I got the Saddle Brown. It matches my Coach wallet and looks cool with the peeks of flat black.
This may sound silly, but I thought it came a little on the orange side and kind of slippery so I've been rubbing a tiny bit of this Burt's Bees ointment into the leather about every other night. It's literally my baby girl's all natural diaper cream, but its awesome for dry skin on big people, too. The case is darkening up and looks more rich now, and feels a lot softer. It also helps smooth out any finger nail scratches.