EDIT: Pipped by Arn :)
Click to expand...

I think it's pretty fair for Google to have wanted branding. As to some of the other things that may or may not have been "demanded", that is questionable.
 
My 2 cents on Google Maps for iPhone: Good Clean Design. Apple maps still looks better especially during Driving mode. Google Maps has Street View and In App Public Transit Which is really really Nice. At the very least Apple should add built in Public Transportation. As far as Points of Interest Google has more since its a more mature product but Apple will catch up. At the end of the day Im sticking with Apple Maps as my main Mapping App and will use GMaps for Streetview and Public Transport.
 
Ballis said:
Everyone will switch to this? How do you figure that? I'm guessing at least 95% of the users will stick to apples maps. Even though apples maps get a lot of criticism on places like this, most casual users don't care and are fine using apples offering.
Click to expand...

Nah, sorry. Casual users do care. This is such a big deal it's making front page news in the UK newspaper websites.

I expect well over 80% of users to switch.

Heck, more than 5% of iOS users Jailbreak.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back