the doc mode layout (auto-aligned left to right top to bottom) of app icons is a good thing though. without it, you have icons floating around randomly all over the place. the doc mode layout adds a good amount of organization, a "center of gravity", if you will, that allows users to place "new or important" icons in a certain place (the top left). if they want to make this new thing (freely floating icons) an *option*, that could be ok, but I think it should be just that - an option. to *remove* the existing "doc mode layout" that's there, that actually takes away functionality, because, as it stands, the existing setup creates a nice simple organized look, where, if you want to call attention to something, you know where to put it: the top left. what they could do, is, ..it seems like people maybe want a "reverse doc mode", so that, in addition to the existing doc mode (left to right, top to bottom), they could add the ability to choose a "reverse doc mode layout" where apps would auto-align right to left, bottom to top. but to just have the sort of stock android layout, where it's just like, throwing icons all over the place kind of randomly, i don't see how that really helps. if people want it, make it an option, but don't change the existing default. if anything, add an *option* to change the size of the grid so that users can add more icons, and more widgets in the same amount of space.
The “put anywhere” should *not* the the default. An option? Maybe. Default? No. the doc mode layout (the existing setup of right to left top to bottom) where there's a center of gravity (upper left) that icons flow toward is a good thing. If they want to make “put anywhere” an option, maybe. they could offer options on the doc mode layout itself. Its good that icons flow to a certain location or "center of gravity". That makes organization *more easy*. If they want to add an option to change *where the icons flow to* or “icon flow” ‘’’
Icon flow or doc mode layout
Left to right, top to bottom - aka center of gravity - top left
They could also add
reverse doc mode - where icons flow “right to left, *bottom to top*” to appease users who want better reachability.