It does indeed learn, but incredibly slow. After typing a few phrases repeatedly for maybe soon a year, they come fully or partly as an suggestion, that is something that happened recently however.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Small Number of SwiftKey Users Discover App Leaked Private Data to Strangers
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I use the spell-checking without AutoTypo.
I ignore all the instances of BS and get to enjoy seeing the occasional snafu which I otherwise wouldn't have seen right away.
Yeah, it's a bit annoying when your iMessage typing looks like a new installation of Word without custom dictionary entries and ignores set up, but oh well...
Glassed Silver:mac
No, it's not simple, because in that way, third party keyboards will be considerably inferior on iOS than on competing platforms, and some thing would be completely impossible, like the GIPHY keyboard, or the GBoard, or learning from multiple users at all time.
And the stock keyboard is everything but awful, if Apple's is awful, I can't describe Google's keyboard for Android or the laggy Swiftkey (and it's laggy everywhere, on Android top-of-the-line phones, not just on iOS)
It's awful not because it's awful at what it does, but that Apple keeps insisting not to implement Swype-type functionality or any other kind of faster typing.
And I wasn't talking about anyone else or what Apple should allow in the App Store, I was speaking for myself only.
Any keyboard that wants internet access to function got deleted from my phone/iPad.
As for GIPHY, I don't have that keyboard, but I wouldn't consider it a keyboard in the traditional sense, so to load some gifs and type nothing else in it, I guess I could live with it, but I have yet to download and try it.
As for "traditional typing" if you will: internet access needed → home screen → wiggle mode → X
Again, that's how I do it, what anyone else does with these sorts of keyboards is up to them.
Glassed Silver:mac
This. 100% this. Apple should definitely add a swipe option to their keyboard. My wife and daughter both use Swype and, no hyperbole, they blaze so quickly across the keyboard. It looks like they are simply spreading finger grease on their screens. Somehow words magically appear. Their only complaints seem to be glitches caused by Apple's limitations. Apple could easily license the tech and make the stock keyboard better.
C'mon Apple listen to Teddy KGB in Rounders: "Pay him... pay that man his money."
While I agree with the whole swipe/glide option being overdue at this point, I have to say that that great Rounders line that is a favorite of mine is what really got me.
It's awful not because it's awful at what it does, but that Apple keeps insisting not to implement Swype-type functionality or any other kind of faster typing.
And I wasn't talking about anyone else or what Apple should allow in the App Store, I was speaking for myself only.
Any keyboard that wants internet access to function got deleted from my phone/iPad.
As for GIPHY, I don't have that keyboard, but I wouldn't consider it a keyboard in the traditional sense, so to load some gifs and type nothing else in it, I guess I could live with it, but I have yet to download and try it.
As for "traditional typing" if you will: internet access needed → home screen → wiggle mode → X
Again, that's how I do it, what anyone else does with these sorts of keyboards is up to them.
Glassed Silver:mac
"It doesn't have the feature that I want" --> it's awful
That's not how "awful" it works.
And if you don't want internet access, you can disable it.
So can someone explain this further. How can swiftkey data of one user be transferred to another user by the initial user returning the device and the second user buying said device? That makes no sense. If that's true it would mean it's an iOS security issue with iCloud not being completely wiped from the device.
I don't believe it's iCloud or anything from Apple that's in question here, but SwitKey's own cloud service that they use for sync type of purposes: https://support.swiftkey.com/hc/en-us/sections/200442552-SwiftKey-Cloud-Account-Personalization-
As for personal judgement, yes that's how it works.
There are MUCH better keyboards, but they are held back not by their makers, but Apple's shoddy implementation of 3rd-party keyboards.
I know, but I was specifically talking about the keyboards that will refuse to be functional at all.
At least when I tried them there were a couple that needed you to grant them full permission otherwise they wouldn't work.
Glassed Silver:mac
Why not just create a text expansion snippet for that? Set a trigger like "sgh" that will expand to become "Sugar Hill".
Wasn't swiftkey acquired by Microsoft? Guess they really do turn everything they touch to ****.
Yeah, they are part of Microsoft as of a few months ago or so. That said, Microsoft has been and is doing fine, and this probably doesn't have much to do with them as it was in place before Microsoft acquired them.
I'd love a reliable alt keyboard, but for it to be useful it must be predictive past fixing typos. And that’s the sticking point for me right there. It has to gather at least some data about me, and in permitting that then I may put at risk info I’d rather not see distributed more widely. It’s hard to see how a company can actually make assurances that a “glitch” won’t happen. Even the best of apps can have "one or two"
As far as testing any new app, I can be enthusiastic but I'm also wary. I might think I need it or want it, but what I don't need is something half-baked or misbehaving to the point of causing me to wipe my device and start over. How many times do I want to wonder if my personal data was compromised anyway?
So I maintain an extra iPod touch with an isolated username setup and only the stock iOS permanently maintained on it. When I’m interested in a new app, I download it onto that device for openers. I want to see what it asks for and how it behaves for awhile. Some apps never get past that step.
But if I like the app then I put a special throwaway mail account on my testing device and use it to surf the news sites like AP or Reuters for a while, mailing links from it to another dummy account that I have on an old iPad Mini (also having only a stock setup on it).
And so forth -- gradually widening the test device’s window on the world and checking to see how the new app behaves in assorted circumstances. If I have questions or concerns, this is the timeframe in which I ask developers questions.
If after awhile I haven’t noticed any weird behavior while using the app as well as the browser and test mail account, then I ditch the test setups, cleaning off the testing devices so they’re ready for use again sometime. LOL well it’s a way to justify having the old gear around anyway.
Final step: think whether I really need that app, and then if I like it enough, install it on my iPhone or iPad.
I'd love to have an alt keyboard that could pass that shakeout. So far? Still waiting.
In response to the image you submitted as a post without additional comment, suggesting I have won the tinfoil hat award for my earlier post: I accept your opinion as a compliment to my hard work to ensure that I don't end up with truly dysfunctional apps on my computing gear.
It sounds like the problem is that he forgot to delete that phone from his list of shared Swiftkey devices. (Or he did but it did not take.)
Thus when the next person bought the phone and installed Swiftkey, the device association was still active and continued to share his personal suggestions.
If so, one fix might be for Swiftkey to also match a user id along with the device id.
You can enable "Full Access", NOT use the sync feature and this issue wouldn't affect you at all.
The two really aren't related. To suggest they are, means a completely lack of understanding (or maybe ignorance) on the issue.
No they didn't. They promised, right there on the screen of your phone, "Full access allows the developer of this keyboard to transmit anything you type, including things you previously typed with this keyboard. This could include sensitive information such as your credit card number or street address." And you clicked "Allow".
Ok, thanks for sharing your ignorance.
You go right ahead and blame your fridge that it can't keep food cold after you stopped paying your electricity bills.
So is that a yes or a no? Seems like I asked a simple question multiple times and all that's coming back are deflections and ad hominems (which I guess indirectly answers even more than that question).
Last edited:
You might as well ask me what colour the sky is. We all know the answer, but it's not relevant.