Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Alexa is not a speaker like Apple's. That is a device to order from Amazon and only has a crappy speaker because it's necessary.

The Echo's speaker is fine for most of us. The Echo Show's is even better.

It's really incorrect to claim that Alexa is just for ordering from Amazon. In fact, that's the least of her capabilities, although a cool one. (The sheer fact that you can speak into the air and order almost anything, often delivered the same day or the next, is astonishing. Try that with a HomePod.)

With over 15,000 available addon "skills", Alexa is able to do everything from home control to horoscopes.

Apple's is a highend smart speaker that can do a few other things. Completely different purpose.

So you're saying that the HomePod is not meant to compete with Amazon's devices in any way? That HomePod buyers will only want it as a "speaker that can do a few other things", and so will still get an Amazon device for intelligent assistance?

Or don't you think that the HomePod is intended to steal Echo sales over to the Apple side.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Phonephreak
Apple already made a speaker back in 2007. It's my main player for my black and silver iPods. Amazon was never the first to make a wireless talkative speaker anyhow.
 
Alexa is not a speaker like Apple's. That is a device to order from Amazon and only has a crappy speaker because it's necessary. Apple's is a highend smart speaker that can do a few other things. Completely different purpose.

Obviously you don't have one. It does a lot more than just order things. :rolleyes:
 
Everyone and their mother will buy one of these, with built-in surround sound in NYC and completely mess with their neighbors ability to live quietly.
 
I've used them, they're really bad like all assistants right now (but all in their own special ways); they're cheap though, so I get their use.
BTW, the "crappy speaker" claim on the Echo is not totally true. Actually the speakers on the Echoshow are quite good. It sounds to me like you have only used the Echodot.

The Echo plays a critical roll in my house. It controls my lights, turns on/off my home theater system, locks my doors, controls my HVAC, etc. I wouldn't call it "bad". I really doubt the Homepod will be as functional as the Echo when it starts. Maybe over time. Then again, it sounds like Apple is aiming for people who listen to music which is fine.
 
The upside to the Dot is the aux out which means you can hook it up to any speaker, stereo, or home theater setup. I have three of them and never use the crappy speaker inside it.

The thing that intrigues me about the HomePod is how it will work with Airplay and the fact that it has Apple Music support. I don't know if it is worth the money, but I will look into what it does and decide. I have no interest in the Samsung speaker.
 
The upside to the Dot is the aux out which means you can hook it up to any speaker, stereo, or home theater setup. I have three of them and never use the crappy speaker inside it.

The thing that intrigues me about the HomePod is how it will work with Airplay and the fact that it has Apple Music support. I don't know if it is worth the money, but I will look into what it does and decide. I have no interest in the Samsung speaker.

So, analog to a stereo. Stereo set up in old fashion way... That's pretty far off from what happen claims the Homepod can do. Many here would think its merely a speaker... With an A8 processor inside (same as Iphone6) and seemingly running IOS... Are kind of funny.
[doublepost=1504134349][/doublepost]
Everyone and their mother will buy one of these, with built-in surround sound in NYC and completely mess with their neighbors ability to live quietly.

How is that different from now. If anything, the better calibration to the room means you don't have to use it as loud to get the same volume.
 
So, analog to a stereo. Stereo set up in old fashion way... That's pretty far off from what happen claims the Homepod can do. Many here would think its merely a speaker... With an A8 processor inside (same as Iphone6) and seemingly running IOS... Are kind of funny.
[doublepost=1504134349][/doublepost]

How is that different from now. If anything, the better calibration to the room means you don't have to use it as loud to get the same volume.
There is nothing new about stand alone speakers that you can’t plug anything into. Many cheap radios have had that “new fashioned” capability for years. The problem is that these stand alone setups are extremely limited compared to new receivers that have tons of flexibility that you lose with a product that has zero inputs and zero outputs.

The thing that the Echo Dot provides is the ability to connect it to better audio systems for $50 (typically less). It still has new-fangled features like controlling lights, thermostats, playing music from several sources, controlling Plex/J River, setting timers, giving you the weather, etc...

As I said, I am more interested in how the HomePod works with AirPlay because it could allow it to work with my better setups when I want something that sounds better than a 7 inch speaker for music. The Echo can connect to my receivers via Bluetooth, if that makes it feel more “new” to your sensibilities, but the analog connection will sound better.

Not sure if you are familiar with receivers made in the past 5 years or so. They have room correction, DSP modes, can have AirPlay, Spotify Connect, Bluetooth, internet connections, high resolution capabilities for music and movies, etc. built in. Outside of the “assistant” features, which can be added on with a Dot, they can blow away a stand alone 7 inch speaker in every other way possible. I still think stand alone speakers can be convenient, but if the HomePod didn’t have AirPlay capabilities I wouldn’t have any interest in it.
 
HTC, LG, and Huawei.:rolleyes: Then Apple. Going back even further, Samsung had a dual camera phone back in 2007. As for the dual cameras on the S8, they took what others have done and improved on it with user selectable focus on the bokeh effect - during photo taking and after it's been taken.

Any of those have a 2x camera to improve telephoto? Any of them have a depth based portrait mode using the two cameras?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.