Been rocking the MX2's for a while now. Still solid and sound great. May upgrade to the MX 5 when the prices start to fall.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Sony's New WH-1000XM5 Headphones vs. Apple's AirPods Max
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You do realize you can get a cable for the Airpods Max that will do that too right?
My wife paid that much and bought me a pair shortly after they first came out. Best Headphones I’ve ever used and absolutely not too heavy.
I agree, I really think that most people complaining about the weight have never owned a pair.
Once I’m paying $300+ dollars for headphones, a fully analog connection is a must. Without it, the headphones are essentially disposable; once the battery dies, they’re useless. (Not to mention the fact that they’ll throw away all the benefits of a high quality DAC)
I tried the APM in store and they sound great, but the lack of an analog connection is a dealbreaker. If the XM5s are equivalent in sound, I may be interested in upgrading from my XM4s if I catch a sale. However I may just hold on in hopes that the APM2 have a off switch and a fully analog connection.
I tried the APM in store and they sound great, but the lack of an analog connection is a dealbreaker. If the XM5s are equivalent in sound, I may be interested in upgrading from my XM4s if I catch a sale. However I may just hold on in hopes that the APM2 have a off switch and a fully analog connection.
Huge proce difference between the two. The one from Sony seems to be better.
And you can get a third party case that protects the phones too. There is no solution for not being able to turn them off, so they stupidly drain the battery fully when you leave them around, harming battery longevity.
Just as you can buy a $400 stand that allows you to adjust the Studio display (that somehow all other monitor manufacturers manage to include in their design) and you might be able to buy a third party solution that kinda lets you connect more than one computer. The power cord is still non-detacheable though.
There’s a clear pattern to what Apple is doing, and it’s not very nice.
I was at the Apple store last week to have my Apple Watch battery serviced and saw a lady buy a pair of AirPods max, so yes, there are definitely people paying full price for them even as we speak.
Also, while I am aware that Amazon sells them for ~20% off, it’s reviews like this which give me pause.
Not sure how widespread this is, but I imagine that’s how these products can sometimes be sold at a discount.
The AirPods Max are a lot heavier, but it’s because of the premium build quality build. The canopy design helps a lot as it distributes the weight evenly on the top of your head. I always thought the XM4 sounded muddy, the XM5 sounds much better. Still think the AirPods Max sounds better. For AirPods Max owner using it with iphone or ipad: to make the AirPods Max sound even better go to Settings>Accessibility>Audio/Visual>turn on Headphone Accommodation. Makes them sound almost as good as some of my best wired headphones.
The WH-1000XM5 sounds like a winner. Great sound and ANC. Sony also seems to understand that headphones you intend to wear for a few hours on a plane should be light and comfortable.
LOL when you need to make up arguments to defend the Apple product. “Naming”. Who the hell compares names?
Totally agree. At 384g the AirPods Max are a bitter pill to swallow, too uncomfortable for any extended listening. I found the review very subjective also, to say one sounds better or performs better than the other without showing any measurements doesn’t quite cut the mustard when reviewing audio equipment.
Imagine returning activated AirTagsI was at the Apple store last week to have my Apple Watch battery serviced and saw a lady buy a pair of AirPods max, so yes, there are definitely people paying full price for them even as we speak.
Also, while I am aware that Amazon sells them for ~20% off, it’s reviews like this which give me pause.
Not sure how widespread this is, but I imagine that’s how these products can sometimes be sold at a discount.
I really cannot believe that we live in a world where people are happy paying half a thousand dollars for headphones. It’s…not normal? Who is buying these? People with limitless expendable income? Seriously. Half a thousand dollars for headphones. Doesn’t anyone question what the mark-up is on these? What the margins are? Doesn’t anyone value the power of the dollar anymore?
i'm getting the sony headphones.
£379 vs £549
the airpod max might look nice but not worth the price. would only pay that much if i was a hardcore apple fan and had more money than sense.
£379 vs £549
the airpod max might look nice but not worth the price. would only pay that much if i was a hardcore apple fan and had more money than sense.
You guessed wrong. It was a friends personal unit. Sound was poor. Could be resolved with eq tuning but much of my library was lacking clarity and the soundstage was unimpressive.
Last edited:
I use my headphones everyday, during workday I even use them for more than 8 hours per day (work + gym + at home to not disturb my wife)
If you share an office with other peoples, having good ANC is a must.
So it depends on your usage, if you use headphone only during the weekend it’s hard to justify. But if you use them everyday it’s not harder to justify as a 1000$ smartphone.
Personally, I’d rather have a good headphone and an old smartphone rather than the opposite.
Fortunately, this is a very "USA" thing, as in, the country with the Upgrade-Subscribe-Abuse lifestyle!
A bit of disposable income, having met the basic near-term needs, and tendency to not think too much about long-term life planning drivee some people in so-called-first-world countries like USA to splurge on gadgets like these.
The Sony are sure nice headphone - but for someone in the Apple ecosystem it is impossible to beat the convenience of the AirPods Max.
I once had the XM3 - and the bluetooth switching was a pain in the ass.
Also the AirPod Max build quality and design are on a different level.
I once had the XM3 - and the bluetooth switching was a pain in the ass.
Also the AirPod Max build quality and design are on a different level.
I think some people's priorities are like this:
1. Name
2. Are they made of metal?
3. Will people who see me be able to tell I'm using a premium product?
4. Are they Apple?
5. ...
.
.
83. What do they sound like?
The core difference between the XM-5’s and the AirPods Max, is the XM’s are a more mature product that really has become refined over every generation. I think one of the my favorite things about the XM’s, is they really don’t feel ‘heavy’ on your head when wearing them, where as with the Max, generally feel like it’s gripping the head way too tight, which gives the vibe that they almost feel heavy on your head. For that alone, the XM’s are preferable for me. And I think it’s really important to remember no matter how ‘good’ the sound quality is, if the headphones you choose are not comfortable, you ain’t wearing them.