I'm wondering if it's safe to update to Big Sur by now, because a while ago there were huge problems with older Macbooks completely bricking in the process. I have a very old Macbook, mid-2014, with Catalina. Has Apple fixed this issue? Are they even going to?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Safe to update to Big Sur?
- Thread starter adp-20
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I say don't. There's still many bugs and imperfections with all sorts of stuff on BigSur (just look at the number of threads here).
And there's not that many benefits in upgrading anyway.
And there's not that many benefits in upgrading anyway.
For me personally? I'd probably go for it. I like shiny, and it's been fine on my 2015 MacBook Pro and 2019 mini.
If I'm advising you, OP, who I know nothing about? If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
If I'm advising you, OP, who I know nothing about? If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
it's an impossible question. safe? if you upgrade, and all is well... then it's 'safe'. if you have issues, then... probably not. lots of people have upgraded and are happy. some are not (i'm fine on both of my macs).
if catalina works for you, you can play it safe, and stay with that. if you decide to upgrade, back up everything first. and then, as with all of us, you hope for the best, because no one here can guarantee anything (good or bad).
if catalina works for you, you can play it safe, and stay with that. if you decide to upgrade, back up everything first. and then, as with all of us, you hope for the best, because no one here can guarantee anything (good or bad).
I'd stay on Catalina on that hardware, if it works.
I've got a 2018 Mini and after the release of 11.3, I upgraded.
I recently had one unexpected reboot (full crash with automatic reboot) and it seems that sometimes, after the displays come back from powersave-mode, all the open application-windows aren't visible anymore.
I do suspect this is more a problem with the Opera Browser.
I do like the look, but I miss the widgets
I've got a 2018 Mini and after the release of 11.3, I upgraded.
I recently had one unexpected reboot (full crash with automatic reboot) and it seems that sometimes, after the displays come back from powersave-mode, all the open application-windows aren't visible anymore.
I do suspect this is more a problem with the Opera Browser.
I do like the look, but I miss the widgets
No problems here either on a "2020" i7 Mac mini.. I bought it with Catalina installed, 'upgraded' to the public beta and then the release, all the way up to 11.3.1. Was kind of surprised that nothing happened along the way to require a reinstall and its still running great.
I recently upgraded my Early 2013 15-inch Retina MBP to Big Sur using OCLP vers 0.1.4 and have not had any issues. In fact when I installed Big Sur I installed vers 11.3.1 then today updated my Big Sur install to vers 11.4 Beta 3 with no issue to report. My laptop updated normally so as long as you follow the install guide you shouldn't have any issue.
Here is the link to the OCLP install guide that I followed...
Yeah, I find it safe to update my laptops to Big Sur.
Also just upgraded my 2018 mini to 11.3.1 after holding off 9 months. Now my 4K monitor isn’t recognised at all and my speakers constantly crackle with no apparent fix. Apple’s software is hilariously bad these days. Even my W10 gaming pc is flawless by comparison…. Very very disappointing.I'd stay on Catalina on that hardware, if it works.
I've got a 2018 Mini and after the release of 11.3, I upgraded.
I recently had one unexpected reboot (full crash with automatic reboot) and it seems that sometimes, after the displays come back from powersave-mode, all the open application-windows aren't visible anymore.
I do suspect this is more a problem with the Opera Browser.
I do like the look, but I miss the widgets
I have 2 Eizo 3285 4K displays on the Mini (via USB C) - the problems with USB C and 4K displays were the reason I held off updating. They are supposed to be fixed in 11.3…
Big Sur will update all your firmware regardless.
And you can’t downgrade these.
macOS ain’t Linux…
Continue holding off for as long as you can imo. Apple haven’t learnt their lesson.
I guess unlucky is my middle name. I’ve had non-stop issues with Mac OS over the past 3 years.
My 4K Samsung has been connected USB-C to DP since day 1, not a single issue with the display here.
I understand Catalina is terrible. Why would you want to, when Mojave is still receiving security patches?
So, your personal experience should now dictate everyone’s experience?
Neither my 2015 nor 2020 MBPs have issues like that. We just updated the 12th corporate MBP to Big Sur and not one has had kernel panics.
I didn’t try to “dictate” anything. The OP, who is using a 7-year-old machine, asked for feedback and I gave some.