Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Self Conflict: MacBook Pro or Mac Pro? *Detailed Long Post*

S

Standard

macrumors 6502
Original poster
I will be moving into residence late August for my Web Development & Animation major. I need to purchase a new computer & monitor. Software I will be using includes:

Adobe Photoshop CS3
Adobe Illustrator CS3
Adobe Flash CS3
Coda

Luxology Modo 302
Macintosh® Requirements (minimum)

* Mac® OS X 10.4 or later
* Macintosh® G4, G5 or Intel processor
General System Requirements

* Minimum 1GB RAM
* Minimum 100MB available hard disk space
(3GB required for all content and integrated training materials)
* OpenGL® accelerated graphics card and monitor capable of at least 1024 by 768 screen resolution
* Internet connection required for initial product activation

AutoDesk Maya
Software

The 32-bit version of Autodesk® Maya® 2008 software is supported on any of the following operating systems:

* Microsoft® Windows Vista™ Business
* Microsoft® Windows® XP Professional (SP2 or higher)
* Red Hat® Enterprise Linux® 4.0 WS (U5)
* Fedora™ Core 5
* Apple® Mac OS® X 10.4.9 (PowerPC® and Intel® versions of Maya)
Hardware

At a minimum, the 32-bit version of Maya 2008 software requires a system with the following hardware:

* Windows and Linux: Intel Pentium® 4 or higher, AMD Athlon® 64, or AMD Opteron® processor
* Macintosh®: Power Mac® G5 or Intel®-based Macintosh® computers
* 2 GB RAM
* 2 GB hard disk space
* Qualified hardware-accelerated OpenGL® graphics card
* Three-button mouse with mouse driver software
* DVD-ROM drive

AutoDesk 3ds Max(Yes, BootCamp)
Software

The 32-bit version of Autodesk® 3ds Max® 2009 software is supported on any of the following operating systems:

* Microsoft® Windows Vista®
* Microsoft® Windows® XP Professional (SP2 or higher)
The 64-bit version of 3ds Max 2009 software is supported on any of the following operating systems:

* Microsoft Windows Vista
* Microsoft Windows XP Professional x64

3ds Max 2009 software requires the following browser:

* Microsoft® Internet Explorer® 6 or higher

3ds Max 2009 software requires the following supplemental software:

* DirectX® 9.0c* (required)
Hardware

At a minimum, 3ds Max 2009 32-bit software requires a system with the following:

* Intel® Pentium® 4 or AMD Athlon® XP or higher processor
* 512 MB RAM (1 GB recommended)
* 500 MB swap space (2 GB recommended)
* Hardware-accelerated OpenGL® and Direct3D® supported
* Microsoft Windows–compliant pointing device (optimized for Microsoft® IntelliMouse®)
* DVD-ROM drive

Note: Apple® computers based on Intel processors and running Microsoft operating systems are not currently supported.

At a minimum, 3ds Max 2009 64-bit software requires a system with the following:

* Intel EM64T, AMD Athlon 64 or higher, AMD Opteron® processor
* 1 GB RAM (4 GB recommended)
* 500 MB swap space (2 GB recommended)
* Hardware-accelerated OpenGL and Direct3D supported
* Microsoft Windows–compliant pointing device (optimized IntelliMouse)
* DVD-ROM drive

That sums up my required software (specifications for 3d applications displayed, I know Adobe products will run fine).

I have been a gamer my whole life and will continue to be. These are some games that I would like to play(Yes, BootCamp, I know):

Unreal Tournament III
System requirements Windows XP/Vista

* 2.0 GHz single core CPU (2.4 GHz dual core CPU or faster recommended)
* 512 MB RAM (1.0 GB RAM or greater recommended)
* 8.0 GB hard disk space
* NVIDIA 6200 or ATI 9600 graphics card (NVIDIA 7800GTX or ATI X1300 or faster recommended)
* sound card
* Internet (TCP/IP) and LAN (TCP/IP) play supported.

Crysis System Requirements - Official
Minimum
* OS - Windows XP or Windows Vista
* Processor - 2.8 GHz or faster (XP) or 3.2 GHz or faster* (Vista)
* Memory - 1.0 GB RAM (XP) or 1.5 GB RAM (Vista)
* Video Card -256 MB**
* Hard Drive - 12GB
Recommended
* OS - Windows XP / Vista
* Processor - Intel Core 2 DUO @ 2.2GHz or AMD Athlon 64 X2 4400+
* Memory - 2.0 GB RAM
* GPU - NVIDIA GeForce 8800 GTS/640 or similar
* Sound Card - DirectX 9.0c compatible

The Orange Box
* Processor: Intel Pentium 4 3000 MHz /
* Display Card!: DirectX 9 compatible graphics card /
* Memory: 1024MB
* Free Disk Space: 5GB
* Operating System: Microsoft Windows 2000/XP/Vista

I also play World of Warcraft. I have interest in some newer games that will be coming out and hope to be able to play them. I realize that eye candy may not be set to the max, but how well could I experience these forms of entertainment? I have searched YouTube, watched positive reviews, then I have read credible reviews on notebook/desktop websites producing negative articles.

I am looking at purchasing a 23" Apple Cinema Display or 30" Apple Cinema Display depending on my budget.

Currently I am looking a new MacBook Pro 15" NVIDIA GeForce 8600M GT with 512MB vs a Mac Pro. Depending on the system, which configuration of memory should I get (I know not through Apple). If looking at the Mac Pro, which GPU customizations should I look at?

Portability is not required for my program, but I am highly considering it. Which machine do you recommend and why? How will it perform differently for my work and entertainment uses?

I am looking/hoping to purchase at the end of August before I move into residence on the 29th.

Sorry if this post is redundant...I have done some research on my own filled with mixed views. I am looking for help from professionals such as yourself 😀

Thank you in advance to whoever contributes to this thread constructively.
 
If you can afford it go Mac Pro + 30" ACD
Suggested spec:

Absolute base, in-store* ie 2.8GHZ x2 quad-cores, 2gb ram (upgrade to 16 from owc), 320GB hd (upgrade from owc/bb if you need to), get the ATIs the 8800gts are good but not good with they're price.
 
It seems it's simply a question of how much you need/want processing power versus portability. You get more computer power for your money with a desktop. But if portability is important, no amount of CPU speed will compensate for not having it.

If you need to do work outside your office, or have a strong desire to work outside the office, then portability is a priority is MBP is a good option.

But if speed is the top priority, you can buy a Mac Pro that is faster than any MBP you can buy.

You can also make compromises: buy a low-end Mac Pro and a MacBook. Or buy a less expensive 30" display (e.g. Dell) and put the savings towards a MacBook to complement the Mac Pro.
 
DaveF said:
It seems it's simply a question of how much you need/want processing power versus portability. You get more computer power for your money with a desktop. But if portability is important, no amount of CPU speed will compensate for not having it.

If you need to do work outside your office, or have a strong desire to work outside the office, then portability is a priority is MBP is a good option.

But if speed is the top priority, you can buy a Mac Pro that is faster than any MBP you can buy.

You can also make compromises: buy a low-end Mac Pro and a MacBook. Or buy a less expensive 30" display (e.g. Dell) and put the savings towards a MacBook to complement the Mac Pro.
Click to expand...

I believe I may be required to bring a portable for my internship. How would the latest MBP's fare for my needs/wants? Will rendering time in above listed 3d apps be somewhat efficient? I've read mixed reviews on the MBP's GPU, what do you guys think?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back