• Did you order new AirTags? We've opened a dedicated AirTags forum.

_LeaFy_

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 12, 2016
44
10
Hi guys,
I'm wondering if I should buy macbook air or ipad pro. They have almost similar prices (ipad 128gb), but the only thing i'm worried about is the macbook air display, is it like bad? In my pc I have 2k display.
I'm gonna use this device for traveling, watching movies, surfing the internet and all this stuff which I do on PC except of gaming. Now I own ipad 4 and I feel that I need an upgrade. What should I buy?
 

jarodlee88

macrumors member
Jun 12, 2016
40
14
If you do not need to use any desktop apps, get the iPad Pro. It's way better for traveling as it is extremely portable. You will definitely have a better experience watching movies on the iPad Pro compared to the MacBook Air due to the higher res display and better speakers.
 
Comment

sracer

macrumors G3
Apr 9, 2010
8,956
10,044
where hip is spoken
Hi guys,
I'm wondering if I should buy macbook air or ipad pro. They have almost similar prices (ipad 128gb), but the only thing i'm worried about is the macbook air display, is it like bad? In my pc I have 2k display.
I'm gonna use this device for traveling, watching movies, surfing the internet and all this stuff which I do on PC except of gaming. Now I own ipad 4 and I feel that I need an upgrade. What should I buy?
I've bolded the important point.

Regarding the MBA's screen quality, it is highly subjective. For those with Marvel Superhero macro vision, the MBA screens are pixelated and blurry messes. For the average human being, the screen is fine and acceptable. Only you know if you are a Marvel Superhero or a mere mortal.

I have both a 12.9 iPad Pro and a 11" Macbook Air. If I was going to travel and needed to do "stuff that I do on my iMac" then I would have to take the MBA. As a day-to-day mobile device, I use my iPP since it can handle most of my "mobile tasks" and on those occasions where I need to do OSX-type things, I remote into my iMac using Jump Desktop.

As the iOS apps that I use improve, I'm finding fewer and fewer reasons to remote into my iMac. For all of the things that I do an iPad no matter how Pro it is, could never replace my iMac. But it is working pretty well as a hybrid device.

The questions to ask yourself, "what things do I do on a PC that I need to be able to do on the road?" "how important is it for me to be able to do those things?" "Are there alternative ways of getting those tasks done and do those ways exist on iOS?"
 
Comment

_LeaFy_

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 12, 2016
44
10
Well, the only thing I was unsure about was the screen, I guess I'm gonna go to the shop and see what it looks like but I think I will go with the macbook, because in the car or plane the Ipad 4 is still good for watching movies but in a long usage, the iOS is just boring to use, so I hope macbook will be fine.
 
Comment

theluggage

macrumors 603
Jul 29, 2011
5,103
4,136
is the macbook air display, is it like bad?

It is perfectly usable, but out-of-date and low resolution. Even your iPad 4 has a high-pixel-density "retina" display that will give sharper text and images than the MBA. The reason for getting the Air is if you need to run full-fat OS X laptop/desktop applications.

The iPad Pro display is better than the MacBook Air (insofar as you can compare different sizes).

You've got an iPad 4 - the iPad Pro is going to be a useful upgrade from this, but not drastically different. You should be able to judge whether an iPad is going to meet all your needs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jarodlee88
Comment

evec

macrumors regular
Jun 8, 2016
228
68
It depending on should you want keyboard for input, as macbook with fully multi-tasking desktop environment with faster internet browsing.
If you just require surfing internet or simple task, get IPAD PRO.
You can also review Macbook12 with good display and light as iPad Pro, however slightly expensive.

As MBA is low resolution, the contrast is not bad and less reflection, make it more suitable for long editing and good for outdoor usage.

As OSX install VLC you can view all format video with long battery life, in IOS viewing unsupported format will get very bad performance, become very hot and high battery quick drain.

MBA 13 have better display that 11 and it 16:10, start config with 8GB which is essential for today OSX system.
 
Comment

Lapine Rider

macrumors member
May 15, 2010
31
48
My solution was to get a 12" Mac Book Retina, for not a whole lot more. Great screen, full capabilities (or at least all the capabilities I actually need), and in my own (experienced) opinion every bit as real-world portable as an iPad with keyboard. I'm very pleased with it after three months, and more so every day. The only downside is that it's indeed a bit less convenient to read a book or watch a movie on a laptop as opposed to a tablet. But that's true of the MBA as well.
 
Comment

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Jul 29, 2008
55,152
38,532
The Far Horizon
It depends on what you wish to actually do with the computer.

Think of the difference as follows: For consuming content, the iPad is excellent. That is, if you want to download stuff, surf, and so on. Here, the retina screen of the iPad will probably also come into its own.

However, for creating content - anything that requires any sort of decent writing, the 11" MBA is without equal as it is a fully fledged computer with a proper keyboard, and it exceedingly portable, powerful and a computer that comes with excellent battery life, too.
 
Comment

_LeaFy_

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 12, 2016
44
10
I guess I will just buy macbook 12, 2015 model.
 
Comment

Pugly

macrumors 6502
Jun 7, 2016
275
228
I really like iPads, but for me the novelty has kind of warned off. You can do amazing things on them, but I'm just not as fast or precise on an iPad as I am on a laptop.

The issue is touch interfaces, while intuitive and great for lots of things... it just takes up too much space on the screen. And if you plan to attach a keyboard all the time anyways... might as well get a laptop at that point.

The MacBook airs screen works fine, but if the screen is what you care about most... it's really not the device for you.
 
Comment

alex2792

macrumors 6502a
Jun 13, 2009
906
2,368
Well that really depends on what that "other stuff" you do on your PC is. If it's anything productivity related then the MacBook Air is a no brainer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Comment

Cheffy Dave

macrumors 68030
I've bolded the important point.

Regarding the MBA's screen quality, it is highly subjective. For those with Marvel Superhero macro vision, the MBA screens are pixelated and blurry messes. For the average human being, the screen is fine and acceptable. Only you know if you are a Marvel Superhero or a mere mortal.

I have both a 12.9 iPad Pro and a 11" Macbook Air. If I was going to travel and needed to do "stuff that I do on my iMac" then I would have to take the MBA. As a day-to-day mobile device, I use my iPP since it can handle most of my "mobile tasks" and on those occasions where I need to do OSX-type things, I remote into my iMac using Jump Desktop.

As the iOS apps that I use improve, I'm finding fewer and fewer reasons to remote into my iMac. For all of the things that I do an iPad no matter how Pro it is, could never replace my iMac. But it is working pretty well as a hybrid device.

The questions to ask yourself, "what things do I do on a PC that I need to be able to do on the road?" "how important is it for me to be able to do those things?" "Are there alternative ways of getting those tasks done and do those ways exist on iOS?"


To the point!
 
Comment

_LeaFy_

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 12, 2016
44
10
I've just got the macbook 12 2016 model and I'm not disappointed. It's really thin and light and the screen is amazing. I was worried about the keyboard but it actually feels really nice.
 
Comment

Wackery

macrumors 6502a
Feb 1, 2015
978
952
the screen on the air really isnt that bad, for entertainment purposes the ipad pro is better, for more versatility in terms of running programs and work i would recommend the air. they're both good tho
 
Last edited:
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.