I'm glad to see all the positive opinions about Gazelle on here. I currently work at Gazelle, doing web design and pricing on the sell side, and I can guarantee that we are a totally legitimate business. As a matter of fact, I have never worked for a company that valued it's customers more than Gazelle does. We are still a relatively small company (we just added phone support last week), but we are honest with our payouts, and we definitely do not scam anyone. We evaluate items that you send in based on our completely static grading system, and while we do sometimes lower the offer based on condition discrepancy, we frequently raise the offer for the same reason.
We just got a TON of iPads in - the day of the iPad 2 launch was our busiest day ever - so keep your eyes peeled on our eBay store in the next few weeks if you are looking for a very reasonably priced original iPad (we have to sell these things somehow, right?)
I like this board and it's members, and I've been an active member here for years, so please feel free to use me as a point of contact in any future Gazelle transactions, should the need arise. Thanks!