Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So I WENT To New York (First Time)

I'd like to post my impressions and experience and how everything went during the few days that I was there. So here goes...

1. Times Square at night is... magical. My wife and I took the subway into Times Square (walked off the train around 7:30) and as we walked through the subway tunnels toward the Times Square exit, we could hear the cars and people buzzing about. It built an epic amount of anticipation and emotion inside of us as we walk with the cool air hitting our face. Then, stepping up off the last step onto the sidewalk and seeing the lights all around was just breath taking. The feeling that coursed through my body was just electric and exhilarating. There exists nothing like Times Square anywhere else in the United States, and it is obvious why. The excitement is inside of EVERYONE there and it constantly felt like something amazing was about to happen. Do yourself a favor, and the first time you visit Times Square, take the Subway in and walk out of a tunnel at night, it is electrifying.

2. THANK GOD FOR MY iPhone/Google Maps/KickMap. I don't know how I would have made it around Manhattan without constantly looking up what subways and buses to take to get to the different stores. The 24 Hour KickMap APP from the appstore is probably one of the best tools for anybody about to visit NYC. I found it very helpful in being able to see when and where each subway line was going and what intersects it to get me to other places. KickMap + Google Maps on iPhone = WIN! I would have made it nowhere without it!

3. Thanks to everybody on restaurant and sight seeing suggestions. I didn't have time to do everything I wanted to, and in some cases I avoided things all together based on you guys suggestions from the original thread. Probably the best thing I did was visit Rockafeller Plaza/Tower and take a trip to the Top of the ROCK + NBC Studio tour. I got to see John Malkovich, Amy Poehler, Seth Meyers and Darrell Hammond rehearsing during the NBC studios tour. The top of the rock definitely gives an awe inspiring view of Manhattan and it was just fantastic seeing the Rockafeller Christmas Tree. That entire plaza is just BUZZING with people and excitement.

4. If you are going to be near Ground Zero, eat at the Essex World Cafe! I found this gem of a restaurant by accident while searching for places near Ground Zero to eat breakfast. They serve you an INSANE amount of food for very very cheap and it is all packed onto a Dixie plate, which gives it a real hearty breakfast kinda feel. They also have on hand the BIG boxes of orange juice, not the tiny little kind that you find in a kiddie lunch. This made the breakfast all the better. Much Food + Much Drink = AWESOME Breakfast. Definitely eat there if you have the chance.

5. NEVER take a taxi to/from La Guardia. All I have to say is $70. I was warned on here, but it was real cold, my wife was very tired (and pregnant) and we were both desperately hungry.

6. Take the subways/buses everywhere. It is so cheap to buy an MTA card that works for both buses and subways, you use them all day long most of the time and honestly, unless you plan on walking the skin off your feet, you HAVE to take the subways/buses to get a decent amount done during the day.

----------

Final Thoughts:

Would I ever want to MOVE to NYC?

I would have to say no. Living in San Antonio and having a vehicle to drive has spoiled me. What took me all day long to do in New York, I could have done in 3 or 4 hours in San Antonio. The reason why is because everything in NYC is PACKED into Manhattan and there isn't anywhere to park a vehicle (except for the extremely expensive and hard to get into/out of parking garages).

In San Antonio, I can drive and park in front of any store in the city and there are several malls that have stores around that that are very easy to access. In addition to this, we spent so much time on the Subway and Buses that it took a very long time to get to/from "home" (our hotel room). I guess this is a result of us staying in an apartment in East Elmhearst (near La Guardia), but it seems like many people live outside of Manhattan (at least from what I could tell). Almost no matter where you live out of Manhattan, it would take you at LEAST 30 mins to 90 mins to get home. I can get to and from anywhere in San Antonio in 45 minutes MAX in my vehicle, and that is with TERRIBLE traffic (which there isn't alot of here). Most points of interest can be accessed in less than 15 minutes.

I know this is just San Antonio, but this is ME we are talking about here.

It WAS good to "be with the people," though. Growing up, I took the city bus everywhere, and being on the Subways in NYC gave me that feeling back, and it is a good feeling being with the people.

The TAXI drivers are CRAZY, the pretzels are cold, and I heard more honks in my first 5 minutes in NYC than I have ever heard in my life (Seriously! Nobody ever honks here in Texas [except Houston and the crazy parts of Dallas]).

Let me stress this: THE PRETZELS ARE COLD! The corner stands say "Hot Pretzels," but they give you the ones that have been sitting out in the cold for lord knows how long and if you try and argue with them they don't give a crap.

Ground Zero is an emotionally confusing place. It is imperative that you see the tribute center across the street from ground zero (2 or 3 shops down from the Essex World Cafe) and almost more imperative to take one of the tours that they offer. They do a really good job of telling the story and showing you the things that you would have missed otherwise.

I say it is emotionally confusing because unless you are hearing one of these first hand accounts from the tour guides, the entire place looks just like a huge construction site (which, incidentally, it is). The emotion is lost if you don't know the significance of the buildings around it, what has been rebuilt, why certain buildings are covered in plastic, why a memorial was built in this specific place, etc. I would say the tours that the tribute center offer are great because you get all the emotion from the tour guides (who all have a first hand account of 9/11), and you get taken to the important places to visit.

I don't hesitate to say that the best view of the Statue of Liberty is from Battery Park. You get a 100% unobstructed view of Lady Liberty from across the bay and it is majestic. Seeing the water glimmer and the statue there in all its glory is fantastic. The view from across the bay is unmatched, even if you go onto the island where the statue sits. Take some pictures from across the bay, you won't regret it.

Also, quick note for people in the other thread. It did in fact FLURRY on the final night I was there, which many though it would not do. I was happy to at least see the flurries. I got to see plenty of snow during my 15 minute stop at Chicago's O'Hare Airport. It was 8 degrees Fahrenheit on our way back to San Antonio.

Anyway, there is a lot that I forgot, but I just thought I would let some of the people who contributed to my original thread know that I made it and I had fun and I thank them for their input.

PLEASE ask questions, I love answering questions.
 
Glad to hear you enjoyed New York. I would suggest to anyone that hasn't visited yet, to do so. I think you hit on some good points for people to see (Times Square, Ground Zero, State of Liberty, etc.)

- Did you get a chance to skate at Rockefeller Center?
- Did you visit the Apple Store (5th & 59th)?
- Did you see the characters of Times Square (Naked cowlady & the drunk crossdresser guy in a dress)?
- Did you see any shows?

I LOL'd when I read the part about honking. When I moved out to NY after growing up in the Bay Area, the first thing I noticed was how quick New Yorkers are to honk after a stop light turns green. Funny part is when I moved back to CA, I noticed how quiet it was.

And yes, Times Square is magical. I spent four years in NY and when I go back to visit, I still look around like its my first time.
 
I went to NY in 2000, had a good time. But the trip sure did start with a bang, literally.

We were saying in a Hostel somewhere near Central Park. This was our second Hostel choice, as a few of us refused to stay at the first one when we saw the street it was on. We walked across the street that night to go to the liquor store. We were in there for a few minutes when we heard gun shots outside the door somewhere. 10 minutes later the ambulances were carting off a few folks. We left the next day and stayed somewhere near the financial district where the hotel was more expensive but MUCH safer. I'll never forget that trip though!
 
random q: do you think it'd be alright to take a dslr out to the places mentioned above?

i think there'd be a lot of great shots out there for someone who has never been to n.y.: you notice things that other people have gotten used to/taken for granted.
 
Glad to hear you enjoyed New York. I would suggest to anyone that hasn't visited yet, to do so. I think you hit on some good points for people to see (Times Square, Ground Zero, State of Liberty, etc.)

- Did you get a chance to skate at Rockefeller Center?
- Did you visit the Apple Store (5th & 59th)?
- Did you see the characters of Times Square (Naked cowlady & the drunk crossdresser guy in a dress)?
- Did you see any shows?

I LOL'd when I read the part about honking. When I moved out to NY after growing up in the Bay Area, the first thing I noticed was how quick New Yorkers are to honk after a stop light turns green. Funny part is when I moved back to CA, I noticed how quiet it was.

And yes, Times Square is magical. I spent four years in NY and when I go back to visit, I still look around like its my first time.


We didn't skate in the rink because my wife is pregnant and she didn't want to fall. We saw what we think was the naked cowboy except he wasn't wearing the USA underwear he was wearing something else. Didn't see the crossdressing dude. I assure you we saw plenty of "characters" I'm general haha. I did make it a point to visit the apple cube store. It was even more awesome than I had imagined. I wanted to visit the one on 14th and 9th but didn't have the chance. We didn't have the chance to see a show though, which I kinda regret but we did have an awesome dinner at the ESPN zone during the Florida Alabama and OU mizzou gAmes. They required we spend 10 bucks for every hour we were there but the raucous atmosphere was worth every penny. Not to mention I had some awesome ribs.

I still can't get over the honking thing. My wife and I still look at eachoter and laugh the very few times we have heard people honk here at home. It's just hilarious. I'm still pissed I wasted 6 bucks on cold pretzels though haha.
 
So I WENT To New York (First Time)

random q: do you think it'd be alright to take a dslr out to the places mentioned above?

i think there'd be a lot of great shots out there for someone who has never been to n.y.: you notice things that other people have gotten used to/taken for granted.

Yeah man there was a tom of people with dslr's out there. I really wish I had one to take some shots of lady liberty from across the bay. I can imagine how beautiful a shot that would be. I wish I could have had a nice dslr to shoot down broadway and catch all the lights in one shot. I have some pictures I am gonna upload to my MobileMe that I can share with you all.

But yeah take an slr if you have one just keep it around your neck at all times.
 
I'd like to post my impressions and experience and how everything went during the few days that I was there. So here goes...

1. Times Square at night is...

2. THANK GOD FOR MY iPhone/Google

6. Take the subways/buses everywhere.

Don't want to put a downer on your experience or anything, but..

My other half and I had 6 days in NYC in June (we live in the UK), and while she (and you it appears ) loved Time Square - I just don't get it. We arrived in the way you described, and I didn't really see what the fuss about two large streets, a lot of people, and some large TV's. It would not be in my must-visit list for NYC next time around.

Believe it or not, people managed to navigate NYC quite well before/without iPhone. We did - very well. We had some maps, and if in doubt, we just asked people and without fail, they were brilliantly helpfull - from the lovely young lady on the subway station near the AMNH who had a kitten in a basket she was taking home from the Vet, to the huge intimidating guy next to us waiting for the subway back from the Yankees stadium. I'd much much rather have had that experience, than known exactly where I was going with my head in a cell-phone half the time.

I agree with the bus/subway. We got a week long card - it paid for itself by mid-week.

Anyway -glad you had a good time. Highlight from our visit was a circle-line sunset boat trip, and the Empire State at Night. It's an amazing city - we've got a short re-visit already in the planning.
 
I'd much much rather have had that experience, than known exactly where I was going with my head in a cell-phone half the time.

The point was that I didn't need to have my head buried in the phone. I look at the kickmap, and it showed me where the nearest station was, we walked there and I just followed the numbers. It wasn't a long, arduous process where I had to search and dig and prod for information. I looked at where we wanted to be, found the nearest number around it on the map, look where we currently were, found the nearest number and connected the dots. I am just saying that it made it easy for me to find my way.

I suppose some people would find the "being lost" feeling as part of the experience. Or at least the "asking the people" feeling as part of the experience. But I found I was personally more satisfied being able to find our way around on our own. I never had to ask anyone for anything except the occasional subway station teller guy, to ask him if we were on the correct side of the street to go in the direction we wanted. I could find any store, anytime, anywhere, using only the GPS on my phone and the built in google maps. I don't feel like I was ever "buried" in my phone, but I can understand what you mean.

I just feel like my phone was way more useful to me as a tourist than was any tourist map, tourist guide, or tourist website that I could find. It is all customized to me and as long as I knew how to use it properly and to its fullest potential, I was never bogged down by trying to find things. I found it to be very efficient.

Like I said, I can understand your point of view though.

I wanted to so badly take a circle line tour also, but it was so damn cold, I didn't know if my wife would have made it. Especially since it is right on the water. Maybe next time, there is plenty that we didn't get to do.
 
5. NEVER take a taxi to/from La Guardia. All I have to say is $70. I was warned on here, but it was real cold, my wife was very tired (and pregnant) and we were both desperately hungry.

I was in New York City from Friday until Monday. I took a taxi ride from our hotel (located at Broadway and 47th street) to La Gaurdia airport and our taxi fair was a flat $40. The guy at the hotel said it's usually between $40 and $45. I think you got screwed on it.

Believe it or not, people managed to navigate NYC quite well before/without iPhone. We did - very well. We had some maps, and if in doubt, we just asked people and without fail, they were brilliantly helpfull - from the lovely young lady on the subway station near the AMNH who had a kitten in a basket she was taking home from the Vet, to the huge intimidating guy next to us waiting for the subway back from the Yankees stadium. I'd much much rather have had that experience, than known exactly where I was going with my head in a cell-phone half the time.

I don't have an iPhone and we got around NYC very well. My wife printed out many maps and circled all the places we wanted to visit. I guess the iPhone would help if you had no clue what you wanted to do.
 
I am glad to hear someone liked my Top of the Rock suggestion - it was great when we visited (in the middle of a big heatwave in September). The views from the top are amazing, and it's a much nicer environment than the Empire State thanks to glass rather than fencing and fewer people. It's also cheaper I believe.

Recommended to all.

If there was one thing which I wish I could do the next time I visit it would be to conquer my jetlag - while I was there I felt immensely tired the whole time thanks to the -5 hour difference and it was a very strange experience for me as it was the furthest I had ever travelled.
 
I am glad to hear someone liked my Top of the Rock suggestion - it was great when we visited (in the middle of a big heatwave in September). The views from the top are amazing, and it's a much nicer environment than the Empire State thanks to glass rather than fencing and fewer people. It's also cheaper I believe.

Recommended to all.

We went to the Top of the Rock and it was amazing! I like it because you can see the Empire State building. You can also get amazing pictures of Central Park. I think that was one of our favorite things we did on our trip.
 
I am glad to hear someone liked my Top of the Rock suggestion - it was great when we visited (in the middle of a big heatwave in September). The views from the top are amazing, and it's a much nicer environment than the Empire State thanks to glass rather than fencing and fewer people. It's also cheaper I believe.

Definitely was one of the best things we did. I had heard that it was better to go up there than it is to the top of the empire state building. I am a firm believer that this is true. You are right that the glass rather than fence makes a huge difference and it is just an amazing view. Probably the best of NYC.

Thanks for the suggestion, it was fantastic.

I was in New York City from Friday until Monday. I took a taxi ride from our hotel (located at Broadway and 47th street) to La Gaurdia airport and our taxi fair was a flat $40. The guy at the hotel said it's usually between $40 and $45. I think you got screwed on it.

I don't have an iPhone and we got around NYC very well. My wife printed out many maps and circled all the places we wanted to visit. I guess the iPhone would help if you had no clue what you wanted to do.

Maybe I overdid the "I COULDNT LIVE WITHOUT MY PHONE," thing, when in reality I meant "WOW MY PHONE MADE THINGS REAL EASY." I say this from the perspective that I didn't have to carry anything around with me except my phone, which had everything I needed. Instead of maps of subways and of new york and tourist destinations and bus routes and times of this and that. I just had my phone. Sure it might not be a big deal to some to carry all those things around, but why carry them around when you don't have to? It made things easy to me and I suppose you are right on the end of "we didn't know what we wanted to do." We went with specific things to do, but there was still alot of time between, before, and after those things that were open for doing things we hadn't planned on. I shouldn't have made it seem like I couldn't have made it without my phone, and made it more about how easy my phone made it for me to get around because of the apps and the GPS and everything all in my pocket. I created a google map with all the locations we wanted to visit (the equivalent of circling things on a map) and then just used that the whole time. I mapped a route from one destination to the next (well, google did it for me) and we were good to go. It took damn near no effort on my part, which was cool.
 
I'm really glad you had a very good time here, I've been a brooklyn native (18 years) and Manhattan is my second home. It truly is an awesome place to stroll around and relax (yeah it sounds crazy but I find the buzz relaxing). If only you had been here way back when the WTC was still erect (RIP). The sight from there and the Empire State are amazing on a cloudless day.
 
I'm really glad you had a very good time here, I've been a brooklyn native (18 years) and Manhattan is my second home. It truly is an awesome place to stroll around and relax (yeah it sounds crazy but I find the buzz relaxing). If only you had been here way back when the WTC was still erect (RIP). The sight from there and the Empire State are amazing on a cloudless day.

Standing at Ground Zero really did make me wish that I had had the chance to go up way to the top and look down on manhattan. I can't wait for the new ones to be finished, I will be visiting as soon as they are done.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.