Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mac8867

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Apr 5, 2010
457
22
Saint Augustine, FL
OK, Just about a year ago, we were all raving about the Intel X25-M's and the OCZ Vertex drives... lamenting the mega $$ for the 160 GB or 250 GB models... etc etc... I broke down back then and picked up, what is now considered a paltry 300 MB/sec OCZ drive (which I love)... I had to such a hard time deciding to buy that one over the intel X25m.

Well, let me tell you, I just picked up an X25M for $180 on Amazon. I plan to remove the platter drive I have in my optical bay and go completely ssd. Mostly for power consumption reasons, truth be told.

So, the moral of the story, 300 MB/sec is still blazingly fast... and if you are OK with "last years" cadillac, great deals on SSD drives are out there to be had.
 
I've already spent almost 1000 on two SSDs past 2 weeks, I think I can stop buying these damn things :D
 
Unfortunately, you won't really see a drop in power usage with a SSD over HDD. They use very similar amounts of power, and what the SSD doesn't use itself, it uses with slightly higher CPU usage.
 
Unfortunately, you won't really see a drop in power usage with a SSD over HDD. They use very similar amounts of power, and what the SSD doesn't use itself, it uses with slightly higher CPU usage.

This is not consistent with my observations and experience (when my first platter drive failed). However, in about a week, I will be able to produce empirical measurements to prove one of us correct :D fair enough?

Of course, I admit, the 7200 RPM scorpio black is a monster power sucker, so any gain I see may be a simple result of getting better.
 
This is not consistent with my observations and experience (when my first platter drive failed). However, in about a week, I will be able to produce empirical measurements to prove one of us correct :D fair enough?

Of course, I admit, the 7200 RPM scorpio black is a monster power sucker, so any gain I see may be a simple result of getting better.

My XT Momentus HDD is 7200 RPM with 4GB of solid state in it and I've noticed an improvement in battery life from my old stock 5200 RPM HITACHI.
 
As much as I'd love to upgrade my geek cred by getting an SSD, I think the cost does not justify the performance benefit especially considering that in a few years these will probably be standard (or we'll be using tablets with cloud storage)
 
This is not consistent with my observations and experience (when my first platter drive failed). However, in about a week, I will be able to produce empirical measurements to prove one of us correct :D fair enough?

Of course, I admit, the 7200 RPM scorpio black is a monster power sucker, so any gain I see may be a simple result of getting better.

I'm with you. it depends on the SSD. the newest sandforce controllers are spec-ed to be up to 2w idle power use and upto 3w active. the x25-m and stock samsung, tosh, are less than 1w idle and active.
 
My XT Momentus HDD is 7200 RPM with 4GB of solid state in it and I've noticed an improvement in battery life from my old stock 5200 RPM HITACHI.

They seem to be too hit or miss to recommend. You either get one that works with your Mac or you have a 2.5" nightmare.
 
As much as I'd love to upgrade my geek cred by getting an SSD, I think the cost does not justify the performance benefit

Words of a person that hasn't bought one. Trust me, you buy and install an SSD you'll never look back. The performance is night and day.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.