Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

dobratzp

macrumors member
Original poster
This took me a few hours to figure out, but I thought I'd post this here in case anyone is having the same issue migrating to a new mac and enabling home sharing of music and videos.

I am in the process of migrating from a 2012 Mac Mini to a 2020 Mac Mini M1. The old Mac Mini was running MacOS Catalina 10.15.7 and the new Mac Mini is running the latest MacOS Ventura 13.1.

Whenever I tried to enable Settings => General => Sharing => Media Sharing, it would prompt me to log in with my Apple ID, but then never actually turn on the Home Sharing service. Some time the Family process would be not responding and the Apple ID and password dialog box would just have a spinner indefinitely waiting. In some cases, this actually prevented quitting the Settings.app and also prevented restarting the computer (had to pull the power plug multiple times in this process).

Finally, I realized that the computer needed to be "authorized"

  1. From the Music.app or TV.app, Account => Account Settings
  2. In the Apple ID summary section, next to Computer Authorizations, Deauthorize All. Note that this is a once a year option, but handy if you have devices that are authorized but you no longer have physical control over.
  3. From the Music.app or TV.app, Account => Authorizations => Authorize This Computer
More about authorizations

Once I did this, then I could go into Settings => General => Sharing => Media Sharing and successfully turn on Media Sharing. Then I could go to my Apple TV box connected to my TV and browse and play all the media in my library.

For some reason, browsing the Home Sharing Media on my iPhone doesn't work correctly (takes forever to load the names of the movies and then errors when attempting to play a movie). If we need to view media on iPhone or iPad, we plug in the device with a USB cable and transfer files from the Mac Mini.

I have all of my media stored on an external hard drive and the metadata for the music and movies are stored in the files themselves. For Music, I use X Lossless Decoder => Mp3tag. For movies, I use MakeMKV => Handbrake => Subler. Most media, I buy on physical discs, but I also have a few purchased items from the iTunes store. I re-created the Music and TV libraries by importing all the files again (note that this loses the play counts). For the iTunes store purchased, the metadata is not re-read from disc until you check the item info (Cmd + I) on each item.
 
Hey, thanks a ton. I was tearing my hair out today setting up an M2 Mac mini as a replacement iTunes server. I had the exact same problem, but had already authorized the computer. Deauthorizing and reauthorizing fixed it a treat. And now, to get out my soapbox and megaphone, here's my obligatory screaming at the top of my lungs about how ludicrous and nonsensical this behavior is from Apple.

For me to have Home Sharing access to the three separate iTunes libraries that my family needs, I have to run THREE SEPARATE ACCOUNTS on this Mac Mini simultaneously with THREE SEPARATE INSTANCES of the TV application running simultaneously. Moreover, I cannot search through this media with either Siri or the TV application, nor can I play it by using Siri commands on my HomePods or Apple TVs. I have to manually find exactly what I'm looking for, every time.

In a world where Apple still cared about local libraries, I would be able to have an iTunes library folder tree set up (as many as I wanted, in fact), and I would be able to plug that external hard drive straight into my AirPort Extreme (or other Wi-Fi router) and have the libraries be separately accessible from any device on the network also signed into that same Home Sharing account. I would also be able to, you know, use Siri to play a local file. I just do not understand why this has been forbidden.

Thank you again for the quick troubleshoot!
 
Heard good things about Plex, and I was somewhat close to going that route, but for now I'll just keep using the built-in media server.
 
I have to second Infuse - specifically over Plex. The nice thing with Infuse is it's ultimately a slick SMB client (along with other protocols), rather than a full client/server architecture, as Plex is. Less complexity, still looks like Netflix. The backend is simply a file server - nothing more. Been using Infuse for years and I have no complaints whatsoever.
 
slick SMB client (along with other protocols), rather than a full client/server architecture,

True, but my preference is for Plex. Much more powerful in display, sorting, library and other options but consequently more complex as so many options.

There are also 3rd party apps available such as Tautulli which will give you play information such as play counts, durations, most watched movies, artists etc. over the last xxx number of days. Tautulli however is a docker application which is another layer of complexity.
 
Last edited:
Spent 2 days searching internet and using ChatGPT with no luck. This was exactly what I needed to do. Home Sharing now works perfectly. Many thanks!
 
Thank you so much. I have been trying to turn on sharing forever but it just wouldn't...Until now!
 
Having the same issue in macOS 27.0. De-authorizing and re-authorizing Apple TV App and Apple Music did not fix it. I have to check "Share Media with Guests" to be able even get the toggle to stay on for Media Sharing, choosing Home Sharing alone does not keep the toggle for Media Sharing on. Even the, I can no longer see the Home Sharing library from devices on the network. I have submitted bug feedback to Apple here https://www.apple.com/feedback/
Turned Off Media Sharing and Cannot Re-Enable Unless Share Media with Guests Also Chosen in macOS 27.0
Steps to Re-Create:
1. Open Settings > General > Sharing
2. Turn Off Media Sharing which had previously been enabled WITHOUT Share media with guests
2. Attempt to Enable Media Sharing and Check Home Sharing
3. Enter the Apple Account to Home Share and enter password
4. Click Turn On Home Sharing
5. Click Done
6. Slider Returns to Off Position
7. Attempt to re-enable Media Sharing
8. With Home Sharing checked you also check Share Media with Guests and Enter same Apple Account to create Home Share again
9. Click Done
10. Media Sharing says it is on, but Home Share not appearing on other iOS devices on same Apple Account in same Wi-Fi network, but the Public Sharing library does appear.

With Share Media with Guests enabled, I can see a "Public Sharing" Library entry in the Apple TV App for the Shared Media from other Macs on the network but not the "Home Sharing" entry previously presented on other devices logged into the same Apple Account.

I have even tried the Deauthorize All Computers option from Apple Music Account Settings and reauthorizing. The only thing that allows the Media Sharing toggle to stay on is Share Media with Guests also enabled. Also, I cannot re-enable Home Sharing in my iOS 27.0 Devices either. It simply says “Unable to Turn On Home Sharing”
 
Last edited:
Having the same issue in macOS 27.0. De-authorizing and re-authorizing Apple TV App and Apple Music did not fix it. I have to check "Share Media with Guests" to be able even get the toggle to stay on for Media Sharing, choosing Home Sharing alone does not keep the toggle for Media Sharing on. Even the, I can no longer see the Home Sharing library from devices on the network. I have submitted bug feedback to Apple here https://www.apple.com/feedback/
Turned Off Media Sharing and Cannot Re-Enable Unless Share Media with Guests Also Chosen in macOS 27.0
Steps to Re-Create:
1. Open Settings > General > Sharing
2. Turn Off Media Sharing which had previously been enabled WITHOUT Share media with guests
2. Attempt to Enable Media Sharing and Check Home Sharing
3. Enter the Apple Account to Home Share and enter password
4. Click Turn On Home Sharing
5. Click Done
6. Slider Returns to Off Position
7. Attempt to re-enable Media Sharing
8. With Home Sharing checked you also check Share Media with Guests and Enter same Apple Account to create Home Share again
9. Click Done
10. Media Sharing says it is on, but Home Share not appearing on other iOS devices on same Apple Account in same Wi-Fi network, but the Public Sharing library does appear.

With Share Media with Guests enabled, I can see a "Public Sharing" Library entry in the Apple TV App for the Shared Media from other Macs on the network but not the "Home Sharing" entry previously presented on other devices logged into the same Apple Account.

I have even tried the Deauthorize All Computers option from Apple Music Account Settings and reauthorizing. The only thing that allows the Media Sharing toggle to stay on is Share Media with Guests also enabled. Also, I cannot re-enable Home Sharing in my iOS 27.0 Devices either. It simply says “Unavle to Turn On Home Sharing”
I am having this problem - I have tried setting up a Home Sharing on a Mac with 27.0.1 RC that I installed today to try it - and my Home Sharing on another Mac 27.0.1 is not working. I see it broadcasts nothing when I do dns-sd -B _home-sharing._tcp, so the problem is on the Mac not on the Apple TV side. Anyone know any more about this?
 
Having the same issue in macOS 27.0. De-authorizing and re-authorizing Apple TV App and Apple Music did not fix it. I have to check "Share Media with Guests" to be able even get the toggle to stay on for Media Sharing, choosing Home Sharing alone does not keep the toggle for Media Sharing on. Even the, I can no longer see the Home Sharing library from devices on the network. I have submitted bug feedback to Apple here https://www.apple.com/feedback/
Turned Off Media Sharing and Cannot Re-Enable Unless Share Media with Guests Also Chosen in macOS 27.0
Steps to Re-Create:
1. Open Settings > General > Sharing
2. Turn Off Media Sharing which had previously been enabled WITHOUT Share media with guests
2. Attempt to Enable Media Sharing and Check Home Sharing
3. Enter the Apple Account to Home Share and enter password
4. Click Turn On Home Sharing
5. Click Done
6. Slider Returns to Off Position
7. Attempt to re-enable Media Sharing
8. With Home Sharing checked you also check Share Media with Guests and Enter same Apple Account to create Home Share again
9. Click Done
10. Media Sharing says it is on, but Home Share not appearing on other iOS devices on same Apple Account in same Wi-Fi network, but the Public Sharing library does appear.

With Share Media with Guests enabled, I can see a "Public Sharing" Library entry in the Apple TV App for the Shared Media from other Macs on the network but not the "Home Sharing" entry previously presented on other devices logged into the same Apple Account.

I have even tried the Deauthorize All Computers option from Apple Music Account Settings and reauthorizing. The only thing that allows the Media Sharing toggle to stay on is Share Media with Guests also enabled. Also, I cannot re-enable Home Sharing in my iOS 27.0 Devices either. It simply says “Unavle to Turn On Home
The fix for my situation :

TL / DR version is my Apple Account Was Locked for Security Reasons (as if someone had attempted to login unsuccessfully multiple times maybe from the web?) but this could only be determined from the Apple Account Web UI. There was no indication on any Apple Device on my account that this was the case. Apple should really fix this in the Home Sharing UI. Basically the fix was to go to a desktop browser on a machine not on my account and go to account.apple.com click Sign In > choose “Use a Different Apple Account” and enter my Apple account info and password. From there, it stated that the Account Had Been Locked Out for Security Reasons and presented an unlock flow to send a code to my account linked Apple devices to unlock the web interface for the account. Once I did this, I was once again able to turn on Home Sharing and login at least on my iPhone in Settings > Music > Home Sharing and expect it will also work when I get back home to my Mac. This is in iOS 27.0 macOS 27.O and tvOS 27.0. Mac UI doesn’t say anything it simply fails to turn on media sharing. Apple TV simply says may be wrong Apple account or password. And iOS just says unable to turn on home sharing when it fails. The UI should provide a better error message along the lines of telling the user to check to see if their Apple Account has been locked for security reasons from the web at account.apple.com. The primary issue with this is if the user chooses to use the local Apple ID account on the trusted device it logs right in without presenting the locked account warning. So you basically have to do it from a machine that is not tied to the account or a non Safari browser to see that the account is locked.
 
  • Like
Reactions: donawalt
WOW @GDMcG you are AMAZING! This worked for me - my account reported as Locked as well! I had no idea! THANK YOU! And Home Sharing is working perfectly again! What a find!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: GDMcG
WOW @GDMcG you are AMAZING! This worked for me - my account reported as Locked as well! I had no idea! THANK YOU! And Home Sharing is working perfectly again! What a find!!!
Glad it worked for you. Yeah I am going to submit this as feedback to https://www.apple.com/feedback/ on the macOS, iPhone and Apple TV feedback forms. To me, macOS, iOS and tvOS should tell you your Apple Account has been locked for security reasons and give you the opportunity in the OS to start the unlock flow rather than forcing you to find this out for yourself via another browser. I would suggest anyone else also submit feedback as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: donawalt
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.