Same Specs, different speed? WHY?

Discussion in 'MacBook Pro' started by mrfizzed, Nov 20, 2015.

  1. mrfizzed macrumors newbie

    Joined:
    Nov 1, 2009
    #1
    So I have in front of me two of exactly the same macbook pros, mid 2015 15". Exactly same specs. Exactly same programs installed, mirrored from time machinebackup. They are exact clones of one another. One has 7 battery cycles, one has 67 battery cycles, thats the only difference.

    2.5ghx quad core i7

    16gb ram

    AMD 2gb Card etc etc etc

    I am doing a test through imovie. Same files, same everything. Hit share at same time for a 1 hr 45 minute video to be processed. One computer does it in 13 minutesm other in 17 minutes. Why would this happen? What could cause this? Makes no sense to me. Am I missing something? If there are literally same computer, same everything including right down to the hard drive being cloned why would one be faster?

    BTW same thing happened with handbrake converting the same file. FPS was faster on one machine. Why?
     
  2. DeltaMac macrumors 604

    DeltaMac

    Joined:
    Jul 30, 2003
    Location:
    Delaware
    #2
    The only way that you could have "EXACTLY" the same software, is to boot both systems from the same volume.
    Once you begin using a cloned system, regardless of how perfect that image might be as a source, on other hardware, it becomes (slightly) different.
    Not likely that you would get a precise repeat of a timed process like video conversion, etc. There's hardware tolerances in the timing of memory, the memory bus, the processor, system bus for access to storage that would all come in to play here.
    Could be that everything adds up on the faster one, to end up with a faster task. And, the other system simply adds up on the slower end of tolerances. But, the two might reverse position on some different task, with a different mix of processor, storage, and memory use.
    It's really the same as running some random benchmark app on both Macbook pros. No benchmark will give you the identical results twice in a row, other than within some set of tolerances. MacBook Pro "A", specced the same as MacBook Pro "B", will not necessarily test and benchmark the same, other than within a range of values. All you have with two "identical" computers, is to know that both have the same hardware, and the same set of software. Beyond that, they will not be identical to each other. I expect that you have one MBPro at the high end of tolerances, and the other is more to the low end. So, both good - but you don't get to expect them to perform identically in real life.

    That being said - if you normally show that same 30% difference, that seems like a lot. I would expect manufacturing tolerances might allow for about 15% (I don't have knowledge about those engineering tolerances, but that seems reasonable, where 30% on the same hardware might be too far off.
     

Share This Page