I'm currently using the CandyShell but what I dislike so much about it is the visibility of scratches. I've searched for other cases similar to the CandyShell but only the Commuter is on sale at Amazon. And here comes the question, does the Commuter offer the same protection of two layers? I really like the CandyShell but just can't stand all those scratches, I wanted a softer back cover like Incipio Destroyer but isn't on sale at Amazon with my gift cards. Commuter also seems too thin for the silicone so I wouldn't know unless I have the case on hand. Thanks!