Originally posted by GrandShenlong
"Some people say that guns don't kill people, people kill people. Well, I think the gun helps a bit." - Eddie Izzard
I think that the argument that crime still happens in Europe in spite of the fact that guns are outlawed is seeing the world in black and white. Europe's crime rates don't even COMPARE with that of America's. Do we seriously think that it's purely caused by "increased racial tensions" or "social conditions"? if we didn't have guns, I'd think that violent crime would go down SIGNIFICANTLY. If a criminal only has a long knife to mug you with, it'll be a mental deterrent for them, and will put you (the average citizen who DOESN'T tote a concealed weapon 24/7) on a more equal footing.
Self-defense: Some say that "I want a gun for self-defense". Ask yourselves: Are there more crimes committed by guns, or are there more average citizens toting guns in the midst of their daily affairs? I think that the former far outnumbers the latter. Also, guns have been legal, and loosely controlled, in America since its inception. Are most ordinary citizens toting Glocks right now for self-defense? I don't think so. Are little old ladies in wheelchairs carrying .22's to ward off muggers? No. They've had plenty of time to provide defenses for themselves. Why aren't they armed to the teeth. or armed at all? The fact is, that most ordinary citizens who might actually need such explosive protection at some point in their lives don't have it. Thus, just looking at it from a "How far have we gotten so far" point of view, I'd say that the point of "I need guns for self-defense" has very little merit.
Social and economical factors have a HUGE part to play in crime rates. Did you read my "swiss" link in my last post? People don't just see a gun and go "wow, I feel like commiting a violent crime now." They want to commit a crime and then they look for something to help them achieve that goal. The genocide in Rwanda (aprox. 800,000 killed in 100 days) was carried out mostly by people w/machete's and and farming tools! A population so poor they barely had ANY firearms yet they managed to slaughter 800,000 people anyway.
In short:
Swiss: Lots of guns + few social/econ issues= gun violence so low it's not even a stastic.
Rwanda: few guns + major social/ecnon issues = mass genocide.
Extreme examples? Yes, but I think it shows my point.
Making guns illegal (or significantly harder to obtain) isn't going to do sh*t for reducing the number of guns used by criminals because over 90% of firearms used in commiting a crime have been aquired illegally. And last time I checked the US isn't exactly doing a great job on keeping drugs and people from sneaking into this country so an increased amount of gun smuggling shouldn't be too hard to pull off.
How will making it harder (or impossible) for me, a law abiding citizen, to purchase a handgun make it harder for Bob the Armed Robber to buy his handgun on the black market?
And just because I haven't ranted enough yet...
According to the International Crime Victims Survey conducted by the Dutch Ministry of Justice, England, Australia and Wales consistently won the dubious honors of having the highest burglary rates and the highest rates for crimes of violence such as robbery, assault and sexual assault in the 17 top industrialized nations.
Yes it is from the NRA so yes it is biased in opinion, but they source their stats in that article so even though the piece is slanted I don't think the stats are. For example,
The London Evening Standard reported on Dec. 19, 2001, "Gun crime in London is rocketing, with increases of almost 90 percent in some firearms offenses, Scotland Yard reported today. New figures show London murders with guns increased by 87 percent in the first eight months of the year com-pared with the same period last year.", or
The Daily Telegraph of Jan. 3, 2002, reported, "Police fear a new crime explosion as school-age muggers graduate to guns
the number of people robbed of personal property at gunpoint rose by 53 percent
. Ballistics experts warn that firearms are now cheap and easily available."
Lethal