Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

geraldem

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Dec 16, 2015
261
159
For the past few years I have always had a iPhone and a Samsung Note. I love being able to take my ATT SIM and swapping it between the two devices. It has never been an issue and always worked without problem. BUT NOW, with my new Apple Series 3 Watch with LTE, I don’t believe I can continue this approach. My understanding of NUMSYNC and how it works...if I change the SIM, and put into back into my Note8, it will break the NUMSYNC setup and my Apple Watch will no longer work when I eventually switch back to the Apple ecosystem.

Anyone have any experience or opinion on this. I really don’t want to try it as it took me 2 1/2 hours to get the Apple Watch setup with ATT.
Thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aston441
I would be curious about this as well. I do the same - switch between Android and iOS frequently. Unfortunately I can not test seeing I sold my S8 a few weeks (waiting for my Pixel 2 XL).

My initial guess would be it should not break anything. NumberSync is a switch-level feature where the two numbers are mated. NOW there could be issues with Notifications on the watch and some SMS/iMessage issues. The folks over at iMore did this and it seemed to work well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: profets
It won't break the setup at the carrier - the association between the AT&T SIM and the eSIM in the watch is maintained. However, the Watch will work the same as if you had the iPhone turned off - ie no SMS forwarding, nor voice calling.

All of the features of the watch will be restored when you put the SIM back into the iPhone.

Enjoy it while it lasts....you know Apple getting the carriers to support eSIMs is a pre-cursor to doing the same in the iPhone. (likely not until 2019 though....will take that long to get the carriers around the world supporting eSIM provisioning). Mind you, they could do it in 2018...just have different SKU's for those carriers that aren't onboard yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lordofthereef
I wanted to know this as well....I have the Note 8 and the Iphone 8 Plus/series 3 LTE combo. I switched my sim from the Iphone 8 plus to the Note 8 and used it all day on yesterday. This morning I removed the sim from the Note 8 and put it back in the Iphone 8 plus. I tried to make a call from the watch (with wifi and bluetooth turned off on the Iphone) and it worked so it seems to be working fine so far...I have not tried text messaging yet.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Aston441
On t mobile. I do this everyday.
Phone call works. I am not sure about text because i only know iphone users.
 
I have a Note 8/S3 Frontier and also an AWS3LTE I use with my iPhone SE (waiting for iPhone X). I switch my SIM between the Note and the iPhone frequently and my AWS3LTE has worked fine. However, I believe you can only have NumberSync set up between your SIM and one other wearable because shortly after I set up my AWS3LTE I got a text message that NumberSync for my S3 Frontier was canceled.

And by the way, so glad to see other folks switching between the Note and iPhone. My wife thinks I'm insane! The Note is such beautiful hardware, but I am pretty entrenched in iOS/iCloud, so I can't go all-in with Samsung. I wish I could just decide on one or the other, but I can't!
 
  • Like
Reactions: denisej
I have a Note 8/S3 Frontier and also an AWS3LTE I use with my iPhone SE (waiting for iPhone X). I switch my SIM between the Note and the iPhone frequently and my AWS3LTE has worked fine. However, I believe you can only have NumberSync set up between your SIM and one other wearable because shortly after I set up my AWS3LTE I got a text message that NumberSync for my S3 Frontier was canceled.

And by the way, so glad to see other folks switching between the Note and iPhone. My wife thinks I'm insane! The Note is such beautiful hardware, but I am pretty entrenched in iOS/iCloud, so I can't go all-in with Samsung. I wish I could just decide on one or the other, but I can't!
No....you are definitely not alone...lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aston441
I have a Note 8/S3 Frontier and also an AWS3LTE I use with my iPhone SE (waiting for iPhone X). I switch my SIM between the Note and the iPhone frequently and my AWS3LTE has worked fine. However, I believe you can only have NumberSync set up between your SIM and one other wearable because shortly after I set up my AWS3LTE I got a text message that NumberSync for my S3 Frontier was canceled.

And by the way, so glad to see other folks switching between the Note and iPhone. My wife thinks I'm insane! The Note is such beautiful hardware, but I am pretty entrenched in iOS/iCloud, so I can't go all-in with Samsung. I wish I could just decide on one or the other, but I can't!
We are probably a small group, but probably all have the same likes. Spot on regarding the Note hardware...amazing. Love it. But I too am so entrenched in the Apple ecosystem, it is hard to not use. So I too “suffer” with not being able to make a decision. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: denisej
I have a galaxy S8 and if I choose to use it with the Apple Watch (even with the series 2, that doesn’t have cellular), I simply just connect the watch to the S8 via cellular hotspot. My iPhone is sitting at home connected to wifi on the charger. Notifications easily come in and this saves battery on the watch.
 
I carry galaxy everyday because of Samsung pay. I don't carry cc or cash or wallet.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.