Thanks for the response. I rebooted into Tiger and set System Preferences > Energy Saver > Processor Performance to Highest, then launched OpenMark and reran the benchmark. I am now seeing 12700 (at 1680x1050x32). I can confirm the 9fps at 12700800, and 13fps at 9124992.
So it seems a score of 9331 is consistent for Leopard, and 12700 on Tiger. Which is not surprising. The single sphere render (on a fresh app launch) now gives ~1600fps tops, which is up from ~1400fps on Leopard.
I didn't need to display sleep to achieve this – can you confirm you get the same behavior by setting the energy saver performance to highest? Or is it only achievable with the display sleep/wake method?