Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I just really don't understand the benefit of the nav panel on the left having transparency.

It does nothing but make things a little bit harder to see and read.


View attachment 2539330
To be fair, this doesn't really show/tell the full picture. This only happens if you were to scroll all the categories over; but even then, I'm having a hard time making things look unreadable on my iPad.

Here's what the sidebar looks like when you open the Music app or go to a different screen...there's nothing behind it. I'm usually interacting with the sidebar right away, or scrolling the categories. I rarely do both at once.

1755705299334.png


When I scroll the categories over, I'm still able to see and read everything. Btw, this only applies to the Home, New, and Radio screens. You can't scroll anything behind the sidebar on the other screens, so they look similar to above.

1755705743268.jpeg


If you still don't like it, turn on Reduce Transparency. Remember, this setting can be applied on a per-app basis. So if you don't want it turned on everywhere, you can just turn it on for the Music app, for example.

1755707019864.jpeg


Long story short, you can't really just go by screenshots; it's better to experience it yourself before deciding if you like it or not. I've noticed that some screenshots of Liquid Glass can look busy or overwhelming, but somehow look fine in real life. I don't know how to explain that...maybe something to do with HDR not coming over in the screenshots, so they don't look as vibrant or contrasty than they actually are.
 
To be fair, this doesn't really show/tell the full picture. This only happens if you were to scroll all the categories over; but even then, I'm having a hard time making things look unreadable on my iPad.

Here's what the sidebar looks like when you open the Music app or go to a different screen...there's nothing behind it. I'm usually interacting with the sidebar right away, or scrolling the categories. I rarely do both at once.

View attachment 2539337

When I scroll the categories over, I'm still able to see and read everything. Btw, this only applies to the Home, New, and Radio screens. You can't scroll anything behind the sidebar on the other screens, so they look similar to above.

View attachment 2539338

If you still don't like it, turn on Reduce Transparency. Remember, this setting can be applied on a per-app basis. So if you don't want it turned on everywhere, you can just turn it on for the Music app, for example.

View attachment 2539344

Long story short, you can't really just go by screenshots; it's better to experience it yourself before deciding if you like it or not. I've noticed that some screenshots of Liquid Glass can look busy or overwhelming, but somehow look fine in real life. I don't know how to explain that...maybe something to do with HDR not coming over in the screenshots, so they don't look as vibrant or contrasty than they actually are.

I don't use HDR on macOS (color calibrated here for work), so that won't help unfortunately.
 
Just experimented with "Button Shapes". I'm not a fan.

First pic is Safari with with Reduced Transparency and Button Shapes off
Second is Reduced Transparency off but Button Shapes on
Third is both on
Fourth is mail with Button Shapes off
Fifth is mail with Button Shapes on.

View attachment 2539117

View attachment 2539118

View attachment 2539119

View attachment 2539120

View attachment 2539121
I wish one could have an option that adds the button outlines but doesn’t add button label underlines. Buttons aren’t hyperlinks, and underlined text tends to be harder to read.
 
when is your eye exam?
Y'know, people's eyes work differently. Some people are sensitive to different coloured lights. Some have eyes that over-contrast, some under. Some people are colour-blind. And yes, some have trouble with transparency.

Just because it doesn't affect you, doesn't mean it doesn't affect others. Have some empathy why don't ya?

And oh yeah… One day, if you live long enough, your body will start failing in ways you can't control. You might think you're immortal, but life is laughing its lungs out at you behind your back.

A great goal in life is not to be a dick. You might want to think about that.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.