Sell my iMacs and assemble 2 PCs?

[Willy S]

Is this a good idea or should I wait until Mac OSX is Intel based?

 

[shadowmoses]

Its really up to you it depends on what you want from your computer,

ShadOW

 

[baummer]

Is this a good idea or should I wait until Mac OSX is Intel based?

Why would you do this?

 

[ITASOR]

Of course it isn't a good idea if you want to run Mac OS X. If you like XP, go ahead.

Or just sell one....why do you need two iMacs?

 

[danny_w]

Is this a good idea or should I wait until Mac OSX is Intel based?

Why??? I just switched from Windows/Linux to Mac and will NEVER go back! I was tired of constantly fighting with and maintaining my pc (virii, spyware/malware, software conflicts, etc. etc. etc.). Since getting my mini I have been able to actually USE my computer instead of FIGHTING my computer. Why on earth would anybody want to go backwards, regardless of how many you can have? Please explain.

 

[camomac]

i thought to myself, well, um NO. but then i was thinking about you post. are you selling those mac's to get a PC's to run OSX on? if so then it is an even WORSE idea.

hopefully this is not what you were thinking.

 

[AmigoMac]

If you're asking yourself this, do it. Now tell us, why you wouldn't.

 

[ITASOR]

Hmm. Perhaps you could keep both iMacs and buy a PC too!

...At least I think this is what the MacRumors ads are suggesting...

 

[tristan]

Should I sell my Powerbook and buy two dell desktops? Should I sell my Porsche Boxster and buy two Ford Festivas? Should I sell my Trump Tower condo and buy two crackhouses in East St. Louis?

I'm thinking... no.

 

[feakbeak]

Should I sell my Powerbook and buy two dell desktops? Should I sell my Porsche Boxster and buy two Ford Festivas? Should I sell my Trump Tower condo and buy two crackhouses in East St. Louis?

I'm thinking... no.

Um... yeah... all Macs are far superior to PCs, of course.

Perhaps he's getting rid of two G3 iMacs and plans to build some Athlond X2 sytems. I'd take a pimped-out X2 system over 10 iMac G3's. When it comes to hardware, form factor, OS, software... it's all a matter of preference.

 

[fartheststar]

The original post doesn't really explain why you would want to do this or not do this. I suppose it depends on what you want to do.

 

[tristan]

Okay, sure maybe he has lab full of 1st generation iMacs with big cracks in the screens and monkey poop all over them and he has the option to trade them for two 8-way Opterons running a copy of Linux tweaked by Linus himself during his last three-day crystal meth binge. I guess I never saw that as a potential possibility.

Yeah, this guy hasn't posted again so we don't know exactly what his situation is or what his goals are. But in general principle, you can only use one computer a time, so you probably want one good one rather than two equally crappy ones.

 

[Jesus]

Um... yeah... all Macs are far superior to PCs, of course.

Perhaps he's getting rid of two G3 iMacs and plans to build some Athlond X2 sytems. I'd take a pimped-out X2 system over 10 iMac G3's. When it comes to hardware, form factor, OS, software... it's all a matter of preference.

he has two iMac G5s, both rev a, one 1.8ghz, with a superdrive, one 1.6ghz, with a combo drive, read the singnature...

Kapeesh




Jesus


Edit: why not sell both your iMac G5s[on ebay] and buy a Top Of The Range PowerMac G5 system with an Apple Display......

 

[plinden]

I'm scratching my head over this one - Willy S's first post was back in May (https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/125352/), where he was asking whether he should buy an eMac or a Mini, and here he is 3 months later wondering if he should sell both his Rev A G5 iMacs to build a PC ...

 

[feakbeak]

read the singnature...

Some of us have our options to not display signatures, so that was just by chance.

tristanp, your provided examples (Trump Tower Condo for crack houses) is far more extreme than G3 iMacs and an X2 system. Also, your second example of an eight way Opteron is also rather extreme. A powerful X2 system can be built for less than $2000.

As man here have said, we don't know what the OP needs are or the details of the situation. Still, I stick to my assertion that is all depends on the specifics, your preferences and intended use. Blanket statements that Macs are generically better than PCs are pointless and unfounded.

 

[tristan]

You're completely missing 80% of point of my post, which was that it's silly to buy two identical computers, cars, or houses. Unless you run a test lab or you have an afternoon appointment with Clones R' Us.

But sure, you caught the other 20% of my post which is that Macs are better than PCs. Well, excuse me for stating the obvious! And you know what else? The sky is blue! Rain is wet! Gravity sucks! Sorry if all that offends you.

 

[risc]

Mmm... flame bait

To the OP what do you actually want to do with the computer? Personally I think you should of actually included information about what you wanted to do, why you are considering selling your Macs, etc. Without doing this all you've done is create a nice troll.

 

[Xephian]

Sell one iMac and build a PC at http://www.NewEgg.com. I think it's a good to have one PC and one Mac. They both have their good and bad sides.

 

[Hattig]

Sell the iMac you use least and build your own PC with components from your favourite online store.

I could never go back to using Windows willingly however. I never turn on the (still nicely specced 2GHz Athlon XP) 30 month old PC upstairs any longer, even though it is connected to a nice 19" TFT monitor. I just use this dinky 12" iBook which I've set up on a nice desk downstairs away from the clutter.

Getting things done on the computer beats getting annoyed with the frustrations and limitations of Windows XP.

 

[feakbeak]

And you know what else? The sky is blue! Rain is wet! Gravity sucks! Sorry if all that offends you.

I AM

Sorry for missing the other part of your post. I wasn't thinking about that. We don't know if they'd be identical PCs or if one would be for gaming and another as an email station type machine. Peronally, I couldn't have too many machines, even if some were identical so that didn't occur to me. Maybe he has two homes or one computer is for the kids... we need more info, until then who knows. I think the original post may have been flame bait as another poster said. The poster is not a newb though.

Come on, Willy S, tell us what's going on.

 

[tristan]

I'm still an apprentice of the obvious.

I was basically just being silly at his expense. Yeah, the guy gave us so little information to go on we'll never know what was up or why he wanted to trade a mac for a PC. Maybe he had a good reason, maybe he's an agent of evil, or maybe he's just a poor misguided soul who didn't get enough hugs growing up. We'll just have to speculate.

 

[Mord]

if you live in the uk i'll trade a socket 939 3000+ pc with an x800XT 512MB ram for an imac g5.

 

[iEdd]

1PC = spyware
2PC's =10^2 spyware
3PC's =10^3 spyware

PCs suck. Linux makes them bearable... Windows is pathetic.
Removing macs and adding PCs is a dumb idea. Don't do it.

7000+Virii for windows this year alone
26 for mac os 1-9
0 for mac os X

I know this isn't a PC bitchfest session, but argh..

 

[mojohanna]

Is this a good idea or should I wait until Mac OSX is Intel based?

Yo... You nuts???? I am completely biased when I say this, but there is not one thing that I can think of that I would need a PC for other than to beat with a sledgehammer in order to release some frustrations. You have two sweet machines that most would be jealous to have.

 

[Willy S]

Do I want Windows? No! (please! give me a little credit)

Do I want Linux? No!

The reason for my post is that I read that someone had cracked the developers edition of Mac OSX so it can be used for a PC. Also Apple is mad about this and made its lawyers work overtime (wonder why if it wasn´t true)

Therefore one should think you could install a Mac OSX on any cheap PC in the near future..