So I've had a hard time deciding between SquareTrade and AppleCare and made a decision tonight (drunk, but I think it was still a good one.) AppleCare would have came out to $252 with Student Discount and Tax. It only covers failures on their part. SquareTrade costs $350, but I got a 25% discount and paid $280 total with some discounts. It covers accidental and failures. I feel like I made a good decision. My question is, has anyone delt with SquareTrade before with a messed up MBP? I know I take great care of my products, but it just feels a little better know accidental coverage is covered for another $28.